General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Warback]

I don't know what's sadder. Carrot and Yamato being added back in the poll or the fact people are voting for them after the dumpster fire arc

I mean think about the fact there's people who still think Smoker is going to join.


Wano might have been a shit arc but there's characters in this poll that are straight delusional headcanon or L collectors

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

I don't know what's sadder. Carrot and Yamato being added back in the poll or the fact people are voting for them after the dumpster fire arc

Some people just can’t move on

I thought the whole point of making a new nakama thread was to cleanse ourselves from the Carrot and Yamato shit.

 

[CoC: Color of Clowns]

Some people just can’t move on

It's more like I don't trust Oda. Oda loves trolling his audience and pulling weird shit. Sabo's entire existence is weird as hell, even if I like him as a character.

As long as a character still has interest in sailing with the crew, I keep them on the list. The reason Yamato, Carrot, Vivi, Tama, Momo, and Kinemon should still be considered as Nakama, is because the Straw Hats have sailed with them and treated them like Nakama. Out of that group, only Carrot hasn't been accepted into the actual crew.

Luffy was pissed as hell that Vivi and Yamato had to stay behind, and wants Momo and Kinemon to join later.

Vivi, Yamato, Tama, Momo, and Kinemon all have official approval from Luffy to join his crew at some point, whether people like it or not. They are all potential candidates.

If Luffy wants you to join the crew at the end of an arc, you're a Straw Hat, to me. That's my criteria. Only Carrot exists in this weird gray area.

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

everyone should be removed besides caribou

Fixed that for ya :cheers:

 

[Momonosuke]

Once the SHs arrive at Wano to face the invaders, Yamato is already killed...

Unless Yamato and the others escape riding their pet flying dragon man child shogun...

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

If Luffy wants you to join the crew at the end of an arc, you're a Straw Hat, to me. That's my criteria. Only Carrot exists in this weird gray area.

My criteria to join is if they snuck onto the Thousand Sunny in a Barrel and heard Luffy’s real dream. Only one person has done this and it ain’t Carrot.

 

[Momonosuke]

While Yamato is certainly not joining, I agree she makes way more sense than Sabo or Bellamy. This is truly a weird ass poll. Raizo is just a joke option though.

It seems like the entire poll was a joke until they updated it. Also between Yamato claiming she was going to join and luffy wanting her to come along, if they're forced to flee wano it's still possible but I'm not expecting it, I just find it more likely than anyone listed in the poll other than vegapunk who we still don't know enough about to make that call

 

[CoC: Color of Clowns]

My criteria to join is if they snuck onto the Thousand Sunny in a Barrel and heard Luffy’s real dream. Only one person has done this and it ain’t Carrot.

Unless Carrot was actually in the barrel alongside Caribou, and heard Luffy's dream using her enhanced rabbit hearing, while Caribou didn't...

Still, I think Carrot is back on Zou, or is stuck in Wano.

Excited to see what Caribou does in this arc, the man is always unpredictable.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Some people just can’t move on

I thought the whole point of making a new nakama thread was to cleanse ourselves from the Carrot and Yamato shit.

I think it was too early to start a new one

 

[Peppercore]

i aint moving on till i get an onscreen acceptance of queendom frm the bun. bffr about that one

 

[Warback]

Unless Carrot was actually in the barrel alongside Caribou, and heard Luffy's dream using her enhanced rabbit hearing, while Caribou didn't...

Still, I think Carrot is back on Zou, or is stuck in Wano.

Excited to see what Caribou does in this arc, the man is always unpredictable.

Stuck on Wano lol, that would be funny, we didn't even see Zunesha move away.




Also who legitamely thinks Sabo or Boa are actually joining? It's 100x more delusional than any Carrot/Yamato cope

 

[CoC: Color of Clowns]

Stuck on Wano lol, that would be funny, we didn't even see Zunesha move away.




Also who legitamely thinks Sabo or Boa are actually joining? It's 100x more delusional than any Carrot/Yamato cope

Zunesha is supposed to open Wano's borders, so it should be nearby, and the Mink should have Vivre Cards for it, I think.

But, it's possible Zou gets attacked for its Ponyglyph.

Despite all the Straw Hats wins, they left Zou, Wano, and Fishman Island really vulnerable.

Yeah, no way Sabo or Boa fully join. They have their own crews/groups, and have never displayed interest in joining.

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

Unless Carrot was actually in the barrel alongside Caribou, and heard Luffy's dream using her enhanced rabbit hearing, while Caribou didn't...

Still, I think Carrot is back on Zou, or is stuck in Wano.

Excited to see what Caribou does in this arc, the man is always unpredictable.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

the honest truth is
no one else is joining either the crew or the grand fleet


luffy has told his dream to all nine crewmembers present
and the GF has been set, with all 8 captains integrated at the same time ,officially capped at 5600 in number.

 

[KonyaruIchi]

I mean think about the fact there's people who still think Smoker is going to join.


Wano might have been a shit arc but there's characters in this poll that are straight delusional headcanon or L collectors

Oh no I agree that there's a lot of picks in this that are complete delusion at this point, but considering the fisaco of the previous arc with both of them and the fact this new thread was supposed to exist to cleanse us for the shitstorm both Yamabros and Carrotbros caused, I find it weird to see them added back in.

The fact they're being voted for is just the cherry on top honestly

 

[Rootbeer]

This thread is now mostly sore orange vegetables..

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Unless Yamato and the others escape riding their pet flying dragon man child shogun...

Not possible... Yamato will stay in Wano no matter what...

 

[Sigran101]

Stuck on Wano lol, that would be funny, we didn't even see Zunesha move away.




Also who legitamely thinks Sabo or Boa are actually joining? It's 100x more delusional than any Carrot/Yamato cope

Sabo is ridiculous, but Boa is completely reasonable.

 

[Warback]

Sabo is ridiculous, but Boa is completely reasonable.

She has no role and the opposite narrative reason to abadon her kingdom

 

[thedarkdragon11]

She has no role and the opposite narrative reason to abadon her kingdom

Luffy doesn't care about roles... What would be Gaimon's role should he accepted the invitation? Or the zombie tree? Or Yamato?