Questions & Mysteries Has Oda Fallen off?

Has He Fallen off?

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
B

Brendan Schaub

‎
#21
#21
Zoro's role was always to sell merchandise and attract chuuni so his backstory being relegated to SBS changes nothing. But yes, Oda got worse in pretty much every aspect, from drawing and paneling to writing.
 
kumae

kumae

‎
#27
#27
More than wano I would say this past year 2022 because besides the dissapointing EOW we had some chapters during egghead where oda clearly show his preference towards luffy and no one stopped him not even his editor though don't like some things but i must admit things are getting better and if he changes some things he could redeem himself as an author
 
Zolo

Zolo

Cope Doctor
‎
#28
#28
kumae said:
More than wano I would say this past year 2022 because besides the dissapointing EOW we had some chapters during egghead where oda clearly show his preference towards luffy and no one stopped him not even his editor though don't like some things but i must admit things are getting better and if he changes some things he could redeem himself as an author
Click to expand...
Like George Lucas , when he was under control star wars were great, when he felt untouchible prequels sucked.... Oda doesnt listen to editor opinions in my opinion.... like those dudes cry once a month
 
Buusatan94

Buusatan94

‎
#30
#30
He has definitely gotten worse in his writing and storytelling skills, the quality of One Piece has declined since the timeskip.

Whole Cake Island was doing good until the Tamatebakko box explosion, it then turned into a disaster with the Wedding Cake, Katakuri fight, and nonsense with the Germa 66 and Firetanks.

But that was only the prologue to the catastrophy that would be Wano arc, this arc really wounded my passion and interest for One Piece, the Oden flashback, Udon mini-arc, characters such as Oden, Momonosuke, Yamato and Tama and the shitshow that was the raid were so bad that it made me nearly want to drop One Piece and are still affecting my judgement of Egghead right now.
 
Last edited:
F

Formerly Seth

#31
#31
Buusatan94 said:
He has definitely gotten worse in his writing and storytelling skills, the quality of One Piece has declined since the timeskip.

Whole Cake Island was doing good until the Tamatebakko box explosion, it then turned into a disaster with the Wedding Cake

But that was only the prologue to the catastrophy that would be Wano arc, this arc really wounded my passion and interest for One Piece, the Oden flashback, Udon mini-arc, characters such as Oden, Momonosuke, Yamato and Tama and the shitshow that was the raid were so bad that it made me nearly want to drop One Piece and are still affecting my judgement of Egghead right now.
Click to expand...
Just when Oda had a chance to charm people like you back he turns Vegapunk into damsel in distress, completely kills off character power ups and make Straw hats team up with fodders + time ticking bomb plot again:milaugh:

Oh and traitor:gokulaugh:
 
Buusatan94

Buusatan94

‎
#33
#33
Seth said:
It's nothing new. When you do a post time skip your fans expect a breath of fresh air, something exciting and etc...

Fishmen Island is just another damsel in distress and Straw Hats helping a country.

Hard to get excited over it.
Click to expand...
And it had the blandest and most anticlimatic battle in One Piece, until the raid on Onigashima, as well as the worst antagonists in the New Fishman Pirates and the even worse Vander Decken, who's the absolute worst antagonist and perhaps character in all of One Piece.
 
G

Gorosei Informer

#35
#35
notAfanboy said:
Wano arc was peak fiction.
We witnessed O-Tama greatness :finally:
Raizo vs Fukurokujo :queenhear:
Kinemon being split in half and not dying :catlewd:
Luffy literally saying, I wont die even if you kill me :daydream:
Queen plagiarizing Judge's tech (or Oda being creative genius) :sadgrin:
We got parallel of Mask on Mask off (flame on, flame off - King) :catpole:
Big Mom went crazy on Page1 and Ulti :catrude:
Kaido awakening was also crazy :bignews:
Big Mom Pirates actively engaged in war and Oda didnt forget about them :fransuper:
Shanks appearance was pre planned and not for Film Red promotion :fullmom:
Yamato was a female, but bathed with men :happinesspunch:

I dont know why fans hate Wano, I absolutely loved it :sanmoji:
@NikaInParis @BleakAsh @Shimotsuki Ghostly @lee33
Click to expand...
Completely agree man. I can't believe it was only 4 years long IRL, should have been twice that! Hell, forget the One Piece, Wano Peace is where its at! If only it has 2 more acts too!
Alas, Goda sama unfortunately had to cut such a beautifully written, majestic, heartfelt, thrilling, tragic, grand, epic, hilarious arc short. That's the true tragedy of Act 3 and Wano. It only lived for so long, the best things in life die young. Like Ace.

Honestly, I was not ready for such peak fiction and I am now wondering my purpose in life, after experiencing something so perfect, so complete and thus superior to anything else I've see, read and experienced and ever will in this lifetime and even a 1000 more lifetimes.

Thank you Goda. What a man you are. I get it now. You truly are the greatest author ever and you will be remembered, hailed, loved for centuries, preserved by history, never forgotten nor undestimated ever again too.

All other writers should retire and give up. Eiichiro Joyboy Oda was born different. Born to be the greatest. He was gifted with the ultimate talent from day 1. They will never dethrone him, they cannot challenge him, they can only try and fail in vain.
Not even just other mangaka but every other author out there too. Don't even try. Just give up now. Goda is supreme, untouchable and undefeatable. You posers cannot compare ever.
 
ShiShiShi

ShiShiShi

‎
#40
#40
Seth said:
It's nothing new. When you do a post time skip your fans expect a breath of fresh air, something exciting and etc...

Fishmen Island is just another damsel in distress and Straw Hats helping a country.

Hard to get excited over it.
Click to expand...
The arc was kinda boring too in my opinion. Too much running around and “Tasukete, Luffy-sama!!”

A lot of fan service happened as well, so a fair amount of panels were wasted on this “Sanji‘s Deathbed“ gag.

If Oda were to kill off Sanji someday, I wouldn’t be surprised if blood loss from a nosebleed causes it. :crazwhat:





 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top