Controversial Man of Steel vs Superman

[HerreraIsBack]

 

[RayanOO]

Some things are done better in Superman but overall Man of Steel is better

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Some things are done better in Superman but overall Man of Steel is better

100% agreed.

 

[nik87]

Man of Steel, any time, any day.

 

[Bullet]

Man of steel.
The new superman is a more accurate and likeable version but the movie is flawed.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Superman mogs.

 

[kekaro]

Man of Steel
The superman movie gets alot of things right about him but James Gunn wants to do his wacky stuff and other characters instead of a superman movie

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Superman was the better Superman movie. It did a better job of encapsulating the heart of the character.

Man of steel had a lot of cool cinematography, but the movie is actively hurt because it’s supposed to be about Superman, and despite Henry Cavills acting, it didn’t properly display the character.

 

[Sentinel]

Man of Steel takes it.

The new Superman isn't bad but man, he simply cannot beat Henry Cavill. Imo Henry Cavill is THE superman just like how Christian Bale was THE batman.

Also, I gave the movie a chance and some scenes were accurat and good but I just didn't like the narrative at all. Scene switch happened so randomly and I often didn't understand what happened.

 

[Doggo]

Y'all takes are wild.

 

[Sentinel]

Y'all takes are wild.

Pro new Superman or Man of Steel?

 

[Doggo]

Pro new Superman or Man of Steel?

2025 and people are still coping about Man of Steel.
It was an okay movie.
Cavill's acting is not that good, but he does a good job with simple roles.
It's a terrible Superman movie.
Zod hard carries it.
Snyder is not a movie director. He's a videoclip director.

 

[kekaro]

2025 and people are still coping about Man of Steel.
It was an okay movie.
Cavill's acting is not that good, but he does a good job with simple roles.
It's a terrible Superman movie.
Zod hard carries it.
Snyder is not a movie director. He's a videoclip director.

Not wrong doesnt make the James Gunn vomit a better movie tho

 

[Sentinel]

2025 and people are still coping about Man of Steel.
It was an okay movie.
Cavill's acting is not that good, but he does a good job with simple roles.
It's a terrible Superman movie.
Zod hard carries it.
Snyder is not a movie director. He's a videoclip director.

I love Man of Steel, so I can't agree to a lot of this post.
However, Zod hard carries indeed lol.

 

[ZenZu]

Man is steel is as mid as it gets. And that's being generous. Snyder fans act like it was the Dark Knight.

 

[Doggo]

I love Man of Steel, so I can't agree to a lot of this post.
However, Zod hard carries indeed lol.

I love Man of Steel as well.
But I can totally point out how bad it is.
It's okay to like bad movies, btw.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Superman was the better Superman movie. It did a better job of encapsulating the heart of the character.

Man of steel had a lot of cool cinematography, but the movie is actively hurt because it’s supposed to be about Superman, and despite Henry Cavills acting, it didn’t properly display the character.

Just because the dark theme is not superman?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I love Man of Steel as well.
But I can totally point out how bad it is.
It's okay to like bad movies, btw.

Hey it’s a masterpiece compared to Batman V Superman…

 

[Sentinel]

I love Man of Steel as well.
But I can totally point out how bad it is.
It's okay to like bad movies, btw.

I honestly loved how Snyder made Superman more humane, like struggling with his daily life, showing real emotions, doubting himself.
The action scenes were also great about this movie and I liked the animations and choreography.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Just because the dark theme is not superman?

It’s not just the dark theme.
1. the death of Pa Kent was so stupid. Pa telling Superman to let him die is just so counter to both characters
2. The battle of Zod felt like I was watching a disaster movie where the story’s about having to survive when Superman comics constantly are about Superman saving anyone and everyone and actively limits collateral damage.
3. The constant “god imagery” is not Superman. He’s not a god on earth and never was meant to be.