Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

[HA001]

If Luffy pick up a Sword and uses to enhance his powers and Haki, him will be a Swordsman?

So if luffy started fighting like zoro you mean

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

So if luffy started fighting like zoro you mean

No, fighting like Roger or Big Mom.

 

[HA001]

No, fighting like Roger or Big Mom.

Roger fights like zoro
With a supreme grade sword
Which means you need swordsmanship mastery to use a supreme grade sword

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Roger fights like zoro
With a supreme grade sword
Which means you need swordsmanship mastery to use a supreme grade sword

WB?
[automerge]1712237029[/automerge]

Roger fights like zoro
With a supreme grade sword
Which means you need swordsmanship mastery to use a supreme grade sword

Where is Roger cutting feat?

 

[сука]

If Luffy pick up a Sword and uses to enhance his powers and Haki, him will be a Swordsman?

Ask the same thing about any other character in any other story and the answer would be yes.

Wonder why you and other people only make an exception for one piece.

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Ask the same thing about any other character in any other story and the answer would be yes.

Wonder why you and other people only make an exception for one piece.

The answer is no, simple because Swordsman are guys who are trained his whole life to be a Swordsman.

 

[сука]

The answer is no, simple because Swordsman are guys who are trained his whole life to be a Swordsman.

Roger, Shanks etc.

 

[gz89]

The answer is no, simple because Swordsman are guys who are trained his whole life to be a Swordsman.

Why did non swordsman Shanks challenged swordsman Mihawk multiple times ? Did he stole his chocolates ?

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Roger, Shanks etc.

Roger doesn't has any sword on the Rayleigh's remembering Memories.

Shanks has, him is a Swordsman.

 

[SkySanji]

Why did non swordsman Shanks challenged swordsman Mihawk multiple times ? Did he stole his chocolates ?

How do you know it wasn't Mihawk that challenged Shanks?

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Why did non swordsman Shanks challenged swordsman Mihawk multiple times ? Did he stole his chocolates ?

Since when i said something about Shanks? The question here is Roger.
[automerge]1712238211[/automerge]
Show me a Cutting feat of Roger

 

[сука]

Roger doesn't has any sword on the Rayleigh's remembering Memories.

Shanks has, him is a Swordsman.

Roger wasn't using haki in Rayleigh's flashback either, it means Roger has no haki

 

[gz89]

How do you know it wasn't Mihawk that challenged Shanks?

He was the famous one back in the day.

Ace wanted to fight WB for recognition not the other way around. Even in real life you will never see the champ searching for opponents its the other guys trying to challenge the champ.
[automerge]1712238807[/automerge]

Since when i said something about Shanks? The question here is Roger.

Whats their difference ? They are both among the strongest swordsmen.

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

He was the famous one back in the day.

Ace wanted to fight WB for recognition not the other way around. Even in real life you will never see the champ searching for opponents its the other guys trying to challenge the champ.
[automerge]1712238807[/automerge]


Whats their difference ? They are both among the strongest swordsmen.

Difference is that Roger wasn't confirmed a Swordsman, while Shanks is.
[automerge]1712239319[/automerge]

Roger wasn't using haki in Rayleigh's flashback either, it means Roger has no haki

What a bullshit argument, Luffy in Wano was swordsman.

 

[gz89]

Difference is that Roger wasn't confirmed a Swordsman, while Shanks is.

So swordsman Shanks uses non swordsman Roger's move to honor his memory ?

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

So swordsman Shanks uses non swordsman Roger's move to honor his memory ?

While not? So the Giants are Swordsmans, because BM uses his attacks with a Sword?

 

[сука]

What a bullshit argument, Luffy in Wano was swordsman.

That bullshit argument is your argument. Now show me young Roger using haki, otherwise he obviously doesn't have haki.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

What I want to know is why does Oda make all these Legendary figures Swordsmen, and directly link them to Luffy, and not the man who wants to be the WSS? Kind of messed up..... The man who rivals Ryuma. The Man who will surpass Gol D. Roger.

Oda is directly telling us that Luffy will be above all the Strongest Swordsmen who ever lived by EoS..... Wild...

Well EoS Luffy is more likely than not going be top 1 of all time so that doesn't really mean anything.






Personally I do believe Roger is a swordsman, but I find it odd that Zoro never showed any interest in him.

 

[сука]

Personally I do believe Roger is a swordsman, but I find it odd that Zoro never showed any interest in him.

I also find it odd that current boxing champions never show interest in fighting Muhammad Ali.

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

That bullshit argument is your argument. Now show me young Roger using haki, otherwise he obviously doesn't have haki.

What this has something in common with Roger who doesn't was showed using Sword, doesn't has any sword with him.

Haki man is bullshit like All characters who uses Swords are Swordsmans.
[automerge]1712239907[/automerge]

I also find it odd that current boxing champions never show interest in fighting Muhammad Ali.

Why didn't Zoro mentions Roger? Or Shanks? Because if Roger is a swordsman Zoro would mention him.

Muhammad Ali is mentioned all the time by Boxers.