Now you are twisting narrative to suit your agenda lol
First you said - they weren't rivals
Then I gave you a panel which clearly says they fought each other numerous times which means they were more or less equals
Now you are saying - it wasn't one vs one but roger vs garp+marine soldiers
Bruhhh....
Why Roger will respect Garp to such extent that he will request Garp to take care of his son if Garp never really fought Roger in fair duel??
First you said - they weren't rivals
Then I gave you a panel which clearly says they fought each other numerous times which means they were more or less equals
Now you are saying - it wasn't one vs one but roger vs garp+marine soldiers
Bruhhh....
Why Roger will respect Garp to such extent that he will request Garp to take care of his son if Garp never really fought Roger in fair duel??
2. Stated that we have zero context on how the fight even remotely went down
3. Then stated that your panel that you showed with rodger saying they fought to the death sometimes does not equate to garp being his equal since we have zero context again in how their fight went down.
4. Stated that if you have the exact context share the chapter that shows it.
There was 0 contradiction on my end since you haven't shown rodger viewing garp as a rival. Infact rodger wanting garp to adopt his kid leads more to rodger viewing garp as a friend and not a rival