Speculations Order of BPs defeats

Finalbeta

Hero of Albion
#21
Not sure why that's "very likely".

Sanji kicked Queen in 1015 and this forum argued for months about Zoro/King. It's not like Queen is any more beaten than he was back then. Essentially 1023 onward can shift the focus back to Jack and whatever is going on with him an Inu. If he loses, he loses. If he wins, Oda can set up, start and finish his fight before going back to Sanji and Queen.

Not to mention the other 5 fights that exist. We still don't don't know if the BMP made it to mainland Wano yet or not. It's been hours already.
Just to be more confident. I don't like 100% scenarios most of the time since this is Oda, but I don't see much ground for that to occur, conversely. Still it's undoubtedly more accurate to pin it that way.
 
#22
- Nothing states that he can't beat him alone. He's healed. The last 10 chapters have implied that he will in fact beat him alone lol

- Like I said, healthy strawhats will fight fodder, Numbers or another threat (CP0, BMP, Jack, Hawkins/Apoo, Peros, Fukurokuju if others arent), just as they have for a 1000 chapters after they win fights

- Nothing in Odens flashback suggests the Strawhats will fight Kaido lol, it suggests "new pirates" will stand up to Kaido (which happened already, read Chapter 1000, it's in the narration) and "Joyboy" will return. That's it
Oden literally said
“In another 20 years the primary figures of that Great War will muscle their way into the new world. They will be the ones to strike down Kaido.”

And just like with this war, the straw hats will be the main figure of the war against the World Government.

And literally no other pirates in wano muscled their way into the new world this year except Luffys and Caribou.

It pretty clearly says the straw hats will strike down kaido.
 
Last edited:
A

Akagaminoproduction

#23
- Nothing states that he can't beat him alone. He's healed. The last 10 chapters have implied that he will in fact beat him alone lol

- Like I said, healthy strawhats will fight fodder, Numbers or another threat (CP0, BMP, Jack, Hawkins/Apoo, Peros, Fukurokuju if others arent), just as they have for a 1000 chapters after they win fights

- Nothing in Odens flashback suggests the Strawhats will fight Kaido lol, it suggests "new pirates" will stand up to Kaido (which happened already, read Chapter 1000, it's in the narration) and "Joyboy" will return. That's it
Let me get this straight..... Eating meat != healing luffy is not at 100 HP because then they dont need chopper and luffy shouldn't ever wear bandages.....are we clear???
secondly... kaido can fight a yonko for 3 days at no point it was shown that his opponents were better than yonko so all that damage you think has occured ... does not really matter to him... so if WSC is true then 1v1 is not favoring SH...
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#27
“In another 20 years the primary figures of that Great War will muscle their way into the new world. They will be the ones to strike down Kaido.”
Setup

Payoff

im fairly certain that this is it. i need to look at the japanese versions of these two panels to see whether the difference in translation is a mistake by the translator (corrected in the volumes) or did oda purposefully change it.

EDIT: Reread ch 1000 and Yamato believed that Ace would lead the group that brings down Kaido. Ace who was in the new world much before the 20 years point. And Yamato probably read it off of Oden's journal.



They hammer in the fact that its the worst generation and not the strawhats even more by literally showing panels of Law, Kidd and Killer.

At this point, it pretty obviously refers to the Worst Gen and not the Strawhats.
 
Last edited:
#29
Setup

Payoff

im fairly certain that this is it. i need to look at the japanese versions of these two panels to see whether the difference in translation is a mistake by the translator (corrected in the volumes) or did oda purposefully change it.

EDIT: Reread ch 1000 and Yamato believed that Ace would lead the group that brings down Kaido. Ace who was in the new world much before the 20 years point. And Yamato probably read it off of Oden's journal.



They hammer in the fact that its the worst generation and not the strawhats even more by literally showing panels of Law, Kidd and Killer.

At this point, it pretty obviously refers to the Worst Gen and not the Strawhats.
The worst Gen tried and failed tho as such it wasn’t referring to them.

The worst Gen didn’t muscle into the new world 20 years after Odens death. They entered 18 years after.

Nor will they be the primary figures of the Great War.

