General & Others How Oda fumbled Kaido's character

#1
Oda basically turned kaido into a video game final boss who sat in his castle for 99% of the series. Instead of having kaido play a bigger role in the earlier parts of the vs yonko saga(or even before that) and showing Kaido's POV more often during act 1 and 2, the man just defeats Luffy and goes to his castle and does nothing until Luffy arrives at onigashima.

The result of this is that it becomes harder to empathize with kaido. He just seems like a heartless monster, which he is, but I think if maybe Oda paid a little more attention to his backstory, the audience would be able to better connect with Kaido.

Like kaido believes in survival of the fittest and that the strong should rule the weak. It would be nice if Oda showed us the exact moment where kaido understood this reality. Perhaps something from his childhood as a soldier in his country's wars. Oda could have even revealed yamato in act 1 or act 2 and have her tell Luffy Kaido's backstory. Alternatively, we could have seen some sort of a scene between kaido and big mom, where kaido talks about his backstory.

Ultimately, I just don't think its very fitting for one of the biggest antagonists in OP to have his backstory shoehorned into the final chapter of his fight.
 
S

Sasaki Kojirō

#2
He spent 20 years of his life knowing that JOYBOY would come to WANO to defeat him, he decided to stay in WANO for 20 years to face the plot armor head on like a true man, an absolute monster.


He enslaved the country in which he was waiting for JOYBOY to come on purpose so that JOYBOY would have a reason to fight Kaidou. It's insane the level of depression for being too strong that Kaidou reached in this manga.
 
#3
Oda basically turned kaido into a video game final boss who sat in his castle for 99% of the series. Instead of having kaido play a bigger role in the earlier parts of the vs yonko saga(or even before that) and showing Kaido's POV more often during act 1 and 2, the man just defeats Luffy and goes to his castle and does nothing until Luffy arrives at onigashima.

The result of this is that it becomes harder to empathize with kaido. He just seems like a heartless monster, which he is, but I think if maybe Oda paid a little more attention to his backstory, the audience would be able to better connect with Kaido.

Like kaido believes in survival of the fittest and that the strong should rule the weak. It would be nice if Oda showed us the exact moment where kaido understood this reality. Perhaps something from his childhood as a soldier in his country's wars. Oda could have even revealed yamato in act 1 or act 2 and have her tell Luffy Kaido's backstory. Alternatively, we could have seen some sort of a scene between kaido and big mom, where kaido talks about his backstory.

Ultimately, I just don't think its very fitting for one of the biggest antagonists in OP to have his backstory shoehorned into the final chapter of his fight.
Even as a brute, Kaido had so much potiental.

Still the best Yonkou for me
 
#6
Kaido is who I thought he was: the World's Strongest Failure. His introduction telegraphed that well.

Plus, I think a bit of fumbling was kinda the point. Yonko is just the shortened term for Not Pirate King, I think it was important to show that Kaido was clearly missing some of those traits.

A big galoot who liked hittin things really hard, Kaido stayed in his lane
 
#7
Kaido is who I thought he was: the World's Strongest Failure. His introduction telegraphed that well.

Plus, I think a bit of fumbling was kinda the point. Yonko is just the shortened term for Not Pirate King, I think it was important to show that Kaido was clearly missing some of those traits.

A big galoot who liked hittin things really hard, Kaido stayed in his lane
If that was the intention here, then why put so much effort into Big Mom's backstory?
 

Finalbeta

Hero of Albion
#8
I expected more intensity from him during the latest exchanges.

Not only a better power showing of this new mode but also some good speech, but I wonder if the latter will still come.
 
Top