Controversial "Imu using a sword to kill Luffy isn't Hawk Eye upscale"

[Cruxroux]

Do you think Zoro can beat Luffy right now.

Absolutely.
Give me a reason how, Luffy even mamages to dodge/block, 1010 Ashura which sliced through kaidou dragon scale obviously tougher than Luffy.
When this was luffy against Fodder class slashes compared 1010 ashura.

Spoiler

 

[Fn Lucci]

Youre dodging the question lol.

Do you think Zoro can beat Luffy right now.

That question has nothing to do with anything I said. I said Luffy has swords/blades as a weakness, which is self explanatory. Throughout the series it has been consistent from Higuma up to 1188.

You responded to my post with both "Luffy was beaten by blunt damage" and "he has blunt damage immunity" lol, and now you just want a diversion from your bad argument.

 

[Fujishiro]

That question has nothing to do with anything I said. I said Luffy has swords/blades as a weakness, which is self explanatory. Throughout the series it has been consistent from Higuma up to 1188.

You responded to my post with both "Luffy was beaten by blunt damage" and "he has blunt damage immunity" lol, and now you just want a diversion from your bad argument.

Ok now Im asking you the question can you answer it or are you keep dodging lol.

 

[Fujishiro]

Absolutely.
Give me a reason how, Luffy even mamages to dodge/block, 1010 Ashura which sliced through kaidou dragon scale obviously tougher than Luffy.
When this was luffy against Fodder class slashes compared 1010 ashura.

Spoiler

I know youre a lost cause so Im not bothering with you br0. Its like saying any swordsman beats Luffy because they use a sword no matter their strength level.

 

[Cruxroux]

I know youre a lost cause so Im not bothering with you br0. Its like saying any swordsman beats Luffy because they use a sword no matter their strength level.

Zoro isn't any swordsman lol.
Idc what argument you're having with people, I answered to Can Zoro beat luffy or not.
And yet again you can't provide single vaid argument against it.
So before calling someone a lost cause, try some self introspection lmao.

 

[Fujishiro]

Zoro isn't any swordsman lol.
Idc what argument you're having with people, I answered to Can Zoro beat luffy or not.
And yet again you can't provide single vaid argument against it.
So before calling someone a lost cause, try some self introspection lmao.

Do you have Zoro and Luffy on the same tier as of this moment?

 

[Cruxroux]

Do you have Zoro and Luffy on the same tier as of this moment?

Absolutely.

And funny how you blamed him for not answering the question but you precisely did the same by not coming up with a counter argument lol. But rather a question to fit your agenda.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

I don't know who that is but they must be high IQ

His posts are good outside of mihawk ones

 

[Fujishiro]

Absolutely.

I see.

And funny how you blamed him for not answering the question but you precisely did the same by not coming up with a counter argument lol. But rather a question to fit your agenda.

When someone asks you a question you answer it first then you can expect them to address your response, not the reverse.

 

[Fn Lucci]

Absolutely.

And funny how you blamed him for not answering the question but you precisely did the same by not coming up with a counter argument lol. But rather a question to fit your agenda.

I see.



When someone asks you a question you answer it first then you can expect them to address your response, not the reverse.

It's a stupid hypothetical meant to distract from Luffy taking what seems to be an instant L this chapter from a guy who only uses swords as a secondary offense, to spite fans of a character who uses swords as his only legit offense. To pretend that Luffy isn't weaker to cutting than anything else is loony. Whoever wins x/10, I don't give a shit lol

Spoiler

 

[Fujishiro]

I don't know who that is but they must be high IQ

Lmaooo is that really you Sleepless.

 

[Cruxroux]

Do you have Zoro and Luffy on the same tier as of this moment?

And when people say Luffy is vulnerable to cut means, his df doesn't provide protection against that.
- Blunt attacks (Club, punches doesn't work)
- Heat (face Boro breath because 'guts')
- bullets? They bounce off
- electricity? Absolutely nothing

But against cut/slash attacks he can't do jackshit. Everything about Sword attack is about rip opening the defense and damaging them. No amount of haki is solving this case for Luffy.

 

[Fujishiro]

It's a stupid hypothetical meant to distract from Luffy taking what seems to be an instant L this chapter from a guy who only uses swords as a secondary offense, to spite fans of a character who uses swords as his only legit offense. To pretend that Luffy isn't weaker to cutting than anything else is loony

Spoiler

Its not a hypothetical, Luffy is weak to cutting not because its a specific weakness of his but its because he has immunity to blunt damage lol.

Thus by default cutting is his weakness.

Anyways you just wont answer my question wont you lol?

 

[Fujishiro]

And when people say Luffy is vulnerable to cut means, his df doesn't provide protection against that.
- Blunt attacks (Club, punches doesn't work)
- Heat (face Boro breath because 'guts')
- bullets? They bounce off
- electricity? Absolutely nothing

But against cut/slash attacks he can't do jackshit. Everything about Sword attack is about rip opening the defense and damaging them. No amount of haki is solving this case for Luffy.

Garp clashed with Rogers sword just fine, why cant Luffy protect himself with ACoC to solve that like him?

 

[Owl Ki]

Vista and “b b but Hawk Eye didn’t hit pre skip Goofy though!?!?” arguments in 2026

You guys must be desperate

If you actually read the post, I did in fact call it a disingenuous comparison, just like how claiming Imu using a sword is Mihawk upscale is also disingenuous.

If you're going to make disingenuous claims then people are rightfully going to hit back with disingenuous slander and Mihawk gives such folks plenty to work if you decide to enter a match of disingenuous mud slinging. Lol.

 

[Cruxroux]

Its not a hypothetical, Luffy is weak to cutting not because its a specific weakness of his but its because he has immunity to blunt damage lol.

It is a weakness my dude.
You're comparing other people saying they vulnerable to cuts as well. But they aren't vnerable to Blunt attacks, Heat and Electricity. Luffy is. So damaging him becomes more tougher.
Againt an opponent like that, Cuts is what you will call weakness.

 

[Fujishiro]

It is a weakness my dude.
You're comparing other people saying they vulnerable to cuts as well. But they aren't vnerable to Blunt attacks, Heat and Electricity. Luffy is. So damaging him becomes more tougher.
Againt an opponent like that, Cuts is what you will call weakness.

And when people say Luffy is vulnerable to cut means, his df doesn't provide protection against that.

You agree with me though right?

 

[Cruxroux]

Garp clashed with Rogers sword just fine, why cant Luffy protect himself with ACoC to solve that like him?

Because Roger doesn't have that kind of Sword cutting ability. He spams Haki through his sword.
What attack of his actually cut deep? Except for maybe the Haki mass attack?
Roger uses AdCoA (Emission)+ AdCoC.
I bet Oden attack would land on Garp. Garp Haki isn't saving him there.
Haki defense have two weakness,
- Stronger Haki (Example not needed that's canon)
- Force bigger than Haki defense
For this, Luffy got hurt by arlong teeth even while he was using haki, does that his haki is stronger than Luffy? No.
But the sharp teeth penetrated Luffy regardless.

That's why Oden would Like severaly damage Garp unlike Roger, he just doesn't have the skill for it. Or his swordsmanship works different.

Oden gave Kaidou PTSD. That's Lethality + AP of sword cuts.

'Oden two sword style is greatest there is' there no evidence to prove it otherwise.

 

[Cruxroux]

You agree with me though right?

Partially yes, Luffy shares this Weakness.
But what make it different is, this is only known weakness.

 

[StocksInMihawk]

Lmaooo is that really you Sleepless.