Questions & Mysteries How much damage did Shiryu's stab through stomach of Iron Garp did?

#24
Less than the damage that made shiryu faint after garp's attack.
It's alright to argue Garp's slam was devastating, but who fainted? Shiryu was laughing and never even let go of his sword. Garp didn't move to finish him off either, and Shiryu was standing straight just fine this chapter.
Post automatically merged:

If someone cuts your leg but you where killed by a gun, did the injury lead to your death?
If missing the leg made it impossible for you to run away, take cover, fight back or whatever, then yes, even if it's not the blood loss (which would have eventually killed you anyway) was the definitive cause of death.

It's not like Aokiji KSed Shiryu, but Shiryu significantly weakened Garp.
 
#27
Can Luffy survive that stab?
Yes, he took more damage on his deathbead aka 1% health from chapter 1045-1049 back to back without falling unlike garp.

Alsso look a the damage he took in chapter 1036 and 1037, and thats in Wano alone.

We already knew he could take stabs like this as he did in the Katakuri fght and kept fighting despite that.

Luffy is just a straight up monster and endurance beast. Only Kaido is better than him at taking damage.
 
Last edited:
#34
Some good Damage but for Beats like Old Garp not enough to slow him a LOT down... if he stabbed him and pulled trough the whole Body like the smart Chad Toji from JJK against Gojo it would have been way more fatal
 
#35
At least 50%.

People comparing the stab to a shoulder stab Sanji took or stab that seemed like it took a chuck of Luffy's side out are not being serious.

Garp was stabbed directly in the gut which is one of the worst places you can be stabbed & immediately he began wobbling and continued to bleed ever since that moment. That was a filthy strike that would put most people down for good. Garp held on due to his will power and continued.
 
#37
Garp say it is nothing and able to fight . And he say it just flesh wounded . Fodder pirates are creditless because they got proven wrong many times.

‘’One piece fanbase have short memory as katakuri slab his gut yet he continue to fight like nothing .
‘They obviously never read warhammer 40K lore or other media where character can have gut slabbed able to fight like video games regularly.
 
Top