Who will be the next SH?


  • Total voters
    113
You provided a sur interpretation. Yamato never said that she idn't want to stay in Wano, it was a choice. Saying "I would love to come with you" and saying "I don't want to stay" are NOT the same things.
That alone, no it doesn't show that. But you're intentionally ignoring the other 3 points I made that prove what I'm saying.

To be perfectly honest, what the panel means is obvious to everyone. It was never a debate if Yamato really wanted to stay in Wano or not, and I feel a little silly breaking it down to a kindergarten level for you to understand anyway. Talking to you really is like arguing with a brick wall. All you do is ignore what I say and reiterate your headcannon for the tenth time. Since you're only interested in making strawmen and aren't willing to reread my post to see what I actually said, please stop responding to me.
 
That alone, no it doesn't show that. But you're intentionally ignoring the other 3 points I made that prove what I'm saying. Since you're only interested in making strawmen and aren't willing to reread my post to see what I actually said, please stop responding to me.
You still haven't given me the panel. I need that and I will indeed stop speaking to you until you give me that panel.
 
You still haven't given me the panel. I need that and I will indeed stop speaking to you until you give me that panel.
I gave you the panel and a detailed explanation. You zeroed in on one line in the panel and one line in my post, and ignored the rest. For the last time, reread my earlier post and respond to all of it, or leave me alone. I'm not interested in your strawman.
 
I gave you the panel and a detailed explanation. You zeroed in on one line in the panel and one line in my post, and ignored the rest. For the last time, reread my earlier post and respond to all of it, or leave me alone. I'm not interested in your strawman.
My straw man ? Are you for real ?? I did no such things. I asked you one thing: to show me the panel where Yamato says that she doesn't want to stay in Wano. Simple.

You shouldn't have to give me "explanation", just the panel as you were saying that Yamato (you own word) said that. Oda is precise when he makes a character talk. There is no trace of Yamato "not wanting to stay on Wano" but we KNOW that it was her choice because of the panel, just like it was the choice of Vivi to stay back. I know that you don't want to be wrong but put down your ego for once and accept the reality.

The reality is simple: Yamato stayed on Wano, she had her own reason. I predicted those reason earlier because of a very specific set of storytelling tools and all of that is become of FREEDOM. Simple.

Now either you accept that or like you said, leave me alone. I'm done with the name calling.
 
My straw man ? Are you for real ?? I did no such things. I asked you one thing: to show me the panel where Yamato says that she doesn't want to stay in Wano. Simple.

You shouldn't have to give me "explanation", just the panel as you were saying that Yamato (you own word) said that. Oda is precise when he makes a character talk. There is no trace of Yamato "not wanting to stay on Wano" but we KNOW that it was her choice because of the panel, just like it was the choice of Vivi to stay back. I know that you don't want to be wrong but put down your ego for once and accept the reality.

The reality is simple: Yamato stayed on Wano, she had her own reason. I predicted those reason earlier because of a very specific set of storytelling tools and all of that is become of FREEDOM. Simple.

Now either you accept that or like you said, leave me alone. I'm done with the name calling.
Yes, strawman, because you took one point of my whole post and claimed it was my entire argument. That's a classic example of a strawman. I don't have time to deal with your nonsense these days, so I'm not going to engage with you anymore.
 
I'd like to bring up Boa Hancock. I don't believe she has a chance, but she's in an interesting position.

She is hunted by the WG and BB, and says it's too dangerous for her to stay on Amazon Lily.

Amazon Lily needs yonko protection like fishman island

She specifically said she needs to go find Luffy.

At the same time, Rayleigh showed up with Luffy's vivre card.

Shakky also showed up and was revealed as the former empress, so she can easily take over for Hancock.

She has none of the requirements to join the crew, but I don't see how her story could go any other way. What do ya'll think about Hancock? Does she have a chance? What will she do if she doesn't join Luffy?
 
Top