thoughts on setup, I do prefer simple abilities so I do like the abilities here. My favorite role is the Piccolo role. Would agree to make it 3 mafia since 2 indies are already present in the game. I normally can't judge on balancing until I see a playthrough of it.
Even though it is scum favored, town did have a chance to win but would require a lot more effort. Town MVP for me would be Rej for me despite the inactivity. Had good reads, couldn't push it to the end due to scum pushing back onto him. (and beta last I checked)
Tbh, If Tris was town we could have lost. Due to her vote manipulation and Protection
I was actually worried she and Beta could turn the tides the last second
And I am not sure if either Gram or Rej could be blamed for Town defeat. Gram couldn't have known that I had already used my only night Ability so RBing me was pointless and Rej just couldn't start a Bandwagon on Gambit due to the fact that we and Queen and Tris more or less controlled the conversation
The only major mistakes town made were Juliet being shot and Drago's lynch and Mango's gameplay (sorry Mango, but it's true)
It was a Combination of there being like one too many Scum roles and the fact that We played pretty unorthodox for mafia, nobody was able to tell that me Usopp and Gambit and Knight were one team.