[FNZ] Role Madness Overlord Mafia Game Thread

[Yoho]

As I’ve already said. My town list is you, Flower, Orca. Unfortunately I feel like the compatibility result to Michelle and YTW is somewhat incriminating considering the current POE I would want to yeet one of them today, and I did check them both for that exact reason.


Those two along with York and Crying were at the top of my Poe list. I chose not to check the other two because I felt they would be more likely to self resolve or get yeeted easier.

In a world where both are town, based purely off play I’d think Pero or Charlie or next most likely to be scum.

I believe Flower bc of their claim consistency/overall trying to solve the whole game. If she’s scum I think we already lost honestly.

Orca I’m less confident about then you or Flower bc his claim doesn’t seem all that necessary. But based off how he postured around hime off the bat I just don’t really see it either. Flower also has given him a town pass all game which I don’t think she does if they were both scum so for that reason I’m choosing to just trust in my Poe for better or worse.

One thing that stuck out to me is Michelle shading me in reference to not even knowing if I’m a sane cop. While it’s technically possible, not only is it highly unlikely in game with no real contested invest roles besides mine, it also sets her up to possibly try to frame herself positively in the case that YTW gets flipped. Just a crackpot foil but very possible.
Michelle
YTW
Pero
Charlie

Going by your results if we lynch Michelle and she flips scum then that would make me rethink my original thought on Yo tan but if she flips town then the chances Yo is town is confirmed

Same vice versa

 

[Yoho]

I dropped out of law school to be a hairstylist rofl but thank you clock it

If I'm ever called to the stand I'll hire you as one of my lawyers

 

[Charlie]

this is the only vc where scum barely escaped lynch afaik, right?

i mean, ekko vs worst on D2


ignoring dead people who hasn't voted either of them

EKKO: flower > worst > Polar Bear > Worst

FLOWER: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Worst > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
ORWELLIAN: Ekko > Worst
ULTRA: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Polar Bear > Ekko > Mango > Worst > Ekko > Worst
PERO: Ekko > Worst
YOHO: Ekko >
YORK: Ekko
ORCA: Ekko
LANJI: Ekko > Unvote > Ekko > Worst
MICHELLE: Ekko > Flower > Worst
HAYUMI: Flower > unvote > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
HIME: Ekko
WORST: Ekko > Ultra > Ekko
CHARLIE: Ekko > unvote > Worst > Ekko
MANGO: Ekko
RATCHET: Ultra > Worst > Unvote > Ekko
JAGUARK: Worst
STARGATE: Worst
Boquise: Ekko

so basically every flipped mafia member was on ekko wagon
flipped towns: 5 for worst, 3 for ekko

idk if they'd all jump on the same wagon but looks like they really tried to save worst here i guess

out of people still in the game:
voted ekko
- me
- flower
- yoho
- orca
- hayumi

hasn't voted at all
- ytw

voted worst
- pero
- michelle

idk about michelle but at very least, i don't want to vote pero

assuming ninja thing isn't bastard, yoho should be good

so flower/orca/hayumi/ytw/michelle and apparently ytw/michelle share alignment

so it could be, if 2:
1. orca and flower
2. ytw and michelle

if 3:
1. hayumi/flower/orca
2. ytw&michelle + either orca or flower

meh, idk, i guess lynching one of michelle/ytw gives the most info in case game isn't over next dp if it's town

 

[Ultra]

this is the only vc where scum barely escaped lynch afaik, right?

i mean, ekko vs worst on D2


ignoring dead people who hasn't voted either of them

EKKO: flower > worst > Polar Bear > Worst

FLOWER: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Worst > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
ORWELLIAN: Ekko > Worst
ULTRA: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Polar Bear > Ekko > Mango > Worst > Ekko > Worst
PERO: Ekko > Worst
YOHO: Ekko >
YORK: Ekko
ORCA: Ekko
LANJI: Ekko > Unvote > Ekko > Worst
MICHELLE: Ekko > Flower > Worst
HAYUMI: Flower > unvote > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
HIME: Ekko
WORST: Ekko > Ultra > Ekko
CHARLIE: Ekko > unvote > Worst > Ekko
MANGO: Ekko
RATCHET: Ultra > Worst > Unvote > Ekko
JAGUARK: Worst
STARGATE: Worst
Boquise: Ekko

