General & Others Rank the Supernova based on importance to the plot

F

Formerly Seth

#21
As of now, I would do it like this:
1. Luffy, Kidd, Zoro
2. Law, Drake, Hawkins, Apoo
3. Killer
4. Bege, Bonney, Urouge where these three are completely irrelevant to the story for now
 
#25
  1. Luffy ( surprise surprise)
  2. Zoro ( bigger surprise)
  3. Law ( Law is basically a MC since PH and he has gained tremendous end-game relevance since his power stays in relation with the treasure in the Holy land)
  4. Kid ( Portrayed as Luffy's main SN rival)
  5. X Drake ( Captain of Sword, the unit that symbolizes the EOS "good" Marines)
  6. Bonney ( Yep, Bonney has a deeper connection to the WG, bond with Kuma, and likely will move with the RA from now on)
  7. Urouge ( Oda likely reserves him for Elbaf)
  8. Bege ( Think Oda is done with him)
  9. Hawkins ( it seems that he's done but he may or very likely help the alliance)
  10. Apoo ( He's done after Wano)
  11. Killer ( Subordinate of Kid)
 
#26
  1. Luffy ( surprise surprise)
  2. Zoro ( bigger surprise)
  3. Law ( Law is basically a MC since PH and he has gained tremendous end-game relevance since his power stays in relation with the treasure in the Holy land)
  4. Kid ( Portrayed as Luffy's main SN rival)
  5. X Drake ( Captain of Sword, the unit that symbolizes the EOS "good" Marines)
  6. Bonney ( Yep, Bonney has a deeper connection to the WG, bond with Kuma, and likely will move with the RA from now on)
  7. Urouge ( Oda likely reserves him for Elbaf)
  8. Bege ( Think Oda is done with him)
  9. Hawkins ( it seems that he's done but he may or very likely help the alliance)
  10. Apoo ( He's done after Wano)
  11. Killer ( Subordinate of Kid)
I’d like for Urouge to get a bigger role in the story, but I think that him beating Snack is pretty much all that we’ll get
 
#29
1.Monkey D Luffy
Doriki 762000
2.Eustass Kid
Doriki 698500
3.Trafalgar D Water Law
Doriki 641866
4.Diez Drake
Doriki 623000
5.Basil Hawkins
Doriki 600000
6.Scratchmann Apoo
Doriki 588999
7.Roronoa Zoro
Doriki 550200
8.Urouge
Doriki 550000
9.Jewerly Bonney
Doriki 421600
10.Capone Gang Bege
Doriki 420000
11.Killer
Doriki 208500
 
#33
Luffy and Zoro obviously miles in front

Then Law, and again for his part he's miles in front of the rest of the competition. He was a main character for 150 odd chapters. Has faded quite a bit since, but still is expected to play a fairly large role in the future compared to the other Supernovas.

Kid is next. Having said that, a lot of his stuff is based on what he's expected to do (and Onigashima is giving credence to that, to be fair) not what he's actually done, which is negligible.

Then we come to the three with potential big roles in the future. Bonney's the standout, given what Sakazuki said about her, her relationship with Kuma and her being involved in Reverie. That suggests an important role to the wider One Piece world well above what most Supernovas have. Drake's obviously got his SWORD thing going on, plus Oda's been giving us little snippets of his past with the Law flashback. Suggests he's got a decent plan for him. And Capone is the great surprise of the Supernova's, had a big role on WCI, could very well be coming back with his sister-in-law (and from the looks of things Gotti's new wife) to finish the Elbaf plot. Although I don't actually expect Capone himself to play a big role there, but he'll at least be there.

I struggle to separate Hawkins, Apoo, and Killer. If anything Killer gets a wee boost for being on Kid's crew and thus will be around with him after the arc. I don't have any expectations of Apoo and Hawkins outwith Wano, where they haven't had much of a role either. I think these guys very much show off the unplanned nature of the Supernovas, they aren't really anything more than powerful rookie pirates, and they've fastened their horse to the wrong chariot in Kaido, who's getting defeated now.

Urouge is dead last. Doesn't have any real, solid set up for the future, hasn't played a role in the past. Shame, because I love him. The only thing I can say for him is that because there's nothing big seemingly set up for him he's a card Oda can play at any time. And maybe, at a push, some Moon history stuff given he seems to be Birkan.
 
#34
It’s really difficult to tell past Luffy, Law (D.) Zoro (PK crew mate), Kid (rival). I will say the 5 Captains with the highest bounties (So add X Drake and Hawkins) seemed to stand out and Bonney, too.

So... 1)luffy 2)law/zoro/kid 5) x drake 6) Bonney 7) hawkins 8) Urouge 9) killer 10) Bege 11) Apoo

I believe Oda would’ve forgotten about most of the Supernovas had it not been for Law’s Unprecedented relevancy. Law has gone over so well he decided to elevate all the rest of them. Other than Kid, none of them were meant to be particularly important.
 
Top