It’s been clear since oden said the arcs ending with straw hats vs Kaido. The worst Gen thing was a red herring as they lost
[automerge]1629641490[/automerge]
But can he do it all alone? Not much points towards that portrayal wise. Also there are like 3 opponents that look more feasible for Jack lol. The 2 dukes and Jinbe specifically. Even from a plot perspective, it would be very aestethically and content pleasing if the dukes terminated the job.
Usopp regularly beats the number 4 of the crew when he has a fight.

Chu/Mr. 4/Perona.

Usopp also needs to surpass his father so he’ll need to defeat a calamity here and now
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#30
The worst Gen didn’t muscle into the new world 20 years after Odens death. They entered 18 years after.
they need not necessarily come to the new world for the first time after 20 years.
yamato was thinking that ace would be the one to lead the new generation of pirates.

its also not a coincidence that in the same chapter (1000) the same phrase is uttered twice (once by yamato and once a oden voiceover) and both of those panels contain the worst generation ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

The worst Gen tried and failed tho as such it wasn’t referring to them.
well luffy is gonna fight him and luffy is still a member of the worst generation. and it has been played multiple times that luffy will fight and defeat him in that 1v1.
also dont you think that if the 9 shadows are the 9 strawhats , doesnt that take away everything from the 9 red scabbards thematically and narratively?
 
#31
they need not necessarily come to the new world for the first time after 20 years.
yamato was thinking that ace would be the one to lead the new generation of pirates.

its also not a coincidence that in the same chapter (1000) the same phrase is uttered twice (once by yamato and once a oden voiceover) and both of those panels contain the worst generation ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


well luffy is gonna fight him and luffy is still a member of the worst generation. and it has been played multiple times that luffy will fight and defeat him in that 1v1.
also dont you think that if the 9 shadows are the 9 strawhats , doesnt that take away everything from the 9 red scabbards thematically and narratively?
The scabbards thematically are the same thing as the tontattas in Dressrosa. They’re people to show the suffering the villain caused and to impart part of their Will into the straw hats to get them to grow stronger.

With Kaido himself saying Luffy casts a strong shadow and him having nine crewmates, the recent portrayal of wings of pirate king, the straw hats ending their fights with energy. Straw hats vs Kaido then Luffy vs Kaido has been set up.
 
#32
The worst Gen tried and failed tho as such it wasn’t referring to them.

The worst Gen didn’t muscle into the new world 20 years after Odens death. They entered 18 years after.

Nor will they be the primary figures of the Great War.

It’s been clear since oden said the arcs ending with straw hats vs Kaido. The worst Gen thing was a red herring as they lost
[automerge]1629641490[/automerge]

Usopp regularly beats the number 4 of the crew when he has a fight.

Chu/Mr. 4/Perona.

Usopp also needs to surpass his father so he’ll need to defeat a calamity here and now
Kind of weird to say this when Law and Kid are still fighting Big Mom. The 3 captains that are present in those panels are still fighting the Yonko currently. Nothing has changed. Those were the pirates Oden was talking about. The narrator showed it, why argue against that logic? I'm at the point where I don't expect the F6 to get up and be threats still, because just this very chapter the Narrator stated they were defeated.

And if you think Usopp will defeat Jack, why are you even assuming Queen and King go down first in order to set up Strawhats vs Kaido? Sorry, I don't get the logic.
 
#33
Kind of weird to say this when Law and Kid are still fighting Big Mom. The 3 captains that are present in those panels are still fighting the Yonko currently. Nothing has changed. Those were the pirates Oden was talking about. The narrator showed it, why argue against that logic? I'm at the point where I don't expect the F6 to get up and be threats still, because just this very chapter the Narrator stated they were defeated.

And if you think Usopp will defeat Jack, why are you even assuming Queen and King go down first in order to set up Strawhats vs Kaido? Sorry, I don't get the logic.
Because Kaido has a lot of stamina yet.

As I’ve said well get:

Momotaro fight - Luffy Zoro Sanji and Momo vs Kaido

Nine shadows fight - Nine Straw Hats as Luffy recovers his haki

Final fight - Kaido vs Luffy

Jack fight will take place during the nine shadows fight then they’ll join after.

The quote Oden spoke said “They will be the one to take down Kaido.” I don’t see how everyone else thinks the supernova are who oden was talking about as they failed to do it. One everything else Oden mentioned didn’t apply to them either.
 
