Questions & Mysteries POLL: What is a worse plot device Zoro getting the magic shot or Luffy eating his way to 100% after falling of Onigashima

[bennbeckman]

Post

 

[Absolute Justice]

Luffy eating

Zoro medicine is an asspull but it gives double the damage

Luffy just eats and boom he is fine

 

[Fleet_AdmiralKoby]

Luffy Eating His HP up always kinda bothered me
Gets ass handed to him by Rob Lucci. Proceeds to eat a Porkchop Boom* Nothing Happend
Yonko Level Injures can be Wished away with some Hot Sauce Marco and Law didnt even need to be there
Theres a Reason Luffy cant become Pirate King with out Sanji

 

[Roosta]

I voted Zoro because I think it's ridiculous the broken bones got fixed, and Luffy eating his way to 100% is something we've seen many times.

However, this time it seems like he ate himself to 150%, which I do find pretty ridiculous.

 

[matt245]

Imma go with Luffy, at least Zoro's has some consequences

 

[Adam 🍎]

Both

 

[Lightbolt]

Zoro had bones broken...on the other hand it is implied Luffy lost conscious due to unmastery of new haki...it was never implied Kaido broke his bone like Zoro

 

[Monster Luffy]

Luffy is not the one with broken bones. He just got white eyes/KOed by Kaidou. He didn't sustain any critical injury. If Luffy recovery is equivalent to magicnbean recovery, it is as much admittance as Luffy took Hakai level attack. If that is the case, I might agree with salty generation users who think that Luffy recovery is anything related to plot armor.

 

[Queek Hea D Taker]

Both

 

[sircrocodile666]

The magic shot was so much bullshit that it wasnt even forshadowed whatsoever.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

We’ve seen Luffy heal and recuperate through meat a bunch of times. The mink medicine had no build up or foreshadowing. The mink medicine is by far the worst

 

[Midnight Delight]

The mink medicine had no build up or foreshadowing

It was forshadowed on Zou

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

Luffy healing by eating meat has been going on forever.... happened with Crocodile, with Lucci, in Impel Down...etc!

Zoro's magic shot came out of nowhere Randy Orton RKO style....

 

[Sir Yasheen]

It was forshadowed on Zou

“Oh you minks heal quickly” is not proper foreshadowing especially when we spent so much time with carrot and Pedro. Oda had ample opportunity to actually foreshadow it and he didn’t

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

It was forshadowed on Zou

It was not.... that scene in Zou was talking about how the minks regrouped and healed very fast for a country that was destroyed is basically talking about how cheery they are with "Garcho" thingy....
Never once has it been foreshadowed that they have a drug... not once

 

[Steven]

Both

 

[Finalbeta]

Why was the medicine so contrived?

I mean this is a series where characters are healed their bones by drinking milk.

 

[Fn Lucci]

I don't know why people bitch about what's been happening for twenty years now. Luffy bounced back from being impaled by Crocodile and Lucci with less actual recovery.

The medicine Zoro received has an enormous consequence. He's about to experience the biggest attack in the series twice over, only a fool would call that cheap

 

[Black]

I am not a fan of the magic shot but at least it has some drawbacks.. unlike luffys full recovery just by eating meat lol.

 

[Finalbeta]

I am not a fan of the magic shot but at least it has some drawbacks.. unlike luffys full recovery just by eating meat lol.

Maybe they preferred if Zoro drank some milk.