@Bogard
PK
1. Roger
2. Whitebeard (yes he is slightly weaker)
3. Garp
Yonko
4. Kaido
5. Big Mom
6. Shanks
7. Blackbeard
8. Mihawk
9. Rayleigh/Sengoku
10. Sengoku/Rayleigh
Admiral
11. Akainu
12. Aokiji
13. Kizaru
14. Fujitora/Ryokugyu/Oden
15. Fujitora/Ryokugyu/Oden
16. Fujitora/Ryokugyu/Oden
Low top tier
17. Luffy
18. Beckman
19. Weevil
20. Sabo
YC1
21. Katakuri/Marco/King
22. Katakuri/Marco/King
23. Katakuri/Marco/King
24. Shiryu
25. Kid
26. Lucky Roo
27. Magellan
Rest are YC2 or below.
We know that WB got his chest scars from Roger, but they were nowhere to be seen after their on-panel clash during the flashback. They didn’t fight while Oden was on Roger’s ship, so this means that WB would have had to have gotten his scars when Roger met WB at that cherry blossom island. They likely had a clash before talking. So in their final fight, WB got scars while Roger apparently didn’t get any permanent damage to his body, and this was a Roger that was a few weeks away from death.