Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1025 Spoilers Discussion
- Thread starter AL sama
- Start date
- Tags #perona>yamato #ulti is best girl #yamato4nakama black maria best girl black maria>yamato have you seen x drake king>yamato laido luffy best mc luffy>kaido momo>kaido sanji best wing skk ulti number 1 ulti>yamato wanji bodies your fav where is x drake x drake is missing yamato hype zoro bodies your fav
- Status
I stand by my stance. If you don't ban me, I'll offer a completely original (not copied) version of the spoiler summary that correctly adresses Yamato as girl next issue.
If you want to ban me though go ahead.
And let me be perfectly clear: I offered an alternative version of those spoilers (clearly still visible for everyone to be redon's work), just changing the pronouns the way the official vivre-cards, promotion etc. tell us to address her.
It was redon who then threatened others over something so insignificant, not me.
So if I get banned over a summary that correctly adresses Yamato as female, so be it.
It's really ironic that you're getting banned for actually correct gendering here though!
If you want to ban me though go ahead.
And let me be perfectly clear: I offered an alternative version of those spoilers (clearly still visible for everyone to be redon's work), just changing the pronouns the way the official vivre-cards, promotion etc. tell us to address her.
It was redon who then threatened others over something so insignificant, not me.
So if I get banned over a summary that correctly adresses Yamato as female, so be it.
It's really ironic that you're getting banned for actually correct gendering here though!
1) It is true that the Vivre card states she is female, I am not denying that. What the issue is that when characters in the story refer to her as "he" "kaido's son", it leaves to each readers opinion on how they want to address yamato, they can either call her "she" based on her biological gender or they can address Yamato as "He" in respect to the story and how its characters call/treat the character there is no wrong option in this imo.
2) Now addressing point 2 you made... It seems to me that Redon is upset that you took HIS summary and changed the pronouns around to fit your own liking rather than writing your own word for word summary of the spoiler. As I mentioned above, Redon prefers to call yamato "He" whereas you and others prefer "She" there is nothing wrong in both options imo but taking someone else's interpretation/summary and altering it because YOU didn't like it are wrong, You could have just pm'd him and talked about it.
2) Now addressing point 2 you made... It seems to me that Redon is upset that you took HIS summary and changed the pronouns around to fit your own liking rather than writing your own word for word summary of the spoiler. As I mentioned above, Redon prefers to call yamato "He" whereas you and others prefer "She" there is nothing wrong in both options imo but taking someone else's interpretation/summary and altering it because YOU didn't like it are wrong, You could have just pm'd him and talked about it.
It's surprising that Redon throwing tantrum over gender. It's not like he is some middle man b/w fans and Oda. Every one reads same manga at viz website or some other website. No fan has right to lord over other fans. Lol.
The fandom is about enjoying the story together with other fans. Not to create factions and peddling agendas.
The fandom is about enjoying the story together with other fans. Not to create factions and peddling agendas.
It is perfectly fine to use redon's summary as "source".
When someone posts something on a public (!) forum, you can cite it as source anytime you want.
As long as you then use your own words to summarize this summary, it's absolutely untouchable.
Nothing this guy can do about it (well, outside of stopping to post spoilers on a public forum of course).
When someone posts something on a public (!) forum, you can cite it as source anytime you want.
As long as you then use your own words to summarize this summary, it's absolutely untouchable.
Nothing this guy can do about it (well, outside of stopping to post spoilers on a public forum of course).
@MonsterZoro Sanji fainted or no?
- Status