Controversial One Piece VS Naruto & Bleach

#61
WB: "Here's a choice, aye or nay?"

All WBPs: "Aye!"

You: "They were manipulated!"

:pepeke:

All this gibberish is irrelevant to your claim that "Whitebeard is a hypocrite".

Everybody in the WBPs likes Ace, Ace was still alive, they're all naturally going to want to save Ace. What's the hypocrisy?
Again WB could have said no to the war. It was ace's fault in first place as he went against WB's orders. WB knew his other sons would be killed in this war and it would be due to ace's own idiotic decision :tchpepe:

WB's job is not only to protect one son but to protect all of his sons. He should have decided to protect his other sons.
 
#65
Pain the guy who commits genocide against a village, kills his father figure and not once doubt his way, but when a child of 16 tells him "uh have you tried not being bad and doing the right thing?" Completely changes his worldviews and resurrecting everyone because he can?
Nagato's story is more complicated than that. He tells Jiraiya that he wants true peace, blah blah blah.

Jiraiya writes his first book with the main character (Naruto) inspired by Nagato.

Nagato ends up talking just like the villain in the book and Naruto hits him with his own quote. "Blah blah, never give up, if there is peace I'll seize it blah blah".

Then he says "remember this book? It was inspired by you, that character's name is Naruto, You can pass on your dreams to me because I don't wanna let my godfather down and taint the name he gave me."

Nagato was already defeated anyway, and didn't think Konan could best Naruto. Might as well do a good deed instead of just cursing into your grave while being killed by a teenager.
 
#66
Nagato's story is more complicated than that. He tells Jiraiya that he wants true peace, blah blah blah.

Jiraiya writes his first book with the main character (Naruto) inspired by Nagato.

Nagato ends up talking just like the villain in the book and Naruto hits him with his own quote. "Blah blah, never give up, if there is peace I'll seize it blah blah".

Then he says "remember this book? It was inspired by you, that character's name is Naruto, You can pass on your dreams to me because I don't wanna let my godfather down and taint the name he gave me."

Nagato was already defeated anyway, and didn't think Konan could best Naruto. Might as well do a good deed instead of just cursing into your grave while being killed by a teenager.
Are you yomi from fanverse?
 
#67
Again WB could have said no to the war. It was ace's fault in first place as he went against WB's orders. WB knew his other sons would be killed in this war and it would be due to ace's own idiotic decision :tchpepe:

WB's job is not only to protect one son but to protect all of his sons. He should have decided to protect his other sons.
Sassenach, if he wanted to protect his sons from any and all martial conflict, he wouldn't be a feckin pirate now would he?

He didn't force anyone to be there, they all went willingly to save their brother. This isn't like a military where refusing to follow dumb orders get a bloke court martialed, there wasn't even an order to begin with. There was a choice.

As for Ace being dumb, sure he's dumb but just because a family member is prone to acts of recklessness doesn't mean you leave them for dead.

Lastly, Whitebeard not retaliating to the execution of a Division Commander would be a crippling prestige blow to the Whitebeard Pirate's empire. It would send the message out to all of their rivals that "Hey, you can execute one of our most popular and famous crew members and we won't do shit because we're too pussy about spilled blood".

It would endanger both the crew and the civilians in the WBP's territories if enemies thought they could get away with grievous trespasses.

You're either obtuse or stupid. No in-between. All this because you can't handle @Gaimon The Pirate thinking that being able to talk a kin slaughtering terrorist out of his Ninja Jihad is actually a bit dumb.
 
#68
Sassenach, if he wanted to protect his sons from any and all martial conflict, he wouldn't be a feckin pirate now would he?

He didn't force anyone to be there, they all went willingly to save their brother. This isn't like a military where refusing to follow dumb orders get a bloke court martialed, there wasn't even an order to begin with. There was a choice.

As for Ace being dumb, sure he's dumb but just because a family member is prone to acts of recklessness doesn't mean you leave them for dead.

