Character Discussion Just another Yamato4nakama theory

#41
I say my second part because you said it's far fetched

The connection is not small. The percentage of our answer is true to "which cat is which SHs" is what is small.

Not really. Feel free to post it or not. I have my own guess too tho



Okay so far I consider that Nekomamushi represents Sunny, as Sunny is a lion; Nekomamushi is a cat, which means 1 family of feline. Nekomamushi is also being depicted bigger than other cats.

Next, cat number 1, 8, 11, 12 don’t have whiskers. Therefore they might represent female crew. So far the female crew are Nami & Robin. Cat number 1 might be Nami, since she sometimes relaxing herself, not to mention that her position on top of Nekomamushi might as well be a hint that she’s usually bossing around the crew. Cat number 12 might be Robin, because of prominent bigger eye size, and the darker part shapes like hair; which in Robin’s case because of her black hair. Cat number 11 might be Yamato, because of its position is either falling / climbing. So far Yamato’s been busy protecting Momo, and falls & climbs back on Onigashima. Not to mention Cat number 11’s stripes, similar to how Yamato’s nio-daisuki is white-purple stripes.

and we can go to other cats. Cat number 2 is Zoro, because of its band on its belly. Cat number 3 is Franky, because of its glasses and it’s wearing pants. Cat number 4 is Brook; again because of its glasses & its gentleman styled-clothes. Cat number 5 is Chopper but in reverse, as we all know Chopper’s weird hiding posture. Cat number 6 is Sanji, as his 1 eye is closed and the other is not; similar like how Sanji’s hair covers one of his eyes. Cat 7 is Luffy, because it sleeps in front of Nekomamushi which represents Sunny, and Luffy’s spot is on Sunny’s head usually. Cat number 9 is Usopp, as he’s standing on higher ground looking at other spot in far away suggesting how Usopp’s role as a sharpshooter. Cat number 10 is Jinbe.

so the unknown cat is number 8 & 13 which are the future nakamas; 1 female & 1 male. Hope this won’t be considered too far-fetched, though.
 
#42
so the unknown cat is number 8 & 13 which are the future nakamas; 1 female & 1 male. Hope this won’t be considered too far-fetched, though.
Okay. Anw. Im sorry about my earlier post. Maybe my word is not really delivered

What I want to say is, this cover itself has high connection to reveal all crew. But the other people argument that is trying to make connection is questionable (high or low based on their own answer)
Post automatically merged:



Okay so far I consider that Nekomamushi represents Sunny, as Sunny is a lion; Nekomamushi is a cat, which means 1 family of feline. Nekomamushi is also being depicted bigger than other cats.

Next, cat number 1, 8, 11, 12 don’t have whiskers. Therefore they might represent female crew. So far the female crew are Nami & Robin. Cat number 1 might be Nami, since she sometimes relaxing herself, not to mention that her position on top of Nekomamushi might as well be a hint that she’s usually bossing around the crew. Cat number 12 might be Robin, because of prominent bigger eye size, and the darker part shapes like hair; which in Robin’s case because of her black hair. Cat number 11 might be Yamato, because of its position is either falling / climbing. So far Yamato’s been busy protecting Momo, and falls & climbs back on Onigashima. Not to mention Cat number 11’s stripes, similar to how Yamato’s nio-daisuki is white-purple stripes.

and we can go to other cats. Cat number 2 is Zoro, because of its band on its belly. Cat number 3 is Franky, because of its glasses and it’s wearing pants. Cat number 4 is Brook; again because of its glasses & its gentleman styled-clothes. Cat number 5 is Chopper but in reverse, as we all know Chopper’s weird hiding posture. Cat number 6 is Sanji, as his 1 eye is closed and the other is not; similar like how Sanji’s hair covers one of his eyes. Cat 7 is Luffy, because it sleeps in front of Nekomamushi which represents Sunny, and Luffy’s spot is on Sunny’s head usually. Cat number 9 is Usopp, as he’s standing on higher ground looking at other spot in far away suggesting how Usopp’s role as a sharpshooter. Cat number 10 is Jinbe.

so the unknown cat is number 8 & 13 which are the future nakamas; 1 female & 1 male. Hope this won’t be considered too far-fetched, though.
Sur.e agree on most of your answer. But I think robin is number 13. The unknown cats are number 8, 11, 12. But I think 12 is a female cat
 
Last edited:
#43
Okay. Anw. Im sorry about my earlier post. Maybe my word is not really delivered

What I want to say is, this cover itself has high connection to reveal all crew. But the other people argument that is trying to make connection is questionable (high or low based on their own answer)
No worries at all. It’s written, therefore miscommunication is common. I actually have been thinking about this cat cover, but because most of the cats are too vague to be theorized, I immediately omit the idea to connect it with possible total nakamas.
Post automatically merged:

Okay. Anw. Im sorry about my earlier post. Maybe my word is not really delivered

What I want to say is, this cover itself has high connection to reveal all crew. But the other people argument that is trying to make connection is questionable (high or low based on their own answer)
Post automatically merged:


Sur.e agree on most of your answer. But I think robin is number 13. The unknown cats are number 8, 11, 12. But I think 12 is a female cat
I suggested Robin is 12 because of no whiskers. 1, 8, 11, 12 have no whiskers, since we all know that whiskers might be considered mustache/hair facial feature on male, which grows because of testosterone; may hint that the other cats are male. Again, because cat 12 has darker part of fur on its back + it has no whiskers which in my theory, is a female. The darker part somehow looks similar with post-timeskip Robin’s hairstyle in Sabaody. And also its big eyes hint that it might represent Robin. Cat 13 has whiskers which may hint it’s male.
 
Last edited:
Top