Chapter Discussion Is this top 5 Luffy fight?

[soheilhazrat]

kaido is done
Thoughts?

 

[Loki D. Terror]

--I will say the good parts were 1037 and 1042 ; other than these two chapters its basically them clashing and luffy attacking Kaido on roof top

--G5 vs Kaido is meh

 

[Finalbeta]

Yep this was spectacular but I expected more from Kaido once he presumably awakened his devil fruit. Or maybe he didn't at all.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

yes

luffy lucci luffy enel luffy doffy luffy kat along with this one

 

[soheilhazrat]

yes

luffy lucci luffy enel luffy doffy luffy kat along with this one

Are you not including luffy vs usopp and luffy vs sanji? Or you dont like them
Also, i think arlong vs luffy and luffy vs croco + the fights you mentioned are better

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Are you not including luffy vs usopp and luffy vs sanji? Or you dont like them
Also, i think arlong vs luffy and luffy vs croco + the fights you mentioned are better

emotional weight in both fights were great but I would hardly consider those fights
sanji luffy was also one sided


arlong vs luffy isnt better than luffy kaido imo.

 

[soheilhazrat]

emotional weight in both fights were great but I would hardly consider those fights
sanji luffy was also one sided

Fair

arlong vs luffy isnt better than luffy kaido imo

I think the finshing move of luffy is one of the best moments in the series

 

[kacarrot]

luffy vs kaido is by far the best fight in one piece, and i mean it. It has the best choreography, the most variety in terms of different types of attacks and abilities, the most creative gear transformation. Luffy vs katakuri is just katakuri wailing on luffy and then luffy gets future sight and just wins like that. Luffy vs kaido has a much better back and forth, where kaido is also able to respond with new tricks of his own

 

[Tai long]

l vs kata
l vs kaido (it is the most diverse luffys fight till date)
l vs lucci
l vs arlong
l vs enel/doffy

 

[nik87]

This and Katakuri are Luffy's worst fights. Enel one is up there too.
Too much plot armor, PIS, babysitting butchered all of them.
Luffy vs Lucci, Luffy vs Usopp and Luffy vs Wyper are his best fights.

 

[Roo]

no, this fight peaked when Luffy lost. G5 should've been a quick win

 

[Ask D question]

It definitely is one of luffy's best fights, but it's not the best imo

 

[WesMidnight]

yes, if edited down into an AMV it has the most content of any fight and the most progression uphill (and will have the best animation).
Editors should have helped Oda cut this arc down substantially to let it flow better and quicker and avoid repetition, but still it's a good fight.

 

[kacarrot]

when the anime gets to it everyone will consider it the best fight, there is so much more to work with compared to other fight. Feel like people are really overrating some of the older fights too. Luffy vs Lucci is one basic ass fight

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

1. Luffy vs Lucci
2. Luffy vs Katakuri
3. Luffy vs Doflamingo
4. Luffy vs Kaido
5. Luffy vs Crocodile

So yes, it's in top 5 Luffy's best fights.

 

[Herrera95]

Yes top 5 worst fight. But Kaido is not done.

 

[Cherry Hilk]

This is arguably One Piece best fight. It’s the plot that was far from perfect

 

[Finalbeta]

I would not label Kaido as done before I have confirmation but I truly enjoyed this clash overall.

 

[Wh1p]

Luffy vs Katakuri is hard to beat but yeah I'd say it's top 5 even above the Lucci fight and Doffy fight.

 

[Cherry Hilk]

My personal top 5 is:

Luffy vs Kaido
Luffy vs Lucci
Luffy vs Katakuri
Luffy vs Doflamingo
Luffy vs Arlong

Croco and Ener fights weren’t really that good to be honest and the others are barely worth mentioning.