Speculations So this is Oda's plan for the big finale

#21
This is the best case scenario. If everyone gets the Poneyglyph, everyOne has the chance to go to Raftel which is absurd. Just because your asscannon wasn't true, it doesn't become bad writing. Its just you have poor comprehension skills.
Post automatically merged:


Anyone who says Naruto> One Piece is a loser, will never get laid and won't even be considered as a human.
You are too retarded to even understand my complaint. Sit down kiddo, this is too much for you to handle
 
#25
I don't care if Kidd and Law lose. I just think it's a stupid and forced way to hand BB and Shanks the Poneglyphs on a platter. It's shitty writing. There were more organic ways to do this
Lmao, realize that both Luffy and Law were handed RPs on a platter from Zou (which Kid might have even gotten) and WCIs was stolen, right? The only legitimate one was Wano, where the Yonko was defeated.

Its only fair the remaining Yonko fight and defeat their opponents for rubbings. They still dont know where the 4th one is and they still have to fight with Luffy over One Piece. If you didnt see this shit coming a mile away, thats on you


Edit: whats the more organic way Luby. You talk awfully much about one, lets hear you discuss it.
 
#26
I don't care if Kidd and Law lose. I just think it's a stupid and forced way to hand BB and Shanks the Poneglyphs on a platter. It's shitty writing. There were more organic ways to do this
And those were?
Post automatically merged:

We know that Law and Kidd arent a real threat for Luffy, so why have them as PK rivals? We arent gonna see Luffy fighting them when we already saw them as allies and we know Luffy is superior, personally and military.

Only Shanks and BB are the real threat for them. So even if Shanks, Luffy, Law, Kidd and BB went to search the One Piece, the conclusion would had been the same, Luffy fights BB or Shanks, loses and doesnt have a new Road Ponelygl or Shanks and BB encounters Law and Kidd and the same happens.

Heck, Shanks should already know where all of them are lol, he might even have them and just wants to take Kidd, he is friend to Zou, to the Gyojins, was friend of Oden and maybe already had it. He might just be missing 1 or 2.
 
Last edited:
#27
Nothing stops BB and Shanks from going to WCI and Wano, and casually strolling in and taking Poneglyph rubbings for themselves now that Kaido and Big Mom are out of the picture.

Is that much more exciting for you over them doing battle against Law and Kidd for the rubbings instead?

Fighting for the Poneglyphs is how it should be
At least with this route they are actually getting some kind of challenge for the rubbings, instead of just walking in, spanking a few underlings, and walking out.

Like Blackbeard legit sent two people to WCI and that was enough to plow through their forces and kidnap one of Big Mom's children.

Thats the alternative.
 
Last edited:
#28
Luffy handing all his rubbings over to law and kidd just for them to conveniently hand them over to bb and shanks because those two are the real rivals. Eversthing about that feels forced
He didn't give his rubbings to them. Kidd had Big Mom's one (retcon) and Law gave him Kaido's rubbing.
Law had Zou's one and acquired Kaido's one as well.
Luffy has 3 and he gave none to them.
Law just happened to be there in Zou and both Law and Kidd were in an alliance with Luffy during the raid so they all had the poneglygh that was in Wano.
 
#29
Nothing stops BB and Shanks from going to WCI and Wano, and casually strolling in and taking Poneglyph rubbings for themselves now that Kaido and Big Mom are out of the picture.

Is that much more exciting for you over them doing battle against Law and Kidd for the rubbings instead?

Fighting for the Poneglyphs is how it should be
At least with this route they are actually getting some kind of challenge for the rubbings, instead of just walking in, spanking a few underlings, and walking out.

Like Blackbeard legit sent two people to WCI and that was enough to plow through their forces and kidnap one of Big Mom's children.

Thats the alternative.
Bbp didn't fight anyone bar Cracker
Kuzan had to go all out even
They didn't plow through their forces if they only invaded chocolate Town which had no veterans or top ministers protecting it.

Anyway, Oda conveniently has Shanks at Elbaf...doesn't feel natural
Teach yeah since we know he's opportunist and has been sending his men all over places.

Only Teach is winning his fight and getting RPs
Shanks? Willl be lucky to beat kid and get RPs
If he wins, he won't have RPs...kid might just tear them apart.
He's not winning against Kid.
 
H

Herrera95

#31
The point is Teach plot make sense. He invaded Big Mom territory when she wasn't there and kidnapped Pudding. Probably also got her Poneglyph. So he has at least one and someone who eventually may be able to read and he is going after some more.

Now Shanks... He knows where at least 3 Poneglyphs are. It doesn't seem he ever got the one from Big Mom or Kaido. He probably have the one from Zou and maybe have or at least know how to get the last one.
What he was doing at Elbaf instead of taking the one at WCI? He just got lucky that Kidd ended up facing him.
 
#34
Lmao, realize that both Luffy and Law were handed RPs on a platter from Zou (which Kid might have even gotten) and WCIs was stolen, right? The only legitimate one was Wano, where the Yonko was defeated.

Its only fair the remaining Yonko fight and defeat their opponents for rubbings. They still dont know where the 4th one is and they still have to fight with Luffy over One Piece. If you didnt see this shit coming a mile away, thats on you


Edit: whats the more organic way Luby. You talk awfully much about one, lets hear you discuss it.
You don't get his point at all, it's a complain from a narrative and story construction pov.

They're getting the RP for free basically, because the plot needs, that lazy writing.

It's not about them being fair or moralistic.

It's about Oda taking the most easy and bring way to get them on the Pirate King race.
 
#37
Both Kidd and Law losing their Poneglyph rubbings the second they set sail from Wano to BB and Shanks.
Honestly that's weak as fuck writing and feels so forced. Oda has to somehow let Shanks and BB be in the mix for the One PIece and this is how he chose to do it. So disappointing and predictable. SMH this is Naruto level writing
It does remind me of like 2014 naruto writing. Like kidd being an actual pirate worth 3 billion when he hasn't proven to be able to beat anybody reminds me of when Kishimoto tried to convince me that Itachi was a great guy.
 
#38
You don't get his point at all, it's a complain from a narrative and story construction pov.

They're getting the RP for free basically, because the plot needs, that lazy writing.

It's not about them being fair or moralistic.

It's about Oda taking the most easy and bring way to get them on the Pirate King race.
Okay, do it better. You complain how its lazy, give me an example of better writing, without breaking the rules/constraints Oda has placed on the story.

Go ahead, im waiting
 
#39
Okay, do it better. You complain how its lazy, give me an example of better writing, without breaking the rules/constraints Oda has placed on the story.

Go ahead, im waiting
So you can only criticize something if you can do it better?

A food critic is not always a better a chef than the person he is judging, but he can review what is given to him.

As the writer oda can write any plot convenience he wants to make the story works, he just choose a easy one.
 
#40
So you can only criticize something if you can do it better?

A food critic is not always a better a chef than the person he is judging, but he can review what is given to him.

As the writer oda can write any plot convenience he wants to make the story works, he just choose a easy one.
anyone can write about food, it doesnt make them a food critic.
Post automatically merged:

Also, what a novel concept: In a series all about pirates, we have them stealing treasure maps from one another.
people complain that its about pirates and nobody acts like a pirate.

then the pirates act like pirates and they complain.
 
Top