[FNZ] Role Madness Overlord Mafia Game Thread

[Orwellian]

Flower isn't healing me out of what I would classify as spite so I'm not really surprised by her action, and she probably also went with lynching Ekko over Worst because Ekko referenced using his "wish" to probably heal me anyways

Oh well c'est la vive

 

[Boquise]

One thing that bothered me about Ekko that I didn't voice was that the Flower kill didn't feel like something he would do as town. That said, I think there was some element of genuine hunting to his reads, it's just that his reads lacked the extra consideration one would expect of a townie. Which is to say, I'm not in favour of blanket throwing out everything he said because he wasn't town.

It feels sort of comforting that you think this because this is how I interpret it too regarding the flower read and that his approached sucked

But
Uh
How does this help you solve living slots

 

[Boquise]

I got an award for posting get rekt kids

 

[Michelle]

Vote lynch Worst

 

[hime]

i doubt anyone wouldve known ekko was sk bc he probs scans town
scum probably have redirects and thought it would be good to preserve him if i had to guess

i just got a trophy for 5000 posts (this is my 5000th post)
ig the universe is trying to send a msg

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Hayumi who'd u cop tn?

 

[hime]

I got an award for posting get rekt kids

lol we probs got our trophies at the same time how bizarre XD

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Stargate18 happy bday

 

[hime]

I didn't say I could heal myself

y r u not dead yet btw?

 

[Ratchet]

damn the omgus
ur defense of him was awful

"keep him alive bc he is mc"
"ainz isnt going to be a fake role"
etc.

there was a lack of progression leading up to ur switch later too

How is it OMGUS? You were asked where you go if Ekko flips Town and said "Worst/Ratchet". I am asking you to explain this because Ekko was relatively confident on me being town so it makes no sense for me to be one of your primary directions, especially after I was defending him for most of the game. My contention specifically is that your comment felt throwaway and underbaked, which are hallmarks of fake thought.

 

[Ultra]

Vote lynch Worst

This is de way

 

[Michelle]

@Hayumi who'd u cop tn?

Yo mama

 

[Ultra]

How is it OMGUS? You were asked where you go if Ekko flips Town and said "Worst/Ratchet". I am asking you to explain this because Ekko was relatively confident on me being town so it makes no sense for me to be one of your primary directions, especially after I was defending him for most of the game. My contention specifically is that your comment felt throwaway and underbaked, which are hallmarks of fake thought.

Why are you voting a checked player

You're gonna lose aura as the kids say

 

[Michelle]

How can you ask that if you pretend you are town Cryo?

 

[Boquise]

How is it OMGUS? You were asked where you go if Ekko flips Town and said "Worst/Ratchet". I am asking you to explain this because Ekko was relatively confident on me being town so it makes no sense for me to be one of your primary directions, especially after I was defending him for most of the game. My contention specifically is that your comment felt throwaway and underbaked, which are hallmarks of fake thought.

Considering Ekko's death tunnels and his alignment, I don't think his reads matter at all

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

How can you ask that if you pretend you are town Cryo?

i meant to ask who they copped last night

allegedly they were refilled

Yo mama

:o

 

[Ratchet]

damn the omgus
ur defense of him was awful

"keep him alive bc he is mc"
"ainz isnt going to be a fake role"
etc.

there was a lack of progression leading up to ur switch later too

Also you're saying it's awful without due context. Day 1 i had Ekko as town because I thought he and Michelle were possible Masons. I agreed that he was unlikely to send the message and have several posts explaining why there is little motivation for Ekko as scum to send a message like that, but lots of motivation for someone to fake the message to frame him. You're acting like this part of the read just doesn't exist, I'm assuming you have good reason for this? I would love to hear it.

Coming into Day 2 after seeing he had claimed Ains, I said it was far too risky to lynch into that claim on the basis of the evidence, which as far as I could see, was the message (which I already outlined my issues with). Fuji loves characters like Ains, there is no way he was not going to be in the game and from what Ekko had claimed there was not much chance of him being Mafia. I ultimately ended up turning on him because when I stepped back and looked at his pushes, especially the Boq push, I found myself unconvinced on them. You'll also note that I did concede the possibility that Ains was a Serial/Indie before any of this too.

So here is where I'm at hime. I'm having a hard time buying your reasoning as genuine because it seems to be in bad faith to me, willfully ignorant of crucial context in order to settle on a position that you think makes sense for you to come to. I believe I've shored up your contention so I'd like you to reconcile the issues I have with your reasoning, can then move past this and just lynch Aurelian like I kinda wanted to yesterday.

 

[Ratchet]

Considering Ekko's death tunnels and his alignment, I don't think his reads matter at all

Well given that you were on the receiving end of one, I hardly think you're the most, shall we say, unbiased perspective on this.

 

[Ratchet]

Maybe I misunderstood but I read your post but it looked like you said Ekko was town lol

I think you need to read the context again.

 

[Ratchet]

I'm not against Worst going over either to be honest but I'm not that confident on it. Would support it though.