Lmao , I don't know what Micky wins means but i'm gonna say it regardless
Luffy vs arlong - He earned it
luffy vs Crocodile - Bullshit (blood as an subtitute to haki was shit writing , oda shouldn't have introduced a logia in the first place this early , later he went to show how cracked admiral logia are and Crocodile goes against them with legit no fear.)
Luffy vs enel - plot armour plot armour no mi
Luffy vs Moria - Nightmare luffy was good ngl.
luffy vs kaku - well deserved
Luffy vs Hordy jones - Actually good well earned
Luffy vs Doflamingo - Definately didn't deserve it , Doflamingo took damage , kept on fighting and luffy ran away mid fight like a bitch , oh wait leeme regain my haki. what MC does this.
luffy vs Katakuri - Again , first kata let him win in the end, he didn't deserve it. also Luffy ranaway mid fight again. wtf is this MC.
Luffy vs Kaido -
- Kaido fought Scabbards (+ Exhaustion)
- Kaido lifted the whole Onisghishima (+ Exhaustion )
- Kaido fought rooftop 5 (Luffy already took his first L here , he didn't run away cuz zoro was carrying him around) (+exhaustion + Damage)
- Kaido vs luffy part 1 (Luffy takes Second L) (Exhaustion+damage)
- Kaido fight Yamato (More exhaustion with Damage)
- Kaido fights luffy Part 2 (Luffy takes Third L) (More damage and Exhaution)
- Kaido vs luffy part 3 (Asspull luffy awakening recovers his haki and Heals him up)(Kaido limit IG)
No way you can call this fight luffy earned it.
In short post time skip except hordy he didn't earn single valid W for me.
If Luffy was side character like Sanji/Zoro he would get worse Treatment than Kidd. it's plot armour which saves him.
Kid got knocked out by shanks and Ship and crew destroyed and now they are at the bottom of the sea (I'm assuming they are dead but we all know oda) , Luffy was lucky enough to be saved by Law crew , had yamato to cover up for him. zoro took Hakai Damage for him.