Speculations Strawhat Commanders group title

[Human D Luffy]

Luffy and zoro the great monster duo (G2)
Jinbe and sanji the lesser monster duo (L2)

I like your classification.
At the same time, I have no problem including jimbei as the new monster trio.
Jimbei is very underrated imo. @TheKnightOfTheSea

To even consider adding Sanji to the trio, Sanji would need to show feats equal to what jimbei did (temporarily tanking akainu's magma fist and fighting BM 1 v 1 on Sunny).

 

[Tejas]

Luffy
Zoro Sanji Usopp
Franky Jinbe Brook Chopper
Girls

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

I like your classification.
At the same time, I have no problem including jimbei as the new monster trio.
Jimbei is very underrated imo. @TheKnightOfTheSea

To even consider adding Sanji to the trio, Sanji would need to show feats equal to what jimbei did (temporarily tanking akainu's magma fist and fighting BM 1 v 1 on Sunny).

Jinbe's very underappreciated, both featwise and as a character. He's definitely top 5 SH's eos by strength.

I still think Sanji's the third strongest Straw Hat, only because his name literally is 3. If Sanji doesn't get a big fight this arc, yeah he's not top 3.

I think by the end of Wano we'll have a Monster Quintet: Condom, Mosshead, Taxi, Mentally ill Cosplayer and Jinbe. Yamato and Zoro will team up a lot, Jinbe and Sanji will work together often and Luffy will mostly do his own thing.

I think Luffy, Zoro and Sanji will be highlighted as the three strongest, but Yamato and Jinbe will still get acknowledged as monsters on-par with them.

Or Luffy and Zoro will form a Monster Duo while Sanji, Jinbe and Yamato form the new Monster Trio.

 

[Human D Luffy]

Jinbe's very underappreciated, both featwise and as a character. He's definitely top 5 SH's eos by strength.

I still think Sanji's the third strongest Straw Hat, only because his name literally is 3. If Sanji doesn't get a big fight this arc, yeah he's not top 3.

I think by the end of Wano we'll have a Monster Quintet: Condom, Mosshead, Taxi, Mentally ill Cosplayer and Jinbe. Yamato and Zoro will team up a lot, Jinbe and Sanji will work together often and Luffy will mostly do his own thing.

I think Luffy, Zoro and Sanji will be highlighted as the three strongest, but Yamato and Jinbe will still get acknowledged as monsters on-par with them.

Or Luffy and Zoro will form a Monster Duo while Sanji, Jinbe and Yamato form the new Monster Trio.

IMO Sanji would have to at least beat Queen in Wano to be on Jimbei's level.
Hard to compare Queen against Jimbei, but solely based on both of their fights against BM, Jimbei > Queen feat-wise.
Do I want Sanji to get stronger? Yes.
Do I think he will beat at least Queen? Not sure.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

IMO Sanji would have to at least beat Queen in Wano to be on Jimbei's level.

Most likely. Sanji deserves a W.

Hard to compare Queen against Jimbei, but solely based on both of their fights against BM, Jimbei > Queen feat-wise.

I still kind of want Jinbe vs Queen, it would be a cool sumo fight.

Do I want Sanji to get stronger? Yes.
Do I think he will beat at least Queen? Not sure.

I'm sure Sanji will fight either King or Queen.

 

[chacharealsmooth]

Most likely. Sanji deserves a W.



I still kind of want Jinbe vs Queen, it would be a cool sumo fight.



I'm sure Sanji will fight either King or Queen.

Remember that Apoo and Drake are also there. Why would Oda let Sanji fight a calamity instead of highlighting SNs, who are and always will be much much stronger than Sanji. I think BM’s crew is setting foot to island soon and Sanji is gonna have his hands full with the genie.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

IMO Sanji would have to at least beat Queen in Wano to be on Jimbei's level.
Hard to compare Queen against Jimbei, but solely based on both of their fights against BM, Jimbei > Queen feat-wise.
Do I want Sanji to get stronger? Yes.
Do I think he will beat at least Queen? Not sure.

No offense but beating any Calamity puts him above Jinbe. Jinbe isn’t even winning against Who’s Who right now.

