Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

[Ratchet]

Yoho/Ace? Possible scum? Both? It would be nice if the game was just jinri/yoho/ace.

 

[Ratchet]

I like Zemmi too much and would rather lynch Ace. They were planning on using abilities and not post much anyway per their own words

If Jinri is scum I don't know if she would include another mate here though.

 

[Charlie]

Reborn - i don't remember anything being claimed
The Orca - watcher
Charlie - double vp, protecting myself and target, there's more but i haven't claimed that yet
Flower- wishes, jail, kill
Xlaw - invest there was also some invest related passive but i don't remember
Mr. Reloaded - afaik nothing
KWEH - passive that tells people their flavour if they target him, post restriction
Alyssa the Lamb - duel
freckles - tree
Ratchet - afaik nothing
AceMarvel - neighbour + protection, protection from rolecrush
Michelle - night chat
Jan - some positive action
jinri - afaik nothing

There's also refilled. My ability was refilled at night

 

[Charlie]

Yoho/Ace? Possible scum? Both? It would be nice if the game was just jinri/yoho/ace.

I mean, my whole point of town reading ace is that Melkor was already protection role but tbh, i can't know for sure that ace protects people while targetting them with neighbour.

My ability is basically the same thing. I mean protect me and my target, just no neighbour. Technically if it's just neighbour, i can see it being scum. Not really if it's really protective.

 

[Ratchet]

Any of the claims that you think are suspect?

 

[havanaclub]

Hot

 

[Reborn]

Reborn - i don't remember anything being claimed

There's also refilled. My ability was refilled at night

so all I would prefer to share is ali send a refill to charlie. Charlimu can confirm it if he hasn't.

Btw, you switching vote at the end is kind of odd. Why voted jan? Why switch from zem to start another wagon when everyone other than jinri had only one vote?

 

[Reborn]

Forum is lagging. Charlie it was ali aka me now who refilled you.

 

[Reborn]

Both zem and jinri had two votes each and Charlie had one.
Charlie has 2vp.

Charlie switched votes at the last minute from zem and placed it on Jan.

Then we had jinri at 2, zem/Charlie/jan at one each but as Charlie has 2vps so this puts jinri with 2 and jan with 2 but it was zem who got lynched.

Unless @Ratchet have additional vp as well this entire thing doesn't add up. There could be lynch deflection in play here

 

[Reborn]

If ratchet has additional vp then this situation makes sense to some extent

If he doesn't then I believe atleast one of Charlie/jan/jinri or even two amongst these could be scum.

If Charlie is scum then it's likely jan isn't. If Jan is scum then it's likely Charlie isn't.

 

[Ratchet]

If ratchet has additional vp then this situation makes sense to some extent

If he doesn't then I believe atleast one of Charlie/jan/jinri or even two amongst these could be scum.

If Charlie is scum then it's likely jan isn't. If Jan is scum then it's likely Charlie isn't.

I don't, I claimed that start of night. Nothing in my role gives me extra vote power

 

[Charlie]

Btw, you switching vote at the end is kind of odd. Why voted jan? Why switch from zem to start another wagon when everyone other than jinri had only one vote?

Zemmi and jinri had 2 votes for couple hours. Looked as if mafia didn't give a shet. That's why. Desperate attempted, more than anything else.

If refill was yours i have no idea what kind of positive action Jan could have btw. I also have protection from redirection/bus drive, do it's not that

 

[Charlie]

Also again, idk how Zemmi was lynched if he had 1 co on him and Jinri/Jan having 2.

 

[Charlie]

Also I targeted Ekko N1 and found out he has no hidden action.
N2 i was late and I could't have action.

I forgot about this one. For the record this was claimed after Ekko already flipped

 

[Charlie]

Zemmi had roleblock on bottom 3 posters, xlaw wasn't blocked. Any chances of this being slip basically? Xlaw being rolecop i mean

 

[Charlie]

That passive about alignment check he said was that if action failed he gets refund basically.

He also said it's one shot but i guess this could be him lying to make sure he's not blocked.

 

[Ratchet]

Zemmi and jinri had 2 votes for couple hours. Looked as if mafia didn't give a shet. That's why. Desperate attempted, more than anything else.

If refill was yours i have no idea what kind of positive action Jan could have btw. I also have protection from redirection/bus drive, do it's not that

BTW, I do have to ask, why is "looking like mafia don't give a shit" a key hangup for you? I ask because I think it's perfectly plausible that we have very low effort mafia here that are just relying on town infighting and not really pushing anything.

 

[Charlie]

I think that's it when it comes to claims

 

[Ratchet]

Zemmi had roleblock on bottom 3 posters, xlaw wasn't blocked. Any chances of this being slip basically? Xlaw being rