Questions & Mysteries Roger did not say "King of the pirates" to Whitebeard and Oden

[ImmaIvanoM]

Roger DIDN'T say "King of the pirates" here to Whitebeard and Oden. He attributes that title to the newspapers.

Meaning Luffy didn't say this as a kid to Ace and Sabo too since its implied he said the same thing as Roger

They probably said "Freest man on the sea"

My bet is we learn what they both said in Shanks' flashback since Shanks said to Rayleigh in Sabaody that "Luffy said what Roger did" and that's why he gave him the strawhat. Also shanks is the most only person who could possibly know what both Roger and Luffy said since both Roger and Luffy probably repeated this line a couple of times and only Shanks was around both of them and in a single flashback we will learn what both said

 

[HA001]

King of the world

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

They probably said "Freest man on the sea"

Wouldn´t fit in the scenario where Luffy said the same word as Roger.
The whole sentence with Luffy,Ace and Sabo was only because Ace wanted to be a great person, then Luffy said the same word as Roger.
Freest man on the sea wouldn´t fit to the sentence, so Luffy must said something greater like "King of the World" else their.

 

[HA001]

Maybe not even king of the world.
What was Im samas title ? King of all ?

 

[Gargo]

From what I know of Luffy. It could be meat, party, fight, freedom, adventure or people.

From what I know of Roger it could be fight, party, freedom, adventure or people.

Ace wanted to be love and accepted.

If it is not King of pirates It is not Fight.
If it is not Free man of the sea it is not Adventure or Freedom.

That could e party or People.

I would say like Naruto : A guy everybody of every Island can count one

 

[Luffy is the mc]

He said something else than pirate king otherwise it would have been showed, he wasn't even aware of that word at the time.
Pirate king was something the wg or the newspapers came up with.

 

[Rmstorm]

From what I know of Luffy. It could be meat, party, fight, freedom, adventure or people.

From what I know of Roger it could be fight, party, freedom, adventure or people.

Ace wanted to be love and accepted.

If it is not King of pirates It is not Fight.
If it is not Free man of the sea it is not Adventure or Freedom.

That could e party or People.

I would say like Naruto : A guy everybody of every Island can count one

Its freest man on the sea, as you can see below.

Here is what Roger says

 

[trav]

... dead

 

[raptorking]

could of said "then i will be dead" but i think king of the pirates myself.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

“That’s right!! And then I’ll be...comfortable enough in my own skin to come out as a transgender woman!!”

#OkamaKingOfPirates

 

[stealthblack]

I want to free the world. From cds

 

[trav]

That's right!!
And then I'll be...

... massively overrated!

 

[Luffy is the mc]

That's right!!
And then I'll be...

... massively overrated!

More than mihawk or shanks?

 

[ardym]

you are right , most likely he said the same thing that Luffy told Ace and Sabo in chapter 585, that panel was cut as well. i think that are the words that Shanks was referring to as well as he told Rayleigh that Luffy said the same words as Roger, and maybe because of those words Shanks decided to bet on Luffy

 

[Évêque Izáya]

The man with the biggest freedom in the world,would be my bet as well.

 

[Finalbeta]

More than mihawk or shanks?

How are they. Unless you mean PK levels.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

How are they. Unless you mean PK levels.

I meant stronger or equal. I've read that here.

 

[stealthblack]

maybe roger said : I want to be a superhero.

that is why they laughed and called him kid

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Wouldn´t fit in the scenario where Luffy said the same word as Roger.
The whole sentence with Luffy,Ace and Sabo was only because Ace wanted to be a great person, then Luffy said the same word as Roger.
Freest man on the sea wouldn´t fit to the sentence, so Luffy must said something greater like "King of the World" else their.

So then Roger and Luffy said different things?

 

[Rmstorm]

So then Roger and Luffy said different things?

No, because Shanks said Luffy said the exact same words as Roger.