Status
Not open for further replies.

Dragomir

The Towniest Townie!
.
krogo was jailed and hawks would be roleblocked, so all I did was swapping the only other non-confirmed townie with the most likely scum target
Krogo actually wasn't jailed. Tris forgot to send in her action. Whispering her role to a non-confirmed player in the game, forgetting to turn in her action, smh. @Tris you're gonna have to put that clownshoes tag back on.

All jokes aside, this was an interesting game to watch. Overall, I was very much disappointed with what I saw from Town this game. All that claiming was nuts. @Gambit you could have very easily pushed for Tobi's lynch without counterclaiming LO. His claim was already suspect enough. That should have been the last resort in case the wagon wasn't gaining any traction. @Zara revealing that you were the Escort was just unnecessary. I get that you were trying to see who between Tris and Queen was blocked but you didn't have to go about it in such an obvious. Besides, there was no need to pressure them so much about it. A Townie would reveal what happened to them at night. If they don't then it just means they're scum. Should have kept peep about it and let the phase progress.

Y'all's reads were very iffy. The scum read on Beta made no sense. He did nothing wrong. His reads were also the better out of everyone's but he kept getting ignored. I felt bad a little. And the Mayor lynch...don't think I need to speak of that. Regardless of what happens afterward, it was a bad lynch through and through. Lynching someone when they're asleep especially for the whimsy reasoning provided. Outing the Guardian Angel is not a priority one bit.

Now as for Mafia, mediocre at best to be honest. Everyone of y'all was passive in this game. The proactivity was non-existent. It felt more like you guys were observing the game instead of actually participating in it. It was irking me so bad how Town was ignoring you guys for the majority of the game.

And another thing, please don't believe claims on first sight–talking to you Zara :eyes: especially easy ones like Bodyguard and Sheriff. They're ridiculously easy to fake as scum. Always have a bit of doubt. This is a game of deception. Don't be getting led astray so easily.

Lastly...please for the love of God DO NOT whisper claim. It's retarded and rarely works in the favor of Town. If you're going to have somebody suspicious claim, then make them do it out in the open. There's always the possibility that a Townie has something that will contradict the claim. Having them whisper claim instead reduces that likelihood and leaves one person to be the deciding factor in whether or not the claim is believable or not. That's dumb.

That's my review of this game. I'm not trying to rip you guys apart here but just be constructive and upfront about the reality of the game. I hope you guys don't mind.

I also just realized, this is the first game with no subs which is pretty neat :feelsokeman:

 
Now as for Mafia, mediocre at best to be honest. Everyone of y'all was passive in this game. The proactivity was non-existent. It felt more like you guys were observing the game instead of actually participating in it. It was irking me so bad how Town was ignoring you guys for the majority of the game
You saw how Gambit thought Finalbeta was mafia because of FB's personality
He would suspect I am mafia from day one if I was active
 
Are there any roles that someone can claim that are automatically trustworthy in tos or do we doubt every claim? Also whens the next tos game? Need a third game to finally settle things once and for all. Still a lot of bad blood.
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
.
Are there any roles that someone can claim that are automatically trustworthy in tos or do we doubt every claim? Also whens the next tos game? Need a third game to finally settle things once and for all. Still a lot of bad blood.
The mayor is claimable and verifyable. They reveal mid-day with an announcement.
Post automatically merged:

Oh I said the same thing as Queen
 

Dragomir

The Towniest Townie!
.
Are there any roles that someone can claim that are automatically trustworthy in tos or do we doubt every claim? Also whens the next tos game? Need a third game to finally settle things once and for all. Still a lot of bad blood.
As Queen and Mel said, Mayor is auto trustworthy. Transporter also. It's the easiest one to verify and no scum would ever claim to be the Transporter. Impossible to fake and the real Transporter would out you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top