Questions & Mysteries How do you live without logic?

[Monkey D Theories]

Kid's DF looks like a joke. All his attacks doesn't seem to hurt BM at all.

Law I agree that he seems strong but his awakening is nothing but a gamma knife. Ridiculous.

I don't know what you want. Kid's magnetism is literally just that strong, Ope ope no mi awakening is even more lethal. Combined they pushed big mom to her limits.

Why can't you just accept this than trying to refute the manga and then complaining when it doesn't adhere to your headcanon?

"Kid's DF looks like a joke"
Well obviously it isn't when its making BM cough up blood. Obviously it isn't when BM herself acknowledges Kid. Obviously it isn't when Kid is able to pin big mom to the floor and Big Mom is literally incapable of breaking out of Kid's magnetism.

This is a manga for 13 year olds. It isn't peak fiction or anything.

 

[Herrera95]

I don't know what you want. Kid's magnetism is literally just that strong, Ope ope no mi awakening is even more lethal. Combined they pushed big mom to her limits.

Why can't you just accept this than trying to refute the manga and then complaining when it doesn't adhere to your headcanon?

"Kid's DF looks like a joke"
Well obviously it isn't when its making BM cough up blood. Obviously it isn't when BM herself acknowledges Kid. Obviously it isn't when Kid is able to pin big mom to the floor and Big Mom is literally incapable of breaking out of Kid's magnetism.

This is a manga for 13 year olds. It isn't peak fiction or anything.

Kid's magnetism is strong? What he did? He don't have any on screen feat besides that fake 2v1 "win" over BM. No one is afraid of Kid's DF or showed any interested on it.
Law's DF awakening didn't showed to be more lethal than Gamma Knife. Only attack that seem really top tier is that Puncture Wille.

I'm not refuting manga. Manga shows that. Kid's and Law's attack were so useless that didn't even knocked out BM that tanked all that shit. At top they managed to broke some bones that she easily healed.

Again the target audience lie. There is enough evidence that debunks that 13 year old target audience. One Piece fandom is majority adults(18+ not necessarily 30+).

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

How do you think it is cool that Big Mom was "defeated" by Kid and Law while Kaido fought her for 3 days without defeating her(or getting defeated by).

Kid + Law = Luffy = Kaido
So it makes total sense for them to defeat her.

How do you think it is great that the Yonkos with biggest bounties which were probably the current strongest Yonkos got defeated by mere rookies while legends that drew their name into history like Roger, WB, Garp Sengoku couldn't?

The rookies are the MC and the golden generation who is paired up with the MC, therefore their grown was exponential as well + what I explained above.
WB was explained already why he didn't kick Kaido's ass.
Garp for what we know, didnt bother with any Yonko after Roger's death. And at that point, BM was weaker and Kaido was an youngster.

How do you think it makes sense for those 2 that beated a Yonko ,just like Luffy did, not being called Emperors but a fucking MC that DIDN'T beated a YC1 was already called an Emperor?

Because of the ambiguity of their victory. They 3 defeated both Yonko like a team (or that's what was implied in the newspapers).
On the other hand, they don't have the kind of influence like Luffy has and Luffy had already built some foundation for his Emperor title with the previous "Fifth Emperor" stuff.

There are many things which we can complain about, specially this arc, but these are not.

 

[SkySanji]

ZKK believer saying people live without logic

 

[Herrera95]

Kid + Law = Luffy = Kaido
So it makes total sense for them to defeat her.

Nope. Kid + Law are not equal Luffy and Luffy is not equal Kaido.
Luffy is much stronger than Kid + Law while Kaido is stronger than Luffy.

The rookies are the MC and the golden generation who is paired up with the MC, therefore their grown was exponential as well + what I explained above.
WB was explained already why he didn't kick Kaido's ass.
Garp for what we know, didnt bother with any Yonko after Roger's death. And at that point, BM was weaker and Kaido was an youngster.

Your first argument is plot armor. The MC and the new era has to surpass everyone. Then we had Shanks defending them from Greenbull "Why are you so afraid of the new era?". Debunked.

WB didn't kicked Kaido's ass because he wasn't sure he would do it without losing nakamas. Or maybe he himself wasn't sure he would beat Kaido. Is not like WB could whenever he wanted.

Garp for what we know. We don't know nothing about Garp. WTF are you saying about BM being weaker and Kaido youngster? Garp didn't beat than at any point.

Because of the ambiguity of their victory. They 3 defeated both Yonko like a team (or that's what was implied in the newspapers).
On the other hand, they don't have the kind of influence like Luffy has and Luffy had already built some foundation for his Emperor title with the previous "Fifth Emperor" stuff.

There are many things which we can complain about, specially this arc, but these are not.

Than at least Law and Kid should also be called Emperor and we would have 6 or 5(without Buggy).
Luffy became 5th Emperor by running from BM. Doesn't all 3 deserves to be Emperors by taking down 2?

And about influence... Are you joking? Strawhats were 2 years DISAPPEARED! Kid and Law were active and made enough influence. Kid in New World while Law became a Shichibukai.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Kid's magnetism is strong? What he did? He don't have any on screen feat besides that fake 2v1 "win" over BM. No one is afraid of Kid's DF or showed any interested on it.
Law's DF awakening didn't showed to be more lethal than Gamma Knife. Only attack that seem really top tier is that Puncture Wille.

I'm not refuting manga. Manga shows that. Kid's and Law's attack were so useless that didn't even knocked out BM that tanked all that shit. At top they managed to broke some bones that she easily healed.

Do you have a learning disability? I'm being serious. How are you incapable of comprehending this manga?

Spoiler

"I'll use one year of my own lifespan too..."
"It's been decades since I've felt pain like this... you runts aren't bad!! Trafalgar Law!!! Captain Kid!! The two of you and straw hat Luffy are serious about taking our thrones!!"

 

[Herrera95]

Do you have a learning disability? I'm being serious. How are you incapable of comprehending this manga?

Spoiler

"I'll use one year of my own lifespan too..."
"It's been decades since I've felt pain like this... you runts aren't bad!! Trafalgar Law!!! Captain Kid!! The two of you and straw hat Luffy are serious about taking our thrones!!"

Dude, BM beated Law and Kid but she did nothing when Kid was having headaches because of Killer vs Hawkins fight...