Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1160 Spoilers discussion thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyone else feel like the Shakky stuff was completely unnecessary?

Like there is so much treasure at God Valley anyway (legendary DFs, treasure and riches, slaves, etc)

What does fighting over Shakky add to anything? It was perfectly reasonable for them to fight over legendary treasure anyway.

Like say Shakky wasn't in the story, you could have just had Morgan's leak about God Valley and everything else would still fit.

@Kurozumi Wiwi @Paperchampion23 @Shiroyru
Rayleigh will probably fight Garling EOS.
 

Yoho

I'm Quite Dandy
Anyone else feel like the Shakky stuff was completely unnecessary?

Like there is so much treasure at God Valley anyway (legendary DFs, treasure and riches, slaves, etc)

What does fighting over Shakky add to anything? It was perfectly reasonable for them to fight over legendary treasure anyway.

Like say Shakky wasn't in the story, you could have just had Morgan's leak about God Valley and everything else would still fit.

@Kurozumi Wiwi @Paperchampion23 @Shiroyru
Shakky was the lynch pin to get all the major players there otherwise why make the trip especially when the prizes werent revealed until everyone was at God Valley
 
Shakky was the lynch pin to get all the major players there otherwise why make the trip especially when the prizes werent revealed until everyone was at God Valley
I mean you could still just have Morgan's leak info. We know Rocks wants legendary DFs (and his real motivation would be saving his family).

So getting Rocks to God Valley is easy.

Roger and Rocks already have an established rivalry outside of Shakky I really don't think it was necessary to get Roger to God Valley.

Idk, it feels weird.
 
BTW in the present Shakky tells Luffy that Garp used to chase after her @Kurozumi Wiwi

Garp is NOT safe from becoming a gooner
I thought about it a few chapters ago but Garp was literally laughing knowing Shakky was a prize for the CDs to win, I don't think he ever saw as anything else than a pirate to capture. Also Garp is even more of a old gen Luffy than Roger was in term of personality so I can't see him goon on-screen
 
they do other wise they would have raided marijeoise a long time ago even xebec said he wil be back because he can't defeat imu . Pirates dont mess with th egm or even navy except if they have too . Roger legit run from the navy except if its Garp .
Yeah but Imu isn't at God Valley, and Xebec was fine raiding Mariejois and attacking CDs even by himself he just knew he couldn't beat Imu
 
I thought about it a few chapters ago but Garp was literally laughing knowing Shakky was a prize for the CDs to win, I don't think he ever saw as anything else than a pirate to capture. Also Garp is even more of a old gen Luffy than Roger was in term of personality so I can't see him goon on-screen


Odds Shakky was into Garp like Rayleigh but he never wound up simping?

Big Warp time if true.
 

Yoho

I'm Quite Dandy
I mean you could still just have Morgan's leak info. We know Rocks wants legendary DFs (and his real motivation would be saving his family).

So getting Rocks to God Valley is easy.

Roger and Rocks already have an established rivalry outside of Shakky I really don't think it was necessary to get Roger to God Valley.

Idk, it feels weird.
True, tho rocks seems to want specific fruits and therez no way for any of them to know if the fruits on God Valley was the fruits Rocks was looking for

Also every major event needs a damsel
 
Anyone else feel like the Shakky stuff was completely unnecessary?

Like there is so much treasure at God Valley anyway (legendary DFs, treasure and riches, slaves, etc)

What does fighting over Shakky add to anything? It was perfectly reasonable for them to fight over legendary treasure anyway.

Like say Shakky wasn't in the story, you could have just had Morgan's leak about God Valley and everything else would still fit.

@Kurozumi Wiwi @Paperchampion23 @Shiroyru
I said this last week but you could easily take away the idol/obsession aspect of Shakky and it wouldnt need to change a thing about character motivations to go to God Valley. They could have just went to save a friend. All this nonsense about the economy halting is dumb lmal

If the Kuja were just important pirates that were chased by Garp and became friends to Roger and Rocks, that story would have worked regardless. Her being kidnapped could have motivated perverts like Shiki, but given that BM and Kaido want DFs and Garp was after Roger, not much "had" to change for Roger to get there too. Hell, Garling thinking she was pretty and wanting to make her his wife? Pretty much in character for CDs.

The problem is outside of this Oda sets up all of his characters to be extreme weirdos all the time, so off course they'll react to half naked Kuja's that way. Why the world reacts the same way I have no fucking clue.

The only saving grace is that Rocks isnt really going for her and as mentioned, a few others like John, BM, and Kaido have their own goals. I have to see how this event ends, because yeah right now Im rolling my eyes at some of it.
 
Anyone else feel like the Shakky stuff was completely unnecessary?

Like there is so much treasure at God Valley anyway (legendary DFs, treasure and riches, slaves, etc)

What does fighting over Shakky add to anything? It was perfectly reasonable for them to fight over legendary treasure anyway.

Like say Shakky wasn't in the story, you could have just had Morgan's leak about God Valley and everything else would still fit.

@Kurozumi Wiwi @Paperchampion23 @Shiroyru
It was done purely to give Garling a reason to kill Shanks’ mom
 
Dragon is in his prime. Garling isn't.
Yes but dragon and garling probably will met there after all dragon only saved shanks in the end and Dragon is the guy that stole garling his sons that seem to be a pretty obvious match up now . Dragon wont be able to beat him in God valey . But in the curent time line why would he take care of the new gorosei who have history with him ?
 
Anyone else feel like the Shakky stuff was completely unnecessary?

Like there is so much treasure at God Valley anyway (legendary DFs, treasure and riches, slaves, etc)

What does fighting over Shakky add to anything? It was perfectly reasonable for them to fight over legendary treasure anyway.

Like say Shakky wasn't in the story, you could have just had Morgan's leak about God Valley and everything else would still fit.

@Kurozumi Wiwi @Paperchampion23 @Shiroyru
Perhaps. I feel like Oda wanted a heroic reason for why Roger would go, so Shakky was there for him. I suppose the Rocks could have been changed to not have cared about her.

I also have to note our way of thinking and Oda's is a LOT different. He probably just thinks of the ga-ga reactions as harmless fun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top