Questions & Mysteries Is Xebec a good guy or a bad one for you?

[Shimotsuki Fenaker]

• Based on what we have seen so far about Xebec, do you think he is a good guy or a bad one ?

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

A Respectable "Bad Guy"

 

[moreha9685]

Neither.
He is too selfish in his pirate-y pursuits to be a "good guy" and too selfless in his GV actions to be a "bad guy".

He's a black-and-white character, with a foundation able to make him into a great character, if it weren't for the lackluster finale to his "grand plan" to usurp the usurper.

 

[Zoinks52]

Chaotic neutral. He can exhibit behaviours associated with good people but is in it for himself and is very ruthless and power- hungry.

If his plans had come to fruition, we would likely have seen more of his bad side....I can't really imagine him being a benevolent king.

But he is capable of loyalty, bravery and self sacrifice. One could even argue that his treatment of Loki is an act of honour disguised as cruelty, since he could easily have manipulated the child's admiration to force Harald's support instead of beating him down.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Inbetweener feels right. He is far less evil than CDs and imu.

 

[Rej]

I think he is a betweener too.
But conceptually leaning towards good.

 

[Djordje]

I expected him to be true madman but he isnt also I expected him to have powerful devil fruit not just basic swordsman like many others.

 

[Rumble]

He's a villain.

Just not the worst or most prolific.

 

[Yoho]

He's a bad guy in the idea that he goes against societal norms of whats considered good and legal

But he has a code and some semblance of morals and he treats everyone he cares about with dignity and respect which makes him good imo

 

[Cruxroux]

He is ok just overrated.

As a villain, I would place Doffy/Crocodile/Lucci over him.

As a hero, I would place other characters over him.

There's nothing " new " to this character.

People only love him cuz he is strong.
:hapnoel:
[automerge]1763570368[/automerge]
One who levels Islands, Kills innocent and commit terrorist acts is not a morally grey character lmao.

 

[Etemenanki]

 

[Bad English]

Rocks is a pirate with honor but he is still a pirate linked to criminal world
[automerge]1763571074[/automerge]

A Respectable "Bad Guy"

Agree

 

[Killerj]

He steal and kill, his entire team steal, kill and destroy, he is good.
The hero of brainlets.

 

[TheD.]

He wanted to change the world not destroy it,with how rough the one peice world is he seems like a Great man to me.

 

[Taolaoxitbop]

He’s a criminal, good or bad is up to you, and it doesnt matter. To me, having a family with kid but go around the sea as a pirate who known to be thugs, rapers in steading of staying with your kids is by no means a good guy. A decent man he is when he went back yo save his family though.

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

Inbetween Roger and Whitebeards cheeks

 

[Ali v2]

I like how oda portrayed Xebec character, he is a true pirate in the sense his pirating ways are closer to reality than luffy's for example, he pilage, steal, scare the shit out of normal ppl and even went as far as Killing a navy admiral, on the other hand his pirating ways are not so "pointless" as he (acknowledging his Davy name inheritance) wants to dethrone the world goverment and Imu in particular ... which is exactly how nowadays teach is, that's the climax that oda wanted, you see Xebec, you like him, then you realize Blackbeard might actually resemble Xebec personality but with a more villanous twist due to his childhood difficulties.

He is in between.

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

He's a bad guy that fought against badder guys

 

[Vanlax]

Anti-hero.

So in-betweener.

 

[Chiji_]

He’s grey, there’s certainly far more evil characters than him but he’s not necessarily a good man either