General & Others The Ace novel is nonsense. Oda directly contradicts the Ace novel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#41
Ace novel clueless author tells us the Charlotte family is the strongest



Oda tells us the Monkey D. Family is the strongest



Ace novel also tells us Whitebeard has the highest number of underlings amongst the Yonko with 1600 in his crew and 10 000 with the allied captains

While Oda tells us Kaido has 30 000 underlings in Onigashima ALONE. This doesn't include his allied captains which Law confirmed he does have back in Dressrosa + also his subordinates protecting islands such as SCOTCH

Ace novel = non canon and mostly manga copy pasta.

The entire section on WB is a copy pasta of Buggy's speech
"Closest to the OP"
"Only one who could rival Roger"
"No one can beat him now"
Your evidence is literally a fan art caption. I think a fan art caption ranks farrr below a novel in terms of what we're intended to believe. And there's context as well. The Monkey D. Family are not a unit like the Big Mom Pirates are.

As for Kaido and the question of numbers, it's simply that Oda and the writer didn't think it through and the numbers were not important until they needed to be. If it is raised, there will be an explanation. Saying it is "nonsense" based on something so trivial as this is in itself nonsense. Not to mention. What is canon or no n canon is not for some weirdo on the internet to decide.
 
#44
Your evidence is literally a fan art caption. I think a fan art caption ranks farrr below a novel in terms of what we're intended to believe. And there's context as well. The Monkey D. Family are not a unit like the Big Mom Pirates are.

As for Kaido and the question of numbers, it's simply that Oda and the writer didn't think it through and the numbers were not important until they needed to be. If it is raised, there will be an explanation. Saying it is "nonsense" based on something so trivial as this is in itself nonsense. Not to mention. What is canon or no n canon is not for some weirdo on the internet to decide.
One is written by Oda, the other isn't
Japan doesn't even use the term "canon", lmao if you were a DB or Gundam fan you'd know that.

The Novel is never said to be "canon", it's just said the author asked Oda questions before writing it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top