General & Others Rate One Piece's writing

[Light D Lamperouge]

Title.

​

 

[Franosuke]

Pre-TS: 8 or 9
Post-TS until Wano: Like a 5
Wano: 2 on a good day

 

[Unlimited Rulebook]

Story-wise: 5/10-so many inconsistencies but some good points
Battles: 4/10 a couple bright spots but mostly meh
Worlds/environments: 10/10 Oda is THE standard
Intangibles 9/10: OP has a charm that is endearing

Overall 7/10

 

[Uncle Van]

Preskip
Thematic Story Telling- 10/10
Execution- 8/10

Postskip
Thematic Story Telling- 8/10
Execution- 4/10

 

[VisualKei]

Pre-TS: 9/10

Post-TS: 7/10

 

[wordy]

Oda has the ability to be a great writer-- that's why he disappoints people so hard and they lose their minds.

He is not good at plot progression. He admitted in that interview with Aoyama that he'd prefer to just draw all the ideas in his head and that storyboards are hard for him.

He also seems to be off his leash more than ever and doing whatever he wants, even to the point of doing things he knows people will hate. Oda is obviously a good story teller, since he's got so many people hooked, but he needs someone to reel him in and keep him on track so that the rest of the story doesn't become a train wreck.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

World building lore and themes - 10
Execution of said world building lore and themes - 5

 

[Finalbeta]

3/10 for Wano

 

[Boiroy]

2/10 Wano

 

[Seven7]

Pre time skip 9/10
Post time skip 6/10
Wano 1/10

 

[Finalbeta]

0/10 for Wano

 

[Herrera95]

He is not good at plot progression.

Oda is obviously a good story teller

since he's got so many people hooked

He was good until timeskip, that he is on a constant downfall that accelerated at WCI and even harder at Wano.

 

[wordy]

He was good until timeskip, that he is on a constant downfall that accelerated at WCI and even harder at Wano.

I'm differentiating between "story teller" and "writer." Even children can be great story tellers. I don't disagree that quality has gone down.

 

[Herrera95]

I'm differentiating between "story teller" and "writer." Even children can be great story tellers. I don't disagree that quality has gone down.

I'm saying he hold many because he was great for a good time and decent for a good time too. One Piece is like 25 years old. For 20 years he was great/good and for 5 years he is bad/horrible.

I didn't understood your difference between story teller and writer.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

Actual Eiichiro Oda... 10/10 (until ts)

The team of interns/assistants/editors who replaced him, 2/10

 

[PeperLevi]

After Shitty Country Arc,there is no other answer than 0.
We should change the forum's name and start to discuss more often other fictions that are truly worth it.

 

[Cross_Marian]

It’s a mess right now

 

[SkySanji]

11/10

Greatest piece of fiction ever written

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Pre-TS: 8/10
Post-TS: 5/10
Wano: 3/10

Overall, a 5 or 6.

 

[Wh1p]

A lot of y'all are really invested in what you consider a 5/10 or below.