 

[Sigran101]

“Monster Trio” and any variations thereof have always been non-canon terms used in the fandom, not the offices of Shueisha. Luffy doesn’t care for the artifice, and while I buy the theory that each Straw Hat Pirate will either officially or unofficially lead a division of the Grand Fleet (expansion of the same pending) in the near future and merit that kind of designation, it’s never gonna be something he recognizes. Until Oda decides to announce titles for the big guns through info boxes/dumping, I think this is a moot issue

Yeah, Luffy definitely won't name them something, but Big News Morgan might.

 

[uyuu]

Luffy is Monkey King, so the commanders can be called Zodiacs?

 

[Salah WG]

Luffy resembles Shanks & Roger Crew, not Kaido's & BM's
So Zoro will become Vice Captain imo, Sanji will be seen as Chief of Staff & Yamato will be the New Fighter if she joins

 

[Sigran101]

Luffy is Monkey King, so the commanders can be called Zodiacs?

That would be super cool!

Luffy resembles Shanks & Roger Crew, not Kaido's & BM's
So Zoro will become Vice Captain imo, Sanji will be seen as Chief of Staff & Yamato will be the New Fighter if she joins

I feel like with the fleet it's almost more like Whitebeard or Blackbeard.

 

[duckman]

2 lines 400 chapters ago. I don't think that stuck enough to count.

How many times are the"Sweet 3" or "Calamities" referenced by that name explicitly

 

[Marimo_420]

The monster Quartet- Luffy, Zoro, Yamato, and Jinbe.

The vets- Franky, Brook, and Robin

The fodders- the rest.

 

[Finalbeta]

Monster Duo: Luffy and Zoro
High Trio: Yamato if joining, Sanji, Jinbe
Mid Trio: Robin, Franky, Brook
Low Quartet: Carrot if joining, Usopp, Nami, Chopper

This is my most likely bet.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

How many times are the"Sweet 3" or "Calamities" referenced by that name explicitly

Calamities isn’t even their title. It’s Lead Performers. They’re just informally named that.

 

[T.D.A]

So after Wano, Luffy will most likely be solidified as a Yonko. Assuming that's the case, do you think his "commanders", presumably Zoro, Sanji, Jinbei, and potentially Yamato if she joins, will get a group moniker like the sweet commanders, the calamities, or the Titanic captains? If so, what could that title be?

@Kishido : The Monster Trio + Jinbei

:cheers:

 

[Jodie]

Luffy - Captain
Zoro - Vice Captain like Beckman

New Monster Trio - Sanji Yamato Jinbei

Coward Trio - Nami Usopp Chopper

Others - Robin Franky Brook

 

[Salah WG]

I feel like with the fleet it's almost more like Whitebeard or Blackbeard.

Shanks have a Fleet too

 

[Cinera]

Jinbe's very underappreciated, both featwise and as a character. He's definitely top 5 SH's eos by strength.

I still think Sanji's the third strongest Straw Hat, only because his name literally is 3. If Sanji doesn't get a big fight this arc, yeah he's not top 3.

I think by the end of Wano we'll have a Monster Quintet: Condom, Mosshead, Taxi, Mentally ill Cosplayer and Jinbe. Yamato and Zoro will team up a lot, Jinbe and Sanji will work together often and Luffy will mostly do his own thing.

I think Luffy, Zoro and Sanji will be highlighted as the three strongest, but Yamato and Jinbe will still get acknowledged as monsters on-par with them.

Or Luffy and Zoro will form a Monster Duo while Sanji, Jinbe and Yamato form the new Monster Trio.

• I find it hard to imagine Sanji being stronger than Yamato given that she will be fighting Kaido, and Sanji seems set up to face Queen.
• I also think Jimbe is max around Jack level given that his opponent is a Tobi Roppo. If Jimbe mid diffs Who's Who, I might elevate him to Queen level.

I feel like with the fleet it's almost more like Whitebeard or Blackbeard.

Eh, I don't think so. The Strawhats aren't the commanders of the fleet. Luffy's Grand Fleet already has its own commanders. The core Strawhats will remain aboard the Thousand Sunny, and the Grand Fleet will do its own thing. The Grand Fleet are a bit like Whitebeard's allied captains IMO. They will come when Luffy calls, but they otherwise don't operate with the Strawhat Pirates.

 

[Kishido]

@Kishido : The Monster Trio + Jinbei

:cheers:

Monster Trio without Jinbe