ONE PIECE Live Action - Episodes Discussion Thread

[U c 4 up da idly]

How is this corruption lmfao? All he said is that he made them run away because of how strong he is. He was basically boasting to save face. Thats not corruption mate.

Doctor a report in a military and see how that plays out

 

[Fujishiro]

Doctor a report in a military and see how that plays out

What did he forge lmfao, the only divergence in his report was that he made them run away instead of them beating him up and leaving.

 

[Date]

BTW guys. I have a question for you. Do you think we should consider the sentence: "you didn't earn that scar" as Canon ? It feels like something Oda has pushed in (although I might be wrong) and I find it interesting in term of characterization.

There's no such thing as "consider canon" the manga is canon, all the other things are just adaptations.

 

[Roo]

it is corruption, you can't doctor a report to make it look like you did good

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

it is corruption, you can't doctor a report to make it look like you did good

What are you blabbering

 

[Logiko]

There's no such thing as "consider canon" the manga is canon, all the other things are just adaptations.

I know I know.. I just find this addition very interesting

 

[Roo]

What are you blabbering

Morgans was a corrupt official and Garp punished him for it. It's not that hard to understand lol

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

Morgans was a corrupt official and Garp punished him for it. It's not that hard to understand lol

He literally let him escape

 

[Roo]

He literally let him escape

we are talking about the Live Action, I'm 3 episodes in and Morgans was punished for being corrupt

 

[Red Night]

I want to be Bogard's toy.

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

we are talking about the Live Action, I'm 3 episodes in and Morgans was punished for being corrupt

Ohhh.

I'm only in episode 1

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Garp was (for some reason) presented as way more villainous than he ever was in the manga

Even when we didn't know his identity, he was never presented as some sort of ruthless, ends-justify-the-means type of guy.

Granted, I've yet to watch the last two episodes, so I don't know how his arc is resolved in this Season. But from what I've seen he's far removed from the unhinged but jolly manga and anime Garp

Yeah, thats the thing it was rushed. And fealt unearned. We also saw that Morgan seemed to actually care about protecting civilians and do his duty. So the “what else could he be witholding” line of thought doesnt hold much weight atleast in the eyes of the viewer.

Basically the randoms who are watching this and know nothing about OP will be left wondering why Morgan was so harshly punished and also think of Garp as someone more sinister then he really is.

I liked this version of Garp better.

Don't think they realized what they wanted to do with Garp after having him take an overly active role though.
He sent Mihawk after Luffy and then after fighting Luffy he says it's just a test.

My guess for entirety of the show:
They were doing Cowboy Bebop 2.0
Oda stepped in and complained.
So they redone a lot of the scenes and patched it up and this is the result.

 

[Fujishiro]

it is corruption, you can't doctor a report to make it look like you did good

Bruh.

Post automatically merged: Sep 1, 2023

I want to be Bogard's toy.

 

[Roo]

Bruh.

dishonest or fraudulent conduct by those in power, typically involving bribery.

it is by definition corruption lol, Morgan just did it to save his own ass instead of for money

 

[Fujishiro]

it is by definition corruption lol, Morgan just did it to save his own ass instead of for money

its a huge reach.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

its a huge reach.

Ok. What do you expect would happen in real life. Either military, navy, marines, whatever you want to call them.

 

[Roo]

its a huge reach.

it's not. You think Morgan is just lying to him and expecting Garp to read something entirely different in the military report?

 

[Moegara]

I'm sad. I was enjoying the show except for a few minor gripes until I just saw Mihawk's episode.

Between Sanji's voice in my language and how much I disliked Mihawk in this show, I'm bummed out.

Just posting to complain. I'm happy Bogard has lines though.

 

[Fujishiro]

Ok. What do you expect would happen in real life. Either military, navy, marines, whatever you want to call them.

The punishment for saying oh yeah i ran them off instead of they beat me up and escaped was too severe.

 

[NikaInParis]

My wishes for Season 2:
Episode 1 - Loguetown. Smoker and Tashigi intro. Dragon intro. Reverse Mountain. Episode ends either with us seeing Laboon or him swallowing the Merry.
Episode 2 - Laboon and Crocus story. Probably a small tease for the Rumbar Pirates and Brook, an Easter Egg. Vivi and Mr# intro and plot. Whiskey Peak arrival. Small tease of Crocodile and Robin.
Episode 3 - Whiskey Peak arc in full. Maybe a tease for more Baroque Works agents, including Mr 3. Smoker and Tashigi whereabouts.
Episode 4 - Little Garden arc in full. Some additional scenes with Croco and Robin, and small teases of Alabasta and the situation there to prepare us for the next half of the season.
Episode 5 - Maybe some additional scenes of Smoker and Tashigi. Wapol. Drum Island arrival and looking for a doctor. Chopper intro. Luffy, Nami and Sanji are healed. Start of Chopper flashback.
Episode 6 - Ace and Blackbeard info. Wapol comes back. Chopper flashback continues. Wapol fight. End of arc.
Episode 7 - Some Alabasta scenes - general populace as well as Cobra and co. Crew arrives. Smoker and Tashigi arrive. Smoker, Luffy, Ace scene and chase. Rebel army plot.
Eoisode 8 - Dance Powder plot. More Alabasta politics. Yuba. Arriving at Rainbase and the whole cage plot. Ends with them escaping the cage and going towards Alubarna, Luffy challenging Crocodile the first time.
Episode 9 - Luffy vs Crocodile. Luffy loses, Robin saves him. Strawhats at Alubarna vs BW. Crocodile and Cobra plot. Here I would make a change and omitt Round 2. Have Croc take Cobra to the tombs and Pell drop Luffy off there). Ends with Luffy arriving at the tomb and punching/challenging Croc for a rematch.
Episode 10 - finale of the fight. Bounties. Farewell to Vivi. More Warlords introduced. Robin joins the crew. Maybe Tease the Sky Islands with a log pose/map whatever