General & Others Joyboy was born 900 years ago yet his defeat was at the end of the void century

#45
Yea. That doesn't mean he can read poneglyph though. And was all books intact and recovered? Like no absolute loss?
Stella Vegapunk says to Robin that dream of Ohara was saved so according to Vegapunk there’s enough books saved that basically the entire mission of Ohara is fine.

the books obviously have the method of reading poneglyphs in them and they also have the history of Joyboy that Vegapunk talking about

That’s it. This is Oda’s intention. Oda wants us to think everything Vegapunk said was correct. And so you having an issue with this is your problem
 
#48
I didn't make the claim on the poneglyphs, but that's irrelevant anyone: VP has all the Ohara knowledge derived from the PGs, even if he can or can't read them himself.
But as far we know only Roger pirates were able to get the knowledge of Red Poneglyphs and get to Laugh Tale therefore truly knowing the whole history.
Post automatically merged:

Stella Vegapunk says to Robin that dream of Ohara was saved so according to Vegapunk there’s enough books saved that basically the entire mission of Ohara is fine.

the books obviously have the method of reading poneglyphs in them and they also have the history of Joyboy that Vegapunk talking about

That’s it. This is Oda’s intention. Oda wants us to think everything Vegapunk said was correct. And so you having an issue with this is your problem
Oda is everytime making us belive things that are later proved incorrect. Zou arc was all about that. Later betrayal plot of that Scabbard I forget the name. Vegapunk death but his mind still alive. Those are just some examples.
Post automatically merged:

Easy. He lived to like 120.
born 901 yrs ago.
died 781 yrs ago.
Where it says that
 
#53
No that's a you problem to ignore manga facts
… your the one that’s saying that a statement Vegapunk said is not true because you think Oda could just be lying that Vegapunk ever read the Ohara research

How am I the one that’s “ignoring manga facts” when you’re entire argument is that “maybe nothing anyone in the manga says or does actually happened”
 
#54
… your the one that’s saying that a statement Vegapunk said is not true because you think Oda could just be lying that Vegapunk ever read the Ohara research

How am I the one that’s “ignoring manga facts” when you’re entire argument is that “maybe nothing anyone in the manga says or does actually happened”
I'm questioning if Vegapunk truly knows the story without ever reading the Red Poneglyphs and going to Laugh Tale where Roger crew stated they finally understood the whole story.

This is all manga facts.

I'm stating how Oda misleads us to believe into something and later change that reality. This is manga fact.

I'm not saying it is a lie just because I want to. I'm giving enough evidences why this could be a lie.

What you are saying is basically that we couldn't question if Raizou was truly at Zou or not because every character but the villain said it wasn't there.
 
#55
I'm questioning if Vegapunk truly knows the story without ever reading the Red Poneglyphs
The red poneglyphs don’t have the story on them. They have the direction to laugh tale

the Rio poneglyph is the one that has the story and it’s directly shown to not be the red ones

Are you forgetting that Clover knew the story about the ancient kingdom. Where do you think he got it.

Again, your argument is that Vegapunk is lying. You’re directly saying that Oda is writing Vegapunk to lie for no apparent reason

This is a you problem
 
#56
The red poneglyphs don’t have the story on them. They have the direction to laugh tale

the Rio poneglyph is the one that has the story and it’s directly shown to not be the red ones

Are you forgetting that Clover knew the story about the ancient kingdom. Where do you think he got it.

Again, your argument is that Vegapunk is lying. You’re directly saying that Oda is writing Vegapunk to lie for no apparent reason

This is a you problem
Red Poneglyphs can have more than just directions. They may explain why laugh tale is different from example.

Rio Poneglyph is rumored to have all the story. And Rayleigh said people can have different interpretations of it.

I really skipped Robin's flashback so I don't know much about it.

Oda is always letting things open. He rarely is direct about something. Everything is up to change later on.
 
#58
So now also Robin doesn’t know what she’s talking about too.

We’re done. If your problem is that people believe what’s stated in the manga and want to discuss what stated in the manga then that’s on you.

you are not worth discussing anything with
You problem is to ignore that manga characters are proven wrong in the manga itself and what exactly words they use for it
 
#60
There are a lot of possibilities, he might have been a giant or a half giant, there are a lot of humans that live a long life, maybe he is a buccaneer or he's allies or successor continued the fight and the conflict lasted 100 years.
An other possibility is that the 100 years period is an era of conflict culminating with Joy Boy at the end of it.

Also at this point I think we all agree that Joy Boy is a nickname right? Attributed to him because of the nika awakening
 
Top