Speculations I don’t think Roger and Garp fought Rocks together

[Arthur Fleck]

Here is my match up base on the chapter:

Roger + Garp vs Xebec
Whang Zhi vs Rayleigh
Linlin vs Saturn
WB + Shiki + Kaido vs God Knights + maybe Sengoku
Rest of Rocks vs Roger pirates vs Admirals + Bogard

 

[Agent31]

It’s most likely that Roger fought him in a 1 vs 1 while Garp fought the rest of the crew also I believe that this is not Prime Roger and that he goes on to be even stronger although Whitebeard and Garp are at their prime here making Roger the strongest character to date

none of the 3 were in their prime

roger didn't have ace

WB's peak is at 38 not 36 (magazine 9 or 10 idk)

garp's peak is after the mountain training for chinjao

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Here is my match up base on the chapter:

Roger + Garp vs Xebec
Whang Zhi vs Rayleigh
Linlin vs Saturn
WB + Shiki + Kaido vs God Knights + maybe Sengoku
Rest of Rocks vs Roger pirates vs Admirals + Bogard

This is the most interesting match up. As we know Linlin is Kaidos mentor of sorts. It would have been nice to see Saturn > Linlin and Kaido saving Linlin. This in turn led to her feeling indebted and giving him the Devil Fruit. 38 years later Kaido says he doesn't own Big Mom shit as they are basically even but as hard as he is he still remembers her mentoring him + giving him the fruit (power) so he decided to team up with her.

A clash with Saturn could also be part of the reason Linlin tried to build power (through alliances) and Kaido the same (through survival of the fittest). They both knew - as strong as they were - that neither could change the world as they were or without massive troops. God Valley probably opened their eyes to just how powerful and terrible the WG is and thus they became like they became as they aged.

 

[Shasha23]

It’s most likely that Roger fought him in a 1 vs 1 while Garp fought the rest of the crew also I believe that this is not Prime Roger and that he goes on to be even stronger although Whitebeard and Garp are at their prime here making Roger the strongest character to date

so Roger who was older is not in his prime and Whitebeard who is younger is in his prime?
Garp who is the same age as Roger has already peaked yet Roger is just getting started?
also Roger gets stronger but Whitebeard and Garp do not?

 

[MarineHQ]

It would be hard to explain power levels if they did 2v1 Xebec. I don't think he was stronger than prime Roger.

 

[Dragon777]

Rayleigh must’ve handled Whitebeard, Big Mom, Shiki by himself

You are forgetting Bogard

 

[MonsterKaido]

Rocks vs Roger
WB vs Garling
Shiki vs Rayliegh
BM vs Gaban
Kaido vs other roger pirates/god's knights

No idea who garp fought. Maybe initially roger and then helped roger beat rocks.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

For whatever reason it is presented as such: Roger and Garp fought Rocks.
Belief and feelings you have don't matter over facts.

 

[Croco boy]

Yeah no way its 2v1 knowing they rivalry, the way i see it its highly possible that was battle royale from 3 faction going at each other