General & Others Rank the Wano fights
- Thread starter Chrono
- Start date
- SHs fights
Robin and Brook vs Black Maria = 9/10
Law and Kid vs BM = 8/10
Jinbe vs WsW = 7/10
Luffy vs Kaido = 6.5/10
Zoro vs King = 6.5/10
Sanji vs Queen = 6.5/10
Franky vs Sasaki = 6/10
Nami and Usopp vs Ulti and P1 = 4/10
- Others
Red Scabbards vs Kaido = 10/10
Hawkins vs Killer = 7/10
Raizo vs Fukuroukuju = Raizo/10
Robin and Brook vs Black Maria = 9/10
Law and Kid vs BM = 8/10
Jinbe vs WsW = 7/10
Luffy vs Kaido = 6.5/10
Zoro vs King = 6.5/10
Sanji vs Queen = 6.5/10
Franky vs Sasaki = 6/10
Nami and Usopp vs Ulti and P1 = 4/10
- Others
Red Scabbards vs Kaido = 10/10
Hawkins vs Killer = 7/10
Raizo vs Fukuroukuju = Raizo/10
Last edited:
1. Robin vs Black Maria. 10. For a fight that’s not got one of the main fighters it’s about the best you can hope for.
2. Zoro vs King. 9. The fanboy in me wants to put this higher but the ending was rushed and King poorly used before the fight
3. Jinbei vs WW. 8. All-round decent fight, but I would have preferred Jinbei get a stronger opponent that could have challenged him.
4. Killer vs Hawkins. 7. This was a really cool fight. Would like to have seen more of it
5. Luffy vs Kaido. 7. A lot of highs but some very weird lows that drag it down. Quite fitting for the main fight of Wano in that respect.
6. Franky vs Sasaki. 6. Okay. Should have been one chapter longer.
7. Kid and Law vs Big Mom. 5. Some interesting DF use but I’m not happy with Big Mom being demoted to Kaido’s sidekick and being beaten by two characters she had next to no relationship with prior
8. Nami vs Ulti. 3. Atrocious ending but a good beginning and middle.
9. Sanji vs Queen. 2. A dismal fight with huge doses of PIS, dreadful choreography, a laughable “dilemma” and an awful climax. But at least the RS was destroyed.
10. Inu and Neko vs Jack and Perospero. 1. Oda didn’t even care about these fights, why should I?
11. Page One. 0. Appalling.
2. Zoro vs King. 9. The fanboy in me wants to put this higher but the ending was rushed and King poorly used before the fight
3. Jinbei vs WW. 8. All-round decent fight, but I would have preferred Jinbei get a stronger opponent that could have challenged him.
4. Killer vs Hawkins. 7. This was a really cool fight. Would like to have seen more of it
5. Luffy vs Kaido. 7. A lot of highs but some very weird lows that drag it down. Quite fitting for the main fight of Wano in that respect.
6. Franky vs Sasaki. 6. Okay. Should have been one chapter longer.
7. Kid and Law vs Big Mom. 5. Some interesting DF use but I’m not happy with Big Mom being demoted to Kaido’s sidekick and being beaten by two characters she had next to no relationship with prior
8. Nami vs Ulti. 3. Atrocious ending but a good beginning and middle.
9. Sanji vs Queen. 2. A dismal fight with huge doses of PIS, dreadful choreography, a laughable “dilemma” and an awful climax. But at least the RS was destroyed.
10. Inu and Neko vs Jack and Perospero. 1. Oda didn’t even care about these fights, why should I?
11. Page One. 0. Appalling.
Luffy vs Kaido - 9/10 - I think the theming of the fight needed work but I really enjoyed the abilities that both used. It felt like a throwback to Luffys OG fighting styles before gear 4.
Zoro vs King - 8.5/10 - I think this fight had the best choreography and would be much better if kings character and ideals was introduced before the fight and not at the tail end
Sanji vs Queen - 8/10 - I think this fight suffered the opposite issue of the king fight. The characterization of both characters were great and the ideals introduced before the fight gave good payoff. Just choreography was bad. (But can be fixed in anime so may be a good anime fight)
Robin vs Black Maria - 6/10 - Fight was enjoyable and I liked Black Marias power set. The finisher is what makes it the best TR Fight.
Franky vs Sasaki - 5.5/10 - Not Franky best fight and Sasaki was pretty meh. The humor fell a little flat but Franky looked like a force to be reckoned with here so always great.
Law and Kid vs Big Mom - 5/10 - For a yonko fight this was so disappointing. Big moms appears we’re cool but we didn’t really get to see them much outside of misery. It was just a showcase of laws and kids awakenings which kids felt lackluster. And the ending with the bombs were awful.
Jinbe vs Who’s Who - 4/10 - By far the worst fight on onigashima. Although the choreography was good, Who’s Whos entire characterization was so wishy washy it made no sense and made this fight so bad. It went from “I have more important things to worry about than luffy” -> “I’ll fight jinbe because he’s a warlord and the WG betrayed me” -> “Straw hat luffy ruined my life.” Like really… it would’ve been so much better if oda scrapped who’s who’s character and just made him an ex NW captain.
