Speculations If Luffy gets KO by Kaido again (4th time), should Zoro become the captain instead?

Should Zoro take over then?


  • Total voters
    106
#62
I figure it is kind of easy of a name change from straw hat pirates to green bandana pirates :myman:
How about pirate hunters. Captain wants to be WSS & vice captain wants to be Pirat King in piratehunters crew.
Post automatically merged:

why do people think Zoro would fare better, oda as already showed us what Zoro could do, his strongest move against kaido did minimal damage.
Zoro did more damage than luffy though. After asspulled conq haki couldnt even made kaido huffing puffing meanwhile almost fucked zoro oneshot made it. You have to accept if ashura hits on luffy he will slice into 2 piece he wont be last
 
#63
Except Luffy did the most damage on Kaido so far... which is laughable to bring this topic

also my statement is back up by non other than Kaido himself who admitted only to Luffy alone! That he enjoyed his fight with him since a long time (referring to Oden)...
Only Luffy got that praise, non of other supernova, non of scabbards
1) Luffy had 3 chances to fight Kaido. If you are talking about cumulative damage done to Kaido, sure he has done the most.
But no one single attack done to Kaido by Luffy > Ashura for sure. If Zoro had 3 rounds against Kaido, I am pretty sure Kaido would be left with 3 scars on the faces, 2 scars on the body and possibly a few more on the back. So no to your argument.

2) Kaido admitted he enjoyed fighting against Luffy? More like he enjoyed kicking Luffy's ass 3 times in a row. That must be satisfying. Dont compare Luffy's feat with Oden. Oden only had 1 shot, Luffy had 3 shots and failed all.
 
#65
1) Luffy had 3 chances to fight Kaido. If you are talking about cumulative damage done to Kaido, sure he has done the most.
But no one single attack done to Kaido by Luffy > Ashura for sure. If Zoro had 3 rounds against Kaido, I am pretty sure Kaido would be left with 3 scars on the faces, 2 scars on the body and possibly a few more on the back. So no to your argument.

2) Kaido admitted he enjoyed fighting against Luffy? More like he enjoyed kicking Luffy's ass 3 times in a row. That must be satisfying. Dont compare Luffy's feat with Oden. Oden only had 1 shot, Luffy had 3 shots and failed all.
Yeah, cumulative attacks is what I’m talking about..
As for a single attack... Oda always saves the best for last round... while Zoro with his own mouth admitted that this was his ALL OUT best attack... Luffy still has so much in his arsenal to reveal... the sheer fact that he didn’t combine gear 4th with King’s haki is already clear proof for that...

So it’s unfair to compare Zoro’s best all out attack to a “mid level attack” in Luffy’s arsenal and STILL Luffy did the best in comulative damage among all 5 supernovas

also for Kaido’s enjoyment with Luffy, you’re simply now twisting facts just to suit your agenda
 
#66
Yeah, cumulative attacks is what I’m talking about..
Luffy still has so much in his arsenal to reveal... the sheer fact that he didn’t combine gear 4th with King’s haki is already clear proof for that...

So it’s unfair to compare Zoro’s best all out attack to a “mid level attack” in Luffy’s arsenal and STILL Luffy did the best in comulative damage among all 5 supernovas
So now you argree that Ashura is the strongest attack done to Kaido, but you are doing damage control by saying that Luffy hasn't even used his strongest attacks before getting his third KO?

You are making Luffy look like the dumbest character in OP stop that.
 
#67
So now you argree that Ashura is the strongest attack done to Kaido, but you are doing damage control by saying that Luffy hasn't even used his strongest attacks before getting his third KO?

You are making Luffy look like the dumbest character in OP stop that.
Damage control?
Alright dude... since you are using that method in debate which is a clear teenage boyish method of trying to prove you’re right and the other is wrong even at the cost of ignoring clear facts... I think it should be time for adults to let the kids have their own fantasy dreams to live in until pubirty

so come back to quote my comments and debate in another 10 years, okay sweetie!
 
#68
Damage control?
Alright dude... since you are using that method in debate which is a clear teenage boyish method of trying to prove you’re right and the other is wrong even at the cost of ignoring clear facts... I think it should be time for adults to let the kids have their own fantasy dreams to live in until pubirty

so come back to quote my comments and debate in another 10 years, okay sweetie!
If you lose a debate, at least walk off gracefully and not sadistically.
Oh wait, didn't realize your name :lusalty:
I appreciate how dumb you make Luffy look by saying he hasn't used his strongest attacks against Kaido, but zoro with 30 bones has used it.
 
