IMU in his chamber: "I no longer feel my connection with Sommers. WTF is going on on Elbaf? Don't tell me there's another one of those dumb wind-up robots propelled by Joyboy's haki. God I hate mechas. Where's my butterflies? I need to cut down ten of those insects at least to calm my nerves down. God I hate this place. Where's my Vivi? Where's that dumb Vegapunk chick with her promised nuclear fusion tank? God I hate these underlings. In 800 years of henchmen, these ones have to be the worst I've ever dealt with. I miss the Devil Dragon... I miss the other Gods... Maybe I should've left Joyboy put me out of my misery... FML."
 
Garling and Rocks put up their children as rewards for whoever wins their battle and put them in treasure boxes. During their battle the Roger Pirates and Garp arrived, Roger ended up claiming all the treasure boxes including the sons of Rocks and Garling
 
My point is it ain't from Roger's.


The bandage we saw is too small for the scar Whitebeard have.

So it basically happened after This specific battle.

Roger and Whitebeard after that has no clash in records because they were busy with One Piece.

In manga during Roger and Whitebeard final clash, the scar is missing as well.
Oda Is flippant on these things, he even draw Shanks with his arm, but we consistently saw WB without scars post GV and Roger wounding him on the chest.

It's not beneath him to retcon, but still.
 
Top