Bougya Rate the One Piece Manga Overall

[Light D Lamperouge]

Just as the title says, rate the One Piece manga. Compare it to other manga, say what its good/bad points are, if you wish, etc etc.

 

[Mathias]

It’s a 10 but the author is copying Naruto for the ending

 

[Rej]

It transcended, others didn't.
10/10 it sets the bar despite its flaws and imperfections.

 

[Logiko]

One Piece is more than just a manga story, it goes being the medium. In term of impact and quality, it rivals the best stories in existence.

It’s a 10 but the author is copying Naruto for the ending

Oda probably had his ending a long time before Naruto's one lol
Plus there are not a lot of similarities.

 

[Nadel]

With the increase in swordsmen in the manga, it improved somewhat, hoping for more of the mysteries of the swordsmen and their swords, especially Yoru

 

[Welkin]

Surprised the responses have been so positive (up to this point, once others see this post it’s cooked)

I’d say it’s a 10 personally

Greatest story ever told for me

It has its flaws obviously but I can’t help but love it

 

[Worthy Man]

One Piece is the kind of reading that captivates the audience and is extremely enjoyable to read; you can have fun and build anticipation for the next chapter. However, after the time skip, I feel that some of the magic of "I can't wait for the next adventure" faded a little. Nevertheless, in my opinion, it remains a very good manga, with an extremely rich plot and a captivating story.

Rating: 9/10

 

[ZenZu]

Literally (objectively) half the series is filler, it can't possibly be anything higher than 7 at this point, being generous.

 

[FutureWarrior123]

9.5/10.

1000+ chapter story is bound to have its quality ebb and flow but the scale and ambition behind the story is unprecedented across all mediums, while still delivering an engaging narrative that keeps readers invested.

 

[GeneralP123]

It's my favorite manga of all time, however I'll wait for it to finish before giving it a 10/10, if the ending Isn't good, it may drop far below a 9.

 

[Nolimittweezy]

10/10

 

[Owl Ki]

Aye, I've had a good bit of entertainment from it over the years but the longer it goes on, the more pacing becomes a serious problem regarding its entertainment value to me.

6/10 overall.

 

[Nidai_Kitetsu]

7 overall

Pre-timeskip: 10/10
Post-timeskip: 4/10

 

[Hina91]

Post timeskip really good tho, but still naruto > one piece, most op villains are incompetent

 

[Luffy is the mc]

8/10, I prefer pre TS but I still enjoy post TS most of the time.

 

[ZoroFan23]

7 overall, if Sanji didn't exist it'd go up to an 8.

 

[AverageBuggyEnjoyer]

Scale isn't high enough, where is 100/10 @Light D Lamperouge?

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

5/10 if I'm being generous. Naruto is objectively the far superior manga

 

[gz89]

Pre ts - 8/10
Post ts (so far) - 4/10

Overall 6/10 but from the way the story is going right now it looks like the ending will be crap so it's very likely to be even lower in the end.

 

[Tai long]

an 8/10. but an 8 for 1000+ chapter is better than a 10 for <100 chapter