General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
Hell yeah, welcome brother! Glad to have you on board:cheers: out of curiousity, why do you see Stussy not having a moral pillar yet (with hints of it happening soon) as more of a problem than Bonney not having a dream or a role with no hints of either occuring in the future?
You made the right choice, my new friend
Join the movement and cast your vote! Let's make this the biggest theory in One Piece
@Devilbat i‘ve come to support Stussy for Nakama 
Join the movement and cast your vote! Let's make this the biggest theory in One PieceI'm on the side of the next crewmate. Which means that my point of view only evolves with the events of the story. 
Actually both would be blocked by the problematic of their roles on the ship and their purpose, that's why I keep "no one" at the 0. position. But playing is fun. And I don't see that as more of a problem. The roles and the driving forces (dreams+2 needs) are in my book only important to consider on the second revision of the characters's potentiel.
In short, once we are sure that the character fits the 7 foundamental rules, then we can move on the things I noted as the 12 pillars:
https://carrotfornakama.wixsite.com/anyonefornakama/post/twelve-pillars-introduction
I specifically divided the 7 rules and the twelves pillars to make it more easy to sort each characters in the story and find good candidate. (at the time those characters where Marco / Tama / Momo / Yamato and Carrot and to make it easier to choose the best candidate among the remainers. Also I divided it that way because I think you can't write a strawhat without a moral Pillar, but you could write one without a dream and a role on the crew.
A dream/goal is just a long time purpose, but if the characterization surrounding the moral Pillar is strong enough, the character should get at least a short time purpose (For Bonney it would be to rescue her father) which is enough for a great characterization. Same, I could see a strawhat without a role on the ship. Even if that's unlikely.
That's why the moral pillar is foundamental while the driving forces are secondary. (for me at least)
Actually both would be blocked by the problematic of their roles on the ship and their purpose, that's why I keep "no one" at the 0. position. But playing is fun. And I don't see that as more of a problem. The roles and the driving forces (dreams+2 needs) are in my book only important to consider on the second revision of the characters's potentiel.
In short, once we are sure that the character fits the 7 foundamental rules, then we can move on the things I noted as the 12 pillars:
https://carrotfornakama.wixsite.com/anyonefornakama/post/twelve-pillars-introduction
I specifically divided the 7 rules and the twelves pillars to make it more easy to sort each characters in the story and find good candidate. (at the time those characters where Marco / Tama / Momo / Yamato and Carrot and to make it easier to choose the best candidate among the remainers. Also I divided it that way because I think you can't write a strawhat without a moral Pillar, but you could write one without a dream and a role on the crew.
A dream/goal is just a long time purpose, but if the characterization surrounding the moral Pillar is strong enough, the character should get at least a short time purpose (For Bonney it would be to rescue her father) which is enough for a great characterization. Same, I could see a strawhat without a role on the ship. Even if that's unlikely.
That's why the moral pillar is foundamental while the driving forces are secondary. (for me at least)
So based on your seven rules:
1. Stussy is alive - Check
2. Stussy is very relevant to the storyline - Check
3. Stussy has shown a unique fighting style - Check
4. Stussy is being kicked out of her home and no longer with CP - Check
5. Stussy is friendly, she has not met the wings and Brook as an ally - Check
6. Stussy may not be looking towards adventure now, however, vegapunk mentioned Stussy ending up in CP0 was coincidental and not planned so she joined This group of her own accord. When we see why, this question will likely get a check
7. Stussy still has yet shown a moral pillar, however, Vegapunk winning peace prizes and searching towards world peace while Stussy has remained loyal in the past twenty years kinda pushes that Stussy is likely a very Moral person.
so currently she’s 5/7 with strong potential for 7/7 when we get any info on her backstory.
1. Stussy is alive - Check
2. Stussy is very relevant to the storyline - Check
3. Stussy has shown a unique fighting style - Check
4. Stussy is being kicked out of her home and no longer with CP - Check
5. Stussy is friendly, she has not met the wings and Brook as an ally - Check
6. Stussy may not be looking towards adventure now, however, vegapunk mentioned Stussy ending up in CP0 was coincidental and not planned so she joined This group of her own accord. When we see why, this question will likely get a check
7. Stussy still has yet shown a moral pillar, however, Vegapunk winning peace prizes and searching towards world peace while Stussy has remained loyal in the past twenty years kinda pushes that Stussy is likely a very Moral person.
so currently she’s 5/7 with strong potential for 7/7 when we get any info on her backstory.
Indeed.. there is a hint in the chapter that shows that Stussy going into the governement was not the wish of Vegapunk. It could mean that there is a story there. I don't know, we need to know more about Stussy to really move her up the ladder.
But it's definitely possible looking at the way Oda is directing the story Parent/child Clone/creators.
But it's definitely possible looking at the way Oda is directing the story Parent/child Clone/creators.