so basically every flipped mafia member was on ekko wagon
flipped towns: 5 for worst, 3 for ekko

idk if they'd all jump on the same wagon but looks like they really tried to save worst here i guess

out of people still in the game:
voted ekko
- me
- flower
- yoho
- orca
- hayumi

hasn't voted at all
- ytw

voted worst
- pero
- michelle

idk about michelle but at very least, i don't want to vote pero

assuming ninja thing isn't bastard, yoho should be good

so flower/orca/hayumi/ytw/michelle and apparently ytw/michelle share alignment

so it could be, if 2:
1. orca and flower
2. ytw and michelle

if 3:
1. hayumi/flower/orca
2. ytw&michelle + either orca or flower

meh, idk, i guess lynching one of michelle/ytw gives the most info in case game isn't over next dp if it's town

Should add YTW didn't cast a vote but tried to push the idea that both wagons were t/t

 

[Hayumi]

Should add YTW didn't cast a vote but tried to push the idea that both wagons were t/t

Great observation

 

[Charlie]

Should add YTW didn't cast a vote but tried to push the idea that both wagons were t/t

oh didn't remember that part, i thought he just wasn't there

this could be "i don't want to vote my scummate becaue it's close but i don't want all of us to be on the same wagon" thing

 

[Hayumi]

this is the only vc where scum barely escaped lynch afaik, right?

i mean, ekko vs worst on D2


ignoring dead people who hasn't voted either of them

EKKO: flower > worst > Polar Bear > Worst

FLOWER: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Worst > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
ORWELLIAN: Ekko > Worst
ULTRA: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Polar Bear > Ekko > Mango > Worst > Ekko > Worst
PERO: Ekko > Worst
YOHO: Ekko >
YORK: Ekko
ORCA: Ekko
LANJI: Ekko > Unvote > Ekko > Worst
MICHELLE: Ekko > Flower > Worst
HAYUMI: Flower > unvote > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
HIME: Ekko
WORST: Ekko > Ultra > Ekko
CHARLIE: Ekko > unvote > Worst > Ekko
MANGO: Ekko
RATCHET: Ultra > Worst > Unvote > Ekko
JAGUARK: Worst
STARGATE: Worst
Boquise: Ekko

so basically every flipped mafia member was on ekko wagon
flipped towns: 5 for worst, 3 for ekko

idk if they'd all jump on the same wagon but looks like they really tried to save worst here i guess

out of people still in the game:
voted ekko
- me
- flower
- yoho
- orca
- hayumi

hasn't voted at all
- ytw

voted worst
- pero
- michelle

idk about michelle but at very least, i don't want to vote pero

assuming ninja thing isn't bastard, yoho should be good

so flower/orca/hayumi/ytw/michelle and apparently ytw/michelle share alignment

so it could be, if 2:
1. orca and flower
2. ytw and michelle

if 3:
1. hayumi/flower/orca
2. ytw&michelle + either orca or flower

meh, idk, i guess lynching one of michelle/ytw gives the most info in case game isn't over next dp if it's town

See, if I can trust you and Perl that’s why I’m more inclined to think it’s just Michelle and YTW. Because Flower has blatantly and openly town read Orca the entire game.

but do you never have a world with Pero scum?

 

[Yoho]

this is the only vc where scum barely escaped lynch afaik, right?

i mean, ekko vs worst on D2


ignoring dead people who hasn't voted either of them

EKKO: flower > worst > Polar Bear > Worst

FLOWER: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Worst > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
ORWELLIAN: Ekko > Worst
ULTRA: Ekko > Flower > Ekko > Polar Bear > Ekko > Mango > Worst > Ekko > Worst
PERO: Ekko > Worst
YOHO: Ekko >
YORK: Ekko
ORCA: Ekko
LANJI: Ekko > Unvote > Ekko > Worst
MICHELLE: Ekko > Flower > Worst
HAYUMI: Flower > unvote > Ekko > Worst > Ekko
HIME: Ekko
WORST: Ekko > Ultra > Ekko
CHARLIE: Ekko > unvote > Worst > Ekko
MANGO: Ekko
RATCHET: Ultra > Worst > Unvote > Ekko
JAGUARK: Worst
STARGATE: Worst
Boquise: Ekko

