Break Week If Robin keeps everything a secret why is she useful?

[Water1415]

In Wano she told Law a secret she didn't want to reveal to Luffy which is understandable but why not anyone else in the crew, why does Law get that special treatment from Robin when he's not her crew mate?

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Luffy - Idiot, would just tell everybody
Zoro - not clever enough to understand the picture (see 3D2Y)
Nami - might be scared
Usopp - might be scared
Sanji - security risk against women
Chopper - might be scared
Brook - he would keep the secret
Franky - he would keep the secret
Jinbei - perfect partner for Robin to tell secrets, come up with strategy

 

[Water1415]

Luffy - Idiot, would just tell everybody
Zoro - not clever enough to understand the picture (see 3D2Y)
Nami - might be scared
Usopp - might be scared
Sanji - security risk against women
Chopper - might be scared
Brook - he would keep the secret
Franky - he would keep the secret
Jinbei - perfect partner for Robin to tell secrets, come up with strategy

Luffy- " my brother is alive, thank you so much Robin"

Zoro: " ZZZZ"

Nami: "Does any of this info lead to treasure"

Usopp: "My dad's bounty is that high, wow if he can do it maybe I can too"

Sanji: "What! Stories of the All Blue existing on X Island? why are we tagging along with this loser, let's head out there immediately"

 

[Apollo]

Its because Oda hates to do reveals too fast, if Robin talks we would be getting info on Rev Army operations, Luffy's parents, Sabo...etc.

Oda doesn't want that, so he has Robin keep her mouth shut.

 

[comrade]

There is no excuse really to tell a guy from another crew but not their own.

 

[LeSSeraphim]

Luffy - Idiot, would just tell everybody
Zoro - not clever enough to understand the picture (see 3D2Y)
Nami - might be scared
Usopp - might be scared
Sanji - security risk against women
Chopper - might be scared
Brook - he would keep the secret
Franky - he would keep the secret
Jinbei - perfect partner for Robin to tell secrets, come up with strategy

Zoro not clever enough to understand this stuff gotta be a joke,you really got brainwashed by reddit eh?clown

 

[soheilhazrat]

Its because Oda hates to do reveals too fast, if Robin talks we would be getting info on Rev Army operations, Luffy's parents, Sabo...etc.

Oda doesn't want that, so he has Robin keep her mouth shut.

So bad writing

 

[JoNdule]

There is no excuse really to tell a guy from another crew but not their own.

People will defend Oda's writing tho

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Maybe she thinks they're too dumb understand,
which is insulting tbh

 

[RoronoaZorro]

Maybe because they just didn't ask. Sabo is reasonable since he wants to do it himself. For D. only Luffy is related but he doesn't care. It's also about exposition, Oda doesn't want the readers to know stuff.

 

[ShiShiShi]

For a dramatic reveal, Oda only makes her say things when it’s finally time to do so.

It’s kind of annoying. Like, she spent two years with the Revolutionary Army? How much does she know?!

 

[Afroking]

Did I miss something? What did Robin say to Law in wano?

 

[Cross_Marian]

The SHC members don’t talk with each other
It’s a new post ts rule
They’re just following their stereotypes
and somehow it’s a tradition to assemble, to do some poses and to watch the sunset or something else

 

[Croci]

They barely talk with each other

 

[vikas]

That's how it is in one piece. It's got the worse mystery, it's better to call them one time reveals... I mean literally every so called mystery has zero progress ots always revealing it. Probably because most of them turn out to be one time, e hype moment.

 

[Cruxroux]

In Wano she told Law a secret she didn't want to reveal to Luffy which is understandable but why not anyone else in the crew, why does Law get that special treatment from Robin when he's not her crew mate?

Luffy is brain dead.
Even if she tells him , it's useless. Bro will forget the next moment. Luffy isn't interested in history either.
Law is , his whole life purpose is to figure out d clan history.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Who said Nico boobs is useful?

 

[ShiShiShi]

The SHC members don’t talk with each other
It’s a new post ts rule
They’re just following their stereotypes
and somehow it’s a tradition to assemble, to do some poses and to watch the sunset or something else

Everything gathered and collectively thought “oh man what a cool sunset dude this is so sick” for 8 whole seconds

 

[Heart pirate]

Law technically Share his D clan secret with her awell. She may have just returned the favor.

There is no excuse really to tell a guy from another crew but not their own.

Law got big brains, an D energy.
Whey wouldn’t she tell him

 

[JoNdule]

Maybe because they just didn't ask. Sabo is reasonable since he wants to do it himself. For D. only Luffy is related but he doesn't care. It's also about exposition, Oda doesn't want the readers to know stuff.

Why should they ask to receive important infos if someone learns of it?
So you keep secrets when you get infos instead of telling your family or close friends stuff that concern them?