Questions & Mysteries Rooftop LVP?

#1
We know the MVP was luffy, closely followed by Zoro

But who was the Least Valuable Player(LVP)? Law hurt Kaido with a gamma knife, and Killer managed to hurt him too. Only one who didn't land a meaningful strike was Kid.

For the reasons stated above, Eustass "Captain" Kid is my vote for the LVP of RoofPiece
 
#3
Kidd, his only contribution was creating a cage for Zeus and lift Big Mom in the air, but we know that Law could have just teleported Zeus out of the way.
Other than that, he didn't damage anybody, talk too much, distracting the other fighters. Very sad performance, he is lucky that Oda likes him a lot and forced his undeserved presence on the rooftop.
 
#4
Kidd, his only contribution was creating a cage for Zeus and lift Big Mom in the air, but we know that Law could have just teleported Zeus out of the way.
Other than that, he didn't damage anybody, talk too much, distracting the other fighters. Very sad performance, he is lucky that Oda likes him a lot and force his undeserved presence on the rooftop.
Kinda fitting he gets 1 shot by a yonko when he's on his own
 
#7
Depends on what your timespan is for MVP...

if its the entire rooftop fights, then yeah Luffy

but if you mean "Roofpiece", where the 5 supernovas fought BM/Kaido

then its Zoro

contribution order in total is

Luffy - Zoro - Yamato - Law - Scabbards - Killer - Fall Damage - Kidd
Just Roofpiece. I've personally got Luffy, but Zoro is a fair shout
Post automatically merged:

Zoro LVP for sure

he did nothing

MVP is Enma
Unarmed Zoro LVP for sure
 
#10
Kidd, his only contribution was creating a cage for Zeus and lift Big Mom in the air, but we know that Law could have just teleported Zeus out of the way.
Other than that, he didn't damage anybody, talk too much, distracting the other fighters. Very sad performance, he is lucky that Oda likes him a lot and forced his undeserved presence on the rooftop.
No he couldn't have. Zeus and Prometheus would have just returned to BM if they were teleported away. Which is why they needed a method of keeping Prometheus and Zeus away from BM.
For Prometheus, Zoro was slicing him via his flamerend technique. For Zeus, it was the cage Kid created.

Fundamentally, Kid was a major reason why they were able to separate Kaido from Big Mom and they likely would have been unable to do so without his help.

At the time Luffy was KO'd and Zoro had just taken heavy damage, so the only people who could have really done something was Kid, Killer, and Law.

Kid played a crucial role, not only in trapping Zeus, but also in repelling BM into the sky so Law could knock her off the roof via tact. This was a unique role that only Kid could have played, as NONE of the other members of the roof had powers that could have done this. Zoro can only slash, not repel. Law has tact, but tact doesn't have the raw force that magnetism has. Hence, Kid was the only one who could have knocked BM into the sky and given Law the opening to knock her out.
 
#13
And it is specifically because of the major role Kid played in knocking BM out of the rooftop. In trapping Zeus and lifting her into the sky, that BM was more focused on him than the other members and chased him down into the castle, separating her from Luffy and Zoro, and allowing them to damage Kaido.

Legit, without Kid, BM stays on the roof and Luffy and Zoro die.
 
#15
We know the MVP was luffy, closely followed by Zoro

But who was the Least Valuable Player(LVP)? Law hurt Kaido with a gamma knife, and Killer managed to hurt him too. Only one who didn't land a meaningful strike was Kid.
This isn't even true. Kid's body slam made Kaido scream and he subsequently acknowledged that the supernova were able to hurt him. Fans just headcanon that Kid did no damage because they cannot conceive that a body slam could hurt kaido.

LVP was Killer because not only did he not do much damage, he just didn't do much in general and needed Luffy to save him from getting eaten by Kaido. Kid at least could mostly hold his own on the roof(save for Hakai, where Zoro saved everyone) and played a major role in separating BM from kaido.
 
#16
This isn't even true. Kid's body slam made Kaido scream and he subsequently acknowledged that the supernova were able to hurt him. Fans just headcanon that Kid did no damage because they cannot conceive that a body slam could hurt kaido.

LVP was Killer because not only did he not do much damage, he just didn't do much in general and needed Luffy to save him from getting eaten by Kaido. Kid at least could mostly hold his own on the roof(save for Hakai, where Zoro saved everyone) and played a major role in separating BM from kaido.
Gibson Slam didn't do anything tbh



Killer and Law's attacks look like they hurt him

No disagreements on the second part tho. Kid's contribution against Meme is a fair shout
 
#17
Lvp is killer all he did was damage kaido. Kidd at least forced BM and kaido apart with repel and had law let Zoro be hit would have been a key part in taking care of BM early. Killer really didn't do much. In terms of importance to the rooftop
1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Law
4. Kidd
5. Killer
 
#18
Gibson Slam didn't do anything tbh



Killer and Law's attacks look like they hurt him

No disagreements on the second part tho. Kid's contribution against Meme is a fair shout
Why are you lying right in front of the manga panel? Kaido had the same scream from Kidd's attack he had with Gamaknife. And the next panel telling us they all are using abilities that doesn't attack him on surface level.
 
#19
Why are you lying right in front of the manga panel? Kaido had the same scream from Kidd's attack he had with Gamaknife. And the next panel telling us they all are using abilities that doesn't attack him on surface level.
I'm not fluent in Japanese, but the English translation I've seen was simply plural. Could've simply been referring to Law and Luffy. And unless Kidd has AdCoA, a slam is nothing beyond surface level, while Luffy and Law's attacks are

The panels are there for anyone to see. If you think Kaido reacts the same to Gibson Slam, as he does to Law and Killer, so be it
 
H

Herrera95

#20
Top