#35
Because Kaido has a lot of stamina yet.

As I’ve said well get:

Momotaro fight - Luffy Zoro Sanji and Momo vs Kaido

Nine shadows fight - Nine Straw Hats as Luffy recovers his haki

Final fight - Kaido vs Luffy

Jack fight will take place during the nine shadows fight then they’ll join after.

The quote Oden spoke said “They will be the one to take down Kaido.” I don’t see how everyone else thinks the supernova are who oden was talking about as they failed to do it. One everything else Oden mentioned didn’t apply to them either.
I just think you are making waaaaaay too many assumptions about something that has no concrete proof lol.

What has solid proof is Luffy defeating Kaido, because the story has only told us like 5 times already after the Rooftop fight.

But whatever. Can't change your opinions man, let's see what happens:kayneshrug:
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#37
Because Kaido has a lot of stamina yet.
yes. and i dont think strawhats (most of them are already roughed up) are gonna pose any bigger threat than a one shot for kaido.

Momotaro fight - Luffy Zoro Sanji and Momo vs Kaido
we have a mythical zoan bird, mythical zoan dog. there's no way sanji and zoro are going up there instead of marco and yamato if the momotaro theory is right.

the way i see it:
9 shadows - 9 scabbards vs kaido
leaders of the new generation - rooftop 5 supernova vs kaido
momotaro - luffy, yamato, marco, momo vs kaido
then luffy gets the final blow in a 1v1 with kaido.

Chu/Mr. 4/Perona.
all pretimeskip fights. usopp vs chew was when there were only 5 crew members. perona was a gag fight.

i dont rule out usopp vs jack but if it happens it'll be filled with PIS and will feel insanely out of place.
jack would look like a joke compared to the other two calamities.
jinbe or neko is a much better candidate since the very reason for neko dragging perospero outside is for carrot to get the finishing blow.
i see carrot vs perospero round 2 after neko softens him up to go fight jack 1v1 after inu loses.
 
#39
Yeah at this point I think Usopp actually will “beat” Jack. Oda will probably make him Luffy’s YC3 in the future, and Oda may want to maintain Usopp’s high bounty in the crew, so Usopp would have to do something more accomplishing than beating a F5
 
#40
yes. and i dont think strawhats (most of them are already roughed up) are gonna pose any bigger threat than a one shot for kaido.


we have a mythical zoan bird, mythical zoan dog. there's no way sanji and zoro are going up there instead of marco and yamato if the momotaro theory is right.

the way i see it:
9 shadows - 9 scabbards vs kaido
leaders of the new generation - rooftop 5 supernova vs kaido
momotaro - luffy, yamato, marco, momo vs kaido
then luffy gets the final blow in a 1v1 with kaido.


all pretimeskip fights. usopp vs chew was when there were only 5 crew members. perona was a gag fight.

i dont rule out usopp vs jack but if it happens it'll be filled with PIS and will feel insanely out of place.
jack would look like a joke compared to the other two calamities.
jinbe or neko is a much better candidate since the very reason for neko dragging perospero outside is for carrot to get the finishing blow.
i see carrot vs perospero round 2 after neko softens him up to go fight jack 1v1 after inu loses.
Don’t underestimate the straw hats.

The idea that Oda will have Kaido one shot any of them is kinda silly. If Kaido couldn’t just one shot scabbards the straw hats will be fine.

Marco was just shown to be out of energy I doubt if there’s a Momotaro fight he’ll be in it. Yamato’s been fighting Kaido one on one for a bit that I doubt he’ll be of much energy left either. Right now the three most energized are Luffy (the monkey) Zoro (the dog) and Sanji (the Bird) or do you think it’s a coincidence Zoro was taught fire Fox style and hung around with a Fox monster and Hiyoris mask is a kitsune. Or that Sanji is the son of the Garuda (The king of the birds) and Sora (The Sky).

Finally Usopp vs Jack, call it Pre TS fights all you want but this is the first legit straw hat vs enemy crew fight post TS. I’m just saying every time before Usopp fought the third strongest underling. He’s Luffys last commander and calling it PIS is just a way people will cope with Usopp begin able to beat people stronger than Jinbe.
 
Top