Lastly, Whitebeard not retaliating to the execution of a Division Commander would be a crippling prestige blow to the Whitebeard Pirate's empire. It would send the message out to all of their rivals that "Hey, you can execute one of our most popular and famous crew members and we won't do shit because we're too pussy about spilled blood".

It would endanger both the crew and the civilians in the WBP's territories if enemies thought they could get away with grievous trespasses.

You're either obtuse or stupid. No in-between. All this because you can't handle @Gaimon The Pirate thinking that being able to talk a kin slaughtering terrorist out of his Ninja Jihad is actually a bit dumb.
You talking out of your ass as you always do lol. One of the worst posters out here for sure.

Again stop being dumb for sake of being dump. WB commanded his crew. He knew more sons will die had he went to save ace which again was something ace himself chose to do. Its irrelevant whether others wanted to save ace or not because at the end WB is the captain. He should know better than to sacrifice most of his sons for one son lol.

Also it won't send any message. WB got lucky that shanks stopped Kaido otherwise bozo would have to face BPs first lol.
 
#72
Again stop being dumb for sake of being dump. WB commanded his crew. He knew more sons will die had he went to save ace which again was something ace himself chose to do. Its irrelevant whether others wanted to save ace or not because at the end WB is the captain. He should know better than to sacrifice most of his sons for one son lol.
He's not the one sacrificing them, they're sacrificing themselves because they love Ace. What part of that don't you understand?

If it was a traditional crew based purely on hierarchy and the chain of command, sure but it isn't and they're going to want to rescue Ace anyway because he's a beloved brother and brothers stick with each regardless of how dumb they're being.
Also it won't send any message.
What a muppet take. :milaugh:

An empire not retaliating to a public execution of what is effectively a high ranking General does indeed send an extraordinarily damning message of weakness that will lead to dramatically increased territory clashes.
Also WB never went to save momo and hiyori and to avenge oden also and gave casualty as a reason. So he is a hypocrite lol @Owl Ki
So hang, according to you Whitebeard is a hypocrite because he sends his crew into mortal danger to rescue a still living Ace but also because he doesn't send his crew into mortal danger to avenge the deceased Oden?

Feckin which is it? :risitameh:
Might have to just concede on this one, he got you pretty good there
Why? He literally just torpedoed his own retarded initial take. Lel.
 
#73
He's not the one sacrificing them, they're sacrificing themselves because they love Ace. What part of that don't you understand?

If it was a traditional crew based purely on hierarchy and the chain of command, sure but it isn't and they're going to want to rescue Ace anyway because he's a beloved brother and brothers stick with each regardless of how dumb they're being.

What a muppet take. :milaugh:

An empire not retaliating to a public execution of what is effectively a high ranking General does indeed send an extraordinarily damning message of weakness.

So hang, according to you Whitebeard is a hypocrite because he sends his crew into mortal danger to rescue a still living Ace and because he doesn't send his crew into mortal danger to avenge the deceased Oden?

Feckin which is it? :risitameh:

Why? He literally just torpedoed his own retarded initial take. Lel.


:suresure::suresure:
 
#74
He's not the one sacrificing them, they're sacrificing themselves because they love Ace. What part of that don't you understand?

If it was a traditional crew based purely on hierarchy and the chain of command, sure but it isn't and they're going to want to rescue Ace anyway because he's a beloved brother and brothers stick with each regardless of how dumb they're being.

What a muppet take. :milaugh:

An empire not retaliating to a public execution of what is effectively a high ranking General does indeed send an extraordinarily damning message of weakness that will lead to dramatically increased territory clashes.

So hang, according to you Whitebeard is a hypocrite because he sends his crew into mortal danger to rescue a still living Ace and because he doesn't send his crew into mortal danger to avenge the deceased Oden?

Feckin which is it? :risitameh:

Why? He literally just torpedoed his own retarded initial take. Lel.
I mean MonsterKaido might have to concede, my bad
 
Top