General & Others Rate Every One Piece Arc Post Timeskip so far

[pg13]

0=Trash/Worst Arc in The Series
5=Mid/Mediocre/Avg
10=Perfect/Peak/Best Arc in The Series

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 7/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6.7/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

Elbaf - TBD but so far 8.1/10


Drop Your Ratings Below

 

[ZenZu]

Fishman Island - 4/10
Punk Hazard - 5/10
Dressrosa - 5/10
Zou - 7/10
Wholecake Island - 3/10
Wano Arc - 2/10
Egghead - 6.5/10

 

[MUUGEN]

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 7/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6.7/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

Elbaf - TBD but so far 8.1/10

FMI 2/5
PH 3.5/5
DR 3/5
Zou 2.5/5
WCI 3.75/5
Wano 3/5
EH 4/5
Elbaf 5/5

 

[Franosuke]

@lee33

 

[Fn Lucci]

For reference: East Blue, Alabasta, Jaya/Skypiea, and DBF/Water Seven would be at 10 as the kind of arcs that make the series.

Fishman Island Arc - 6/10
Punk Hazard Arc - 7/10
Dressrosa Arc - 8/10
Zou- 8.5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 6/10
Egghead Island Arc - 6/10

Overall still pretty good but so many particularly shitty spots. Elbaf is kinda ass

 

[NikaInParis]

Fishman Island Arc - 3/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 10/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 5.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

 

[Wanderer]

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10 (just bad and boring acr, but atleast have a great flashback and good art)
Punk Hazzard Arc - 6/10 (could be hier, but too long, too tedious, to much Law and to little SH)
Dressrosa Arc - 7,5/10
Zou- 8,5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 9/10
Wano Arc - 7/10
Egghead Island Arc - 0/10 (not trash, but worst arc in the series)

Elbaf - TBD but so far 5,5/10 (Rocks flashback is saving the day, the rest is really bad)

 

[Yakyu]

Fishman Island - 5/10 (great for lore, flashback and Luffy/Jimbe scene, but the worst group of enemies and pacing were pure pain)
Punk Hazard - 6/10
Dressrosa - 6/10
Zou - 8/10
Wholecake Island - 7/10 (wedding cake shit hurt this arc so freaking much bro)
Wano Arc - 7/10 (Oda stalled WAY more than any other arc and we had the whole "I'm Oden" shit from Yamato)
Egghead - 8/10

 

[MonsterKaido]

Fishman Island Arc - 2/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 8/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 10/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 6.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 9/10

Elbaf - 10/10 so far

 

[Uncle Van]

Fishman Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 2/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 4.5/10

Punk Hazard
Thematic Storytelling 4/10
Characters 7/10
Execution 7/10
Overall 6/10

Dressrosa
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 3/10
Execution 6/10
Overall 6.5/10

Zou
Thematic Storytelling 7/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 10/10
Overall 8/10

Whole Cake Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 7/10

Wano
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 4/10
Execution 2/10
Overall 5/10

Egghead
Thematic Storytelling 6/10
Characters 5/10
Execution 1/10
Overall 4/10

 

[Sir Yasheen]

FMI - 5/10
Punk Hazard - 5/10
Dressrosa - 7/10
Zou - 7/10
WCI - 8/10
Wano - 3/10
Egghead - 6/10

 

[Senfret]

Overall One piece is an 8.9 in my opinion

 

[Fn Lucci]

Fishman Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 2/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 4.5/10

Punk Hazard
Thematic Storytelling 4/10
Characters 7/10
Execution 7/10
Overall 6/10

Dressrosa
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 3/10
Execution 6/10
Overall 6.5/10

Zou
Thematic Storytelling 7/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 10/10
Overall 8/10

Whole Cake Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 7/10

Wano
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 4/10
Execution 2/10
Overall 5/10

Egghead
Thematic Storytelling 6/10
Characters 5/10
Execution 1/10
Overall 4/10

What does "characters" mean, and how does Dressrosa get a 3/10 while Zou is 8/10 and even WCI is 8/10?

 

[mly90]

Fishman Island - 3/10
Punk Hazard - 4/10
Dressrosa - 6/10
Zou - 6/10
Wholecake Island - 1/10
Wano Arc - 0/10
Egghead - 2/10

 

[SkySanji]

Fishman Island Arc - 3/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4/10
Dressrosa Arc - 5/10
Zou- 5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6/10
Wano Arc - 9/10
Egghead Island Arc - 5/10

 

[park_min young]

Fishman Island — 5/10
Punk Hazard — 9/10
Dressrosa —7.5/10
Zou — 8/10
WCI —7/10
Wano — -1/10
Egghead — 7.5/10

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Fishman Island - 6/10
Punk Hazard - 7/10
Dressrosa - 7.5/10
Zou - 7.5/10
Wholecake Island - 7.5/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead - 2/10
Elbaf - need to see how it ends but it's good so far

 

[Topi Jerami]

Fishman Island 10/10
Very memorable villains Hody Jones and Van Der Decken, I still see people discussing them everyday in 2025
Good focus on Fishman Karate Dojo that I already excited about since elementary school

Punk Hazard 10/10
So happy Momo and Kinemon tagging along for arcs later (the duo are far more likeable than Vivi and Carue duo)
Caesar KOed Luffy, repeating what Crocodile did twice in Alabasta. GG Caesar

Dressrosa 10/10
Sabo is still alive I am very happy
Gladiators joining to be Luffy's cocksucker, that's my dream too if I lived in One Piece world

Zou 10/10
Carrot's debut my favorite post TS character

WCI 10/10
Carrot tagging along she got great chemistry with equally good character post TS Chopper
My favorite Straw Hat, Sanji pulling another Mr. Prince except he was in Kamabakka 2 years so it was Mrs. Princess moment but still good

Wano 10/10
"Are you having fun, Kaido?" Of course I as the reader had fun too reading Luffy vs Kaido
Nika's debut horray

Egghead 10/10
Gorosei are very competent. If Lucci was the big dog in Water 7, now he becomes little puppy in Gorosei's presence
Gorosei are very competent too just like the government in my country, hidup Jokowi @GrandmasterChef Zonji

Elbaf Shakky/10
Shakky Valley flashback -> peak One Piece

 

[Kizaruber Eats]

@lee33

Miss the GOAT along with Pooth.

 

[MUUGEN]

What does "characters" mean, and how does Dressrosa get a 3/10 while Zou is 8/10 and even WCI is 8/10?

up until EH WCI was the best post-TS arc.