Status
Not open for further replies.

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
If I were scum, I’d pick a scum mate to argue with me viciously in discord. It’s in a small group so there’s less people to add their own views and break it down but still a sizable population to vouch for myself and another player not being on the same page, should one of us die.
Very informative stuff! Since I’m not scum, I don’t think about what scum would do, so maybe we shouldn’t all be grading by your rubric. We haven’t even started the Discords yet, so bring those carts back and put them behind the horses, not in front of them.
Post automatically merged:

Nah it means pay attention to who a Captain (in Mel’s case that she thinks is scum) picks.

Simple as that
Yes, and don’t pay attention to people you think AREN’T scum in D0, solid plan.
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
If I were scum, I’d pick a scum mate to argue with me viciously in discord. It’s in a small group so there’s less people to add their own views and break it down but still a sizable population to vouch for myself and another player not being on the same page, should one of us die.
Ahh good thing to look out for, that makes sense since we'll be under microscopes in those chats. Maybe bonbon and caty? But iirc they haven't interacted much here.

Also you have a leader in mind as least trustworthy?
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
Ahh good thing to look out for, that makes sense since we'll be under microscopes in those chats. Maybe bonbon and caty? But iirc they haven't interacted much here.

Also you have a leader in mind as least trustworthy?
So you think Captain is scum and picked us for cover? I don’t like how opportunistic this feels, how do we know it’s not the other way around?
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
Very informative stuff! Since I’m not scum, I don’t think about what scum would do, so maybe we shouldn’t all be grading by your rubric. We haven’t even started the Discords yet, so bring those carts back and put them behind the horses, not in front of them.
Post automatically merged:


Yes, and don’t pay attention to people you think AREN’T scum in D0, solid plan.
You are awfully aggressive when I'm just saying "hey, pay attention to the Captains and their picks".

I'd say voters too if anyone has the patience for that.
Ahh good thing to look out for, that makes sense since we'll be under microscopes in those chats. Maybe bonbon and caty? But iirc they haven't interacted much here.

Also you have a leader in mind as least trustworthy?
All of them are in the same category as "I'll trust them when I'm given a reason to"
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
So you think Captain is scum and picked us for cover? I don’t like how opportunistic this feels, how do we know it’s not the other way around?
Nope, I don't think he picked us as cover. I think it's just informer stuff, but since I don't trust him fully I think it's fair to maybe think he had an ulterior motive? I am neutral on Caty atm so just tinfoiling.
 
Very informative stuff! Since I’m not scum, I don’t think about what scum would do, so maybe we shouldn’t all be grading by your rubric. We haven’t even started the Discords yet, so bring those carts back and put them behind the horses, not in front of them.
Post automatically merged:


Yes, and don’t pay attention to people you think AREN’T scum in D0, solid plan.
You've gotten awefully defensive when TAC brought up this scenario bro.

Don't dismiss it entirely.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
You are awfully aggressive when I'm just saying "hey, pay attention to the Captains and their picks".

I'd say voters too if anyone has the patience for that.

All of them are in the same category as "I'll trust them when I'm given a reason to"
Easy to call someone aggressive to deflect from your own efforts to undermine other players just for being chosen as captains and doing what they’re supposed to do. Is this just because you weren’t selected for the honor?
Nope, I don't think he picked us as cover. I think it's just informer stuff, but since I don't trust him fully I think it's fair to maybe think he had an ulterior motive? I am neutral on Caty atm so just tinfoiling.
That’s fair, and I can squint and see what you’re saying, but playing into these TACtics isn’t gonna help any of us.
Post automatically merged:

You've gotten awefully defensive when TAC brought up this scenario bro.

Don't dismiss it entirely.
I didn’t and I’m not, but why are you so eager to defend it?
 
Easy to call someone aggressive to deflect from your own efforts to undermine other players just for being chosen as captains and doing what they’re supposed to do. Is this just because you weren’t selected for the honor?

That’s fair, and I can squint and see what you’re saying, but playing into these TACtics isn’t gonna help any of us.
Post automatically merged:


I didn’t and I’m not, but why are you so eager to defend it?
TAC is one of the captains :few:
 

Melontonin

Blood Manipulation
Easy to call someone aggressive to deflect from your own efforts to undermine other players just for being chosen as captains and doing what they’re supposed to do. Is this just because you weren’t selected for the honor?

That’s fair, and I can squint and see what you’re saying, but playing into these TACtics isn’t gonna help any of us.
Post automatically merged:


I didn’t and I’m not, but why are you so eager to defend it?
TACtics 😂
I am just staying careful and to a certain degree paranoid. Plausible scenario!

And what do you think about BoonBon? You think he's town?
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
Easy to call someone aggressive to deflect from your own efforts to undermine other players just for being chosen as captains and doing what they’re supposed to do. Is this just because you weren’t selected for the honor?
1. Last time we had a system like this, in the weeb game, roughly half of the Student Councilers who could discuss at night were scum.
2. This game is almost definitely Multiball. So thinking scum won't be pushing for their own candidates or that they aren't plotting in PMs is really weird.

There is absolutely zero deflection. You're acting very dismissive of the notion of being skeptical of people who want power and can form their own groups. Which is really, really weird.
 
Easy to call someone aggressive to deflect from your own efforts to undermine other players just for being chosen as captains and doing what they’re supposed to do. Is this just because you weren’t selected for the honor?

That’s fair, and I can squint and see what you’re saying, but playing into these TACtics isn’t gonna help any of us.
Post automatically merged:


I didn’t and I’m not, but why are you so eager to defend it?
First as Nat said TaC was selected.

And I’m no really defending his theory, I’m saying it doesn’t hurt to keep it in mind instead of entirely dismissing it like you’re doing.
 

Zemmi

GodMommie
1. Last time we had a system like this, in the weeb game, roughly half of the Student Councilers who could discuss at night were scum.
2. This game is almost definitely Multiball. So thinking scum won't be pushing for their own candidates or that they aren't plotting in PMs is really weird.

There is absolutely zero deflection. You're acting very dismissive of the notion of being skeptical of people who want power and can form their own groups. Which is really, really weird.
It could be two mafia teams, or it could be one mafia team with a lot of indies.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
TAC is one of the captains :few:
Even more reason for him to cast aspersions on others, this doesn’t do anything to clear him for me.
TACtics 😂
I am just staying careful and to a certain degree paranoid. Plausible scenario!

And what do you think about BoonBon? You think he's town?
I don’t have a lean on him either way because we’re halfway through what amounts to a prequel day phase, that’s why I’m concerned that TAC is already pushing this agenda so hard.
1. Last time we had a system like this, in the weeb game, roughly half of the Student Councilers who could discuss at night were scum.
2. This game is almost definitely Multiball. So thinking scum won't be pushing for their own candidates or that they aren't plotting in PMs is really weird.

There is absolutely zero deflection. You're acting very dismissive of the notion of being skeptical of people who want power and can form their own groups. Which is really, really weird.
This has WAY less impact now that I know you’re one of these captains, you’re either telegraphing your own intentions or giving actual scum in the same position some good ideas. I don’t think any of this is impossible, but getting hung up on it now seems like a poor plan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top