so basically every flipped mafia member was on ekko wagon
flipped towns: 5 for worst, 3 for ekko

idk if they'd all jump on the same wagon but looks like they really tried to save worst here i guess

out of people still in the game:
voted ekko
- me
- flower
- yoho
- orca
- hayumi

hasn't voted at all
- ytw

voted worst
- pero
- michelle

idk about michelle but at very least, i don't want to vote pero

assuming ninja thing isn't bastard, yoho should be good

so flower/orca/hayumi/ytw/michelle and apparently ytw/michelle share alignment

so it could be, if 2:
1. orca and flower
2. ytw and michelle

if 3:
1. hayumi/flower/orca
2. ytw&michelle + either orca or flower

meh, idk, i guess lynching one of michelle/ytw gives the most info in case game isn't over next dp if it's town

It could be false hope but my neighbor chat with Yo tan makes me trust that he's town so I'd rather go for Michelle between the two since while I think she's town Its not as clear to me if she flips scum then that would make me reevaluate my Yotan read and if town that just reaffirms it

What's the case on Orca by the way I haven't been able to get a good reading on that slot

 

[Ultra]

My secret tinfoil is that Michelle is scum with some sort of bussing incentive since she pretty much went for worst straight away with no clear reason

 

[Ultra]

If anything Hayumi's result probably suggests there's one scum max in yo ton/Michelle since remaining mafia is probably 2 with one godfather

Unless there's 3 lmao

 

[Yoho]

Vote Lynch Michelle

 

[Hayumi]

My secret tinfoil is that Michelle is scum with some sort of bussing incentive since she pretty much went for worst straight away with no clear reason

Absolutely. I would be shocked if not a single scum was on Worst early. That’s always an optimal play to make to get town cred. And Michelle was never in a position to be worried early on.

She definitely seems smart enough to make that play, I know it’s what I would do.

 

[Charlie]

but do you never have a world with Pero scum?

simply voting for worst lynch when other 3 members tried to avoid it

reason why michelle's case is different is that i remember people saying in thread she's bussing her scummates a lot

 

[Ultra]

Really don't like Flower walking back on Pero

I can believe a certain degree of endgame confusion but she seems like, I dunno. Disingenuous? Bizarrely open?

Way off meta though, I think she'd have to be like a traitor or something

 

[Yoho]

If anything Hayumi's result probably suggests there's one scum max in yo ton/Michelle since remaining mafia is probably 2 with one godfather

Unless there's 3 lmao

Think so when I see compatible makes me think they're on the same side would town be compatible with scum?

Hime was compatible with Echo and one was scum the other a serial killer of some sort

Both working against town

At least that's how I understand it

 

[Hayumi]

I highly doubt we have 3 scum left tbh. Perhaps one more third party?

 

[Hayumi]

Think so when I see compatible makes me think they're on the same side would town be compatible with scum?

Hime was compatible with Echo and one was scum the other a serial killer of some sort

Both working against town

At least that's how I understand it

Well according to Fuji, because of Ekko’s passive that makes him favorable to investigations I should have actually gotten an incompatible result, but for an unknown reason he cannot explained I got a compatible instead.

 

[Charlie]

My secret tinfoil is that Michelle is scum with some sort of bussing incentive since she pretty much went for worst straight away with no clear reason

tbh, she tagged/quoted people to switch to RA, so even before worst, because he's been inactive

like, when RA is active

 

[Ultra]

Think so when I see compatible makes me think they're on the same side would town be compatible with scum?

Hime was compatible with Echo and one was scum the other a serial killer of some sort

Both working against town

At least that's how I understand it

They would scan as compatible if she hit the godfather

So logically if there's a godfather and only two mafia left, scanning both at once would always mean they're incompatible

Meaning those two are likely 50/50 at best, taken with a grain of salt

 

[Yoho]

Well according to Fuji, because of Ekko’s passive that makes him favorable to investigations I should have actually gotten an incompatible result, but for an unknown reason he cannot explained I got a compatible instead.

🧐