Questions & Mysteries Shanks: Snitch dragon or Son of Rocks?

#24
shanks is both. (father Rocks, mother celestial Dragon)
he got taken by roger after the god valley incident and placed safely in west blue, and when he grew up he got taken by roger for the rest of the journey. the government only caught up with him after roger's death only after he made a name for himself as a pirate. he uses that connection to maintain back channels with the government.
 
#26
shanks is both. (father Rocks, mother celestial Dragon)
he got taken by roger after the god valley incident and placed safely in west blue, and when he grew up he got taken by roger for the rest of the journey. the government only caught up with him after roger's death only after he made a name for himself as a pirate. he uses that connection to maintain back channels with the government.
Do you see him betraying Luffy in the future ?
 
#27
Do you see him betraying Luffy in the future ?
i don't see why he would ? i see shanks and luffy meeting, a joyous reunion. and part on good term. then shanks finally confront blackbeard and dies. and the strawhats will end up at god valley (which i believe to be the penultimate before raftel) where they meet an old wounded rocks who wont be an antagonist but an unpleast guide who challenges luffy's resolve to learn the secrets and burdens of the world and .....
went on a bit of a tangent there.
 
#28
Did a theory on the Roger Pirates a long time ago. Can't remember exactly what it was for, but it had to do with Jewelry Bonney, and the Roger Pirates. But anyways, I just remembered something I had brought up in the theory.

A Shank is the part of a ring that holds the Gem in place.

Now that I think about it, Gems are often called "Rocks" in slang terms in reference to Jewelry.

Do what you will with this information.
 
#29
Did a theory on the Roger Pirates a long time ago. Can't remember exactly what it was for, but it had to do with Jewelry Bonney, and the Roger Pirates. But anyways, I just remembered something I had brought up in the theory.

A Shank is the part of a ring that holds the Gem in place.

Now that I think about it, Gems are often called "Rocks" in slang terms in reference to Jewelry.

Do what you will with this information.
for some reason I do think Shanks was there to talk about either Rocks or Jewelry Bonney with Gorosei ....
 
#31
Why Son of Rocks? 🤔

He only got rock like abs but that is it overall
- He is 39, God Valley happened 38 years ago, so Roger might have adopted him at very early age from God Valley
- Recurrent theme of raising an enemy's child
- Xebec was also a normal sized human, much shorter than other yonkos
- WB tells Shanks, "the wound I got from that guy aches whenever I look at you" - here, that guy might be Xebec
 
Last edited:
#32
I think "God Valley" is were they sent Celestial Dragon bastards to live since they couldn't live in Mary Geois. They are the children they fathered with their slaves. Shanks is one of those bastards but he's a special case, while Buggy and the others were bastard children of regular Celestial Dragons, Shanks is Im-sama's son.
 
#34
- He is 39, God Valley happened 38 years ago, so Roger might have adopted him at very early age from God Valley
- Recurrent theme of raising an enemy's child
- Xebec was also a normal sized human, much shorter than other yonkos
- WB tells Shanks, "the wound I got from that guy aches whenever I look at you" - here, that guy might be Xebec
I think Shanks and Buggy are FOR SURE adopted after war ... that should not even be debated

but
while Shanks being Rocks was the original idea of myself :steef:

I still wonder why Shanks said he is from west blue ... I don't think he bore there ... maybe Rocks did ...
Post automatically merged:

Both, he is a failure
 
#35
Xebec to Roger - "Take care of my son Roger. You're the only one I can trust."

Roger to Garp - "Take care of my son Garp. You're the only one I can trust."

So that's where Roger got it from. And then it'll be like father like son.

Shanks to Luffy - "Take care of my son Luffy. You're the only one I can trust."
Luffy to Akainu- "Here's my son, take care of him Akainu. You're the only on........"
Akainu- Dai Funka:absojustice:
 
Top