Versus Battle Madara or Kaido.Who is the better Villain
- Thread starter Steven
- Start date
Kaidou had the best introduction, the way he one shot Luffy. He was very good until Oden flashback happened. Oda did a dirty in portrayal of Oden empty wank and even that he didn't justify properly. That flashback is the start of Kaidou downfall. He had some savage moments later but scabbards doing some kinda damage and not able to put down anyone except Luffy reduced his threat even more. All I am waiting is just some food backstory from him and that will repair his character to some extent. So, I will hold until the end of wano.
Madara is you know just can't. He is just overpowered dude with convenient plot power from Kishimoto who cornered himself with ridiculous overpowered character without writing a respectable defeat. Orochimaru is the best villain followed by pain. Madara is just an author backed badass dude.
Madara is you know just can't. He is just overpowered dude with convenient plot power from Kishimoto who cornered himself with ridiculous overpowered character without writing a respectable defeat. Orochimaru is the best villain followed by pain. Madara is just an author backed badass dude.
Madara had a badass introduction but then kind of became one dimensional for me -- He simply is -- I am this powerful , I am god you are nothing but shit again and again
Looking objectively kaido is lacking depth for now which he will get soon through flashback and his reason of choosing wano ;
Looking objectively kaido is lacking depth for now which he will get soon through flashback and his reason of choosing wano ;
Last edited:
Kaido is the second worst antagonist in One Piece. Madara was a great antagonist pre-Kaguya. Dropping a meteor on the alliance, humiliating the 5 Kages, breaking Edo Tensei, and preventing Tobi from reviving everyone and instead forcing Tobi to revive Madara instead were all great scenes. I also enjoyed his flashback as well.
Kaido is a 1/10 antagonist and Madara is a 7/10 antagonist.
Kaido is a 1/10 antagonist and Madara is a 7/10 antagonist.
Kaido isn't that interesting as a villain rn. If Oda gives us more information about his past and his true motives, he might be more interesting and possibly become a top tier villain (I doubt it but who knows). Madara was worked enough to be at least considered an interesting villain imo. So, I would say Madara is a better villain until we get to know more about Kaido.
Madara but not by miles
But Madara wasn’t a great villain. I don’t think he is even Top 5 villain in Naruto : Orochimaru, Pain, Zabuza, Akatsuki as a whole, Danzo, Gaara, Itachi etc etc were much better than him.
Madara end wasn’t that great even his fights were often one side stomps etc. It’s not his fault but the power inflation became ridiculous. Even his personality wasn’t that great or his ideals.
But still a bit better than Kaido who is here only to club everyone without more depth
(but let’s wait Kaido end to really judge)
But Madara wasn’t a great villain. I don’t think he is even Top 5 villain in Naruto : Orochimaru, Pain, Zabuza, Akatsuki as a whole, Danzo, Gaara, Itachi etc etc were much better than him.
Madara end wasn’t that great even his fights were often one side stomps etc. It’s not his fault but the power inflation became ridiculous. Even his personality wasn’t that great or his ideals.
But still a bit better than Kaido who is here only to club everyone without more depth
(but let’s wait Kaido end to really judge)
tbf we've only started getting glimpses of kaido's personality, ideals and philosophy in the onigashima battle.
the rocks backstory will hit differently when we see how kaido's past shaped his world view, philosophy and dream.
i agree with you that we need to wait until his full story is revealed before we judge.
the rocks backstory will hit differently when we see how kaido's past shaped his world view, philosophy and dream.
i agree with you that we need to wait until his full story is revealed before we judge.
both had great intros but the hype and build up to Madara was just paid off and just made you go...
One comes in from the sky 10, 000m and you u had SN's shocked.. beloved death is to him.
the Other steps out of a rusty grave and had the whole shinobi army sweatin..
The kage went
Naruto went
the army went
Saints praying went
and then Madara went...
Post automatically merged:
One comes in from the sky 10, 000m and you u had SN's shocked.. beloved death is to him.
the Other steps out of a rusty grave and had the whole shinobi army sweatin..
The kage went
Naruto went
the army went
Saints praying went
and then Madara went...
Last edited:
both had great intros but the hype and build up to Madara was just paid off and just made you go...
One comes in from the sky 10, 000m and you u had SN's shocked.. beloved death is to him.
the Other steps out of a rusty grave and had the whole shinobi army sweatin..
The kage went
Naruto went
the army went
Saints praying went
and then Madara went...
Post automatically merged:
One comes in from the sky 10, 000m and you u had SN's shocked.. beloved death is to him.
the Other steps out of a rusty grave and had the whole shinobi army sweatin..
The kage went
Naruto went
the army went
Saints praying went
and then Madara went...