Zoro vs King - 8.5/10 - I think this fight had the best choreography and would be much better if kings character and ideals was introduced before the fight and not at the tail end
Sanji vs Queen - 8/10 - I think this fight suffered the opposite issue of the king fight. The characterization of both characters were great and the ideals introduced before the fight gave good payoff. Just choreography was bad. (But can be fixed in anime so may be a good anime fight)
Robin vs Black Maria - 6/10 - Fight was enjoyable and I liked Black Marias power set. The finisher is what makes it the best TR Fight.
Franky vs Sasaki - 5.5/10 - Not Franky best fight and Sasaki was pretty meh. The humor fell a little flat but Franky looked like a force to be reckoned with here so always great.
Law and Kid vs Big Mom - 5/10 - For a yonko fight this was so disappointing. Big moms appears we’re cool but we didn’t really get to see them much outside of misery. It was just a showcase of laws and kids awakenings which kids felt lackluster. And the ending with the bombs were awful.
Jinbe vs Who’s Who - 4/10 - By far the worst fight on onigashima. Although the choreography was good, Who’s Whos entire characterization was so wishy washy it made no sense and made this fight so bad. It went from “I have more important things to worry about than luffy” -> “I’ll fight jinbe because he’s a warlord and the WG betrayed me” -> “Straw hat luffy ruined my life.” Like really… it would’ve been so much better if oda scrapped who’s who’s character and just made him an ex NW captain.
Ngl yall hating on sanjis fight for no reason. I think it's one of the best written fights in the series.
I'd rank it an 8/10
Sanji underwent allot. Mentally and physically and the pay off was sweet.
I'd put zoros at an 8/10 also.
I generally feel like no one truly appreciates one piece like I do. They are so caught up in their bias and agenda to truly enjoy the series.
I'd rank it an 8/10
Sanji underwent allot. Mentally and physically and the pay off was sweet.
I'd put zoros at an 8/10 also.
I generally feel like no one truly appreciates one piece like I do. They are so caught up in their bias and agenda to truly enjoy the series.
Luffy vs Kaidou phase 3: 10/10
Luffy vs Kaidou phase 4: 10/10
Kid e Law vs Big Mom: 9 (Oda was very creative with Law's techniques, the fight emotions were great, BM's choreography was not bad, several panels were very good - The fact that Kid let down doesn't make it a bad fight)
Luffy+SNs vs Kaidou phase 1: 8/10
Luffy vs Kaidou phase 2: 8/10
Zoro vs King: 9/10
Yamato vs Kaido: 8/10 (excellent choreography)
Sanji vs Queen: 7/10
Killer vs Hawnkis: 7/10
Robin vs Maria: 6/10
Jinbei vs WW: 6/10
Franky vs Sasaki: 5.5/10
Kaido vs Scabbards: IDK
Luffy vs Kaidou phase 4: 10/10
Kid e Law vs Big Mom: 9 (Oda was very creative with Law's techniques, the fight emotions were great, BM's choreography was not bad, several panels were very good - The fact that Kid let down doesn't make it a bad fight)
Luffy+SNs vs Kaidou phase 1: 8/10
Luffy vs Kaidou phase 2: 8/10
Zoro vs King: 9/10
Yamato vs Kaido: 8/10 (excellent choreography)
Sanji vs Queen: 7/10
Killer vs Hawnkis: 7/10
Robin vs Maria: 6/10
Jinbei vs WW: 6/10
Franky vs Sasaki: 5.5/10
Kaido vs Scabbards: IDK
The story told in Sanji’s fight is melodramatic garbage treading over the exact same ground as WCI, where it wasn’t especially interesting either.
Sanji’s dilemma is not interesting because the Vinsmokes are shit, boring characters and there’s no way that Oda would upset the status quo enough for any of the supposed issues facing Sanji to have any real consequences.
Sanji’s dilemma is not interesting because the Vinsmokes are shit, boring characters and there’s no way that Oda would upset the status quo enough for any of the supposed issues facing Sanji to have any real consequences.
Zoro vs king=+10/10 best choreography 
The rest
Sanji vs Queen=8/10 when Queen got serious the fight was amazing but it fucked up with the whore situation
Inu vs Jack=4/10 I liked the last attack with the sword
Jinbe vs Ww=9/10 I liked it and it had a very good choreography even it was a low diff
Robin vs Black maria=9.5/10 they same with Jinbe but liked it more
Franky vs Sasaki=7/10 it was good
Dino bros fight better not to talk
Neko vs peros=2/10
Killer vs Hawkins=9/10 very enjoyable and a great moment for willer
Kid and law vs meme=6/10 I expected more haki feats but it wasn't that bad
Luffy vs kaido=like the beginning it was 10/10 later with the nika situation it got 7/10
The rest
Sanji vs Queen=8/10 when Queen got serious the fight was amazing but it fucked up with the whore situation
Inu vs Jack=4/10 I liked the last attack with the sword
Jinbe vs Ww=9/10 I liked it and it had a very good choreography even it was a low diff
Robin vs Black maria=9.5/10 they same with Jinbe but liked it more
Franky vs Sasaki=7/10 it was good
Dino bros fight better not to talk
Neko vs peros=2/10
Killer vs Hawkins=9/10 very enjoyable and a great moment for willer
Kid and law vs meme=6/10 I expected more haki feats but it wasn't that bad
Luffy vs kaido=like the beginning it was 10/10 later with the nika situation it got 7/10