H

Herrera95

#73
Why? For Zoro to get Koed 10 times more before winning?
Yes. Like he did against Pica. Oh wait he actually no diffed Pica at their first encounter. But he failed a lot against Monet. Oh no, no diffed again. But Hody Jones and that other guy gave him a hard time, oh wait they didn't. But all that was after timeskip.

Remember pre-timeskip Zoro losing to Zombie Ryuuma, oh no he actually beat in first fight. But he lost to Kaku just like Luffy lost to Lucci and Blueno(don't remember right how it was) just to then fight against him again with a lot of disavantage from having Usopp with him against Jabra and Kaku and not only that but locked with him. Way different from Luffy having all advantage on his favor and still struggling and losing.


I can continue this until Morgan.
 
#74
Yes. Like he did against Pica. Oh wait he actually no diffed Pica at their first encounter. But he failed a lot against Monet. Oh no, no diffed again. But Hody Jones and that other guy gave him a hard time, oh wait they didn't. But all that was after timeskip.

Remember pre-timeskip Zoro losing to Zombie Ryuuma, oh no he actually beat in first fight. But he lost to Kaku just like Luffy lost to Lucci and Blueno(don't remember right how it was) just to then fight against him again with a lot of disavantage from having Usopp with him against Jabra and Kaku and not only that but locked with him. Way different from Luffy having all advantage on his favor and still struggling and losing.


I can continue this until Morgan.
I remember him losing to Arlong, Enel (in group fight, Moria pre-skip (in group fight and help)
Zoro cannot do the job against the major arc enemy, he falls short..
 
H

Herrera95

#76
I remember him losing to Arlong, Enel (in group fight, Moria pre-skip (in group fight and help)
Zoro cannot do the job against the major arc enemy, he falls short..
He fought Mihawk and almost die few hours before facing Arlong. He didn't know he could use the same technique que used against Mr 1 to kill Enel.
Don't remember how he fought Moria I need to see it. But he had the greatest feat in that arc by facing Kuma and damage him. Thriller Bark major enemy was Moria or Kuma?
 
#77
He fought Mihawk and almost die few hours before facing Arlong. He didn't know he could use the same technique que used against Mr 1 to kill Enel.
Don't remember how he fought Moria I need to see it. But he had the greatest feat in that arc by facing Kuma and damage him. Thriller Bark major enemy was Moria or Kuma?
He lost WITH All SHs vs Moria who controlled Oars... End of story... same with Arlong, he lost, end of story...but of course.. yeah “I don’t remember it” with Moria is a great sentence to use as always...

oh and now that you’ve mentioned Kuma and Mihawk... you reminded me of the two peope guving Zoro heavy injuries... I remember what happened next...
Arlong arc he was 90% of the arc resting for the wound..
Saboady 90% of the arc he was using the wound as excuse..
Now with Hakai from Kaido/Big Mom... I know that for majority of the arc and next one he’s about to be 90% of the time using the excuse of “oh, my 20 broken bones, I can’t do xxx”

So what I’m saying is... at least Luffy bounces back from defeat without actually taking Full arcs to heal Lol...
oh and neither Law nor Chopper have the skills to heal him fast
As for Marco, we saw the limits of his healing ability when he used it on the animal back in WB territory as he BARELY healed a bit of it just to barely walk and WARNED him not to jump or do anything rash...
And here in Onigashima we saw how the fire was limited on the people there, and he’s already shown exhaustion and needed chopper to cure the people to save some fire for himself

the idea that ANY of the 3 doctors healing Zoro magically is an extreme asspull that MIGHT HAPPEN not gonna lie, but if it did, just say goodbye to logic

At least Luffy has previously numerous times recovered really fast...he has presidence... in same arc comes back stronger and fresh ready to go with mere meat... as a rubber boy...

Zoro’s “supposed role” for the rest of this arc if we follow Logic of previous arcs and endurance feats.. his role should be to “be protected” by the rest of the crew... and stay in his cross bandage..
 
Last edited:
Top