Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1040 Spoilers Discussion

[Ssg super suit coby]

Literally nothing changed this chapter except BM having another 5% HP for a dramatic moment. The hole and bombs were always for her.

Read what Law said "Your era is over". Not "Your era is over in Elbaf".

Yet didn't knock her out?

 

[sanjikun]

Is she unconscious? If so point to the spoiler that says that she is

Thats what "winning" is. Her being thrown off the island could be done without Law/Kid landing ultimates and using bombs.

 

[Paperchampion23]

how this is even a debate with the Roger/One Piece scene

I honestly don't know. I thought it was pretty clear by her thinking that, that she KNOWS she can't find one piece anymore. That others are beating her to it.

For sure, she has an unfinished plotline with Caramel, but that has zero bearing on what's happening here.

 

[Screws Loose242]

And some people said they were weaker than Tobi Roppo

If that's what they said then they didn't read/watch WCI

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

Thats what "winning" is. Her being thrown off the island could be done without Law/Kid landing ultimates and using bombs.

Which means she can simply use her homies to heal while law and kidd are resting since they didn't know her out

 

[Iam25]

Thats what "winning" is. Her being thrown off the island could be done without Law/Kid landing ultimates and using bombs.

Sanjikun dude its enough two warlords don't stand a chance against BM. She negs Kuma snd Doffy at same time

 

[sanjikun]

Elbaf is a Shanks arc and not a major Wano-type arc either.

 

[Screws Loose242]

No because Big Mom isn’t coming back from this one

That's what they always said kml like they said she was gonna be ko and defeated

 

[sanjikun]

Which means she can simply use her homies to heal while law and kidd are resting since they didn't know her out

Mate what part of "it's over" don't you get?

Perospero is still up top. CP0 is arresting them all.

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

What's annoying you in particular?

The borderline non-conclusion of this fight and the obvious return of Big Mom in future arcs, paired up with the absolutely terrible handling of her as a character in Wano has me seriously questioning Oda's competency as a writer.

Like straight up, if you remove Big Mom from this arc, not only does nothing change, it probably becomes better.

Like don't get me wrong, if Law and Kidd had won with the attack at the end of last week it would have been very questionable/inconsistent, but in all honesty, I think the implications of what we're getting this week for the rest of the story is even worse.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Maybe BMP will be there as hypetools?

blackbeard is really more of shanks's rival than he is Luffy's

He was a Whitebeard pirate whereas Shanks was a Roger pirate. He has multiple DFs whereas shanks has none. He scarred shanks's eye.

He's also a middle aged man

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

I want kids and law fans to answer this for me. If thilese bombs dont take bigmom exactly what stops her from healing flying back to onigashima using her homies? This is why gettting the job done is so damn important

 

[sanjikun]

It's funny seeing so many cope because they can't handle the idea of seeing Big Mom again in another arc.

Who knows maybe she really is knocked out and it will be confirmed later on, but for the time being it seems like Oda just wanted her to be removed from the battle while at the same time giving Kid and Law some sort of win.

The only "cope" is coming from you.

The "knock off the island" shit was already done and Oda easily could have drowned her. He wanted to give Law/Kid a real win. If he just wanted her out he would have let her drown.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

I want kids and law fans to answer this for me. If thilese bombs dont take bigmom exactly what stops her from healing flying back to onigashima using her homies? This is why gettting the job done is so damn important

If Oda dropped a narration box giving us Kid and Law's victory that won't happen. Either she's out or if by chance she's still conscious, she'll probably just bail on kaido.

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

The borderline non-conclusion of this fight and the obvious return of Big Mom in future arcs, paired up with the absolutely terrible handling of her as a character in Wano has me seriously questioning Oda's competency as a writer.

Like straight up, if you remove Big Mom from this arc, not only does nothing change, it probably becomes better.

Like don't get me wrong, if Law and Kidd had won with the attack at the end of last week it would have been very questionable/inconsistent, but in all honesty, I think the implications of what we're getting this week for the rest of the story is even worse.

I agree with everything you say. I couldn't have said it any better

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

I want kids and law fans to answer this for me. If thilese bombs dont take bigmom exactly what stops her from healing flying back to onigashima using her homies? This is why gettting the job done is so damn important

The bombs are literally a plot device to KO Big Mom.

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

If Oda dropped a narration box giving us Kid and Law's victory that won't happen. Either she's out or if by chance she's still conscious, she'll probably just bail on kaido.

Which means nothing stops her from healing which also means she would have left while kid and law are in a position where they wouldn't be able to defend themselves meaning they still only survived at the mercy of bigmom?

 

[Indigo]

The borderline non-conclusion of this fight and the obvious return of Big Mom in future arcs, paired up with the absolutely terrible handling of her as a character in Wano has me seriously questioning Oda's competency as a writer.

Like straight up, if you remove Big Mom from this arc, not only does nothing change, it probably becomes better.

Like don't get me wrong, if Law and Kidd had won with the attack at the end of last week it would have been very questionable/inconsistent, but in all honesty, I think the implications of what we're getting this week for the rest of the story is even worse.

Yeah man...

This isn't going well

 

[sanjikun]

The borderline non-conclusion of this fight and the obvious return of Big Mom in future arcs, paired up with the absolutely terrible handling of her as a character in Wano has me seriously questioning Oda's competency as a writer.

Like straight up, if you remove Big Mom from this arc, not only does nothing change, it probably becomes better.

Like don't get me wrong, if Law and Kidd had won with the attack at the end of last week it would have been very questionable/inconsistent, but in all honesty, I think the implications of what we're getting this week for the rest of the story is even worse.

There is no "non conclusion". Oda straight up told you she is done. Thats what a narrator box is.

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

The bombs are literally a plot device to KO Big Mom.

The same way law and kidd were supposed to plot devices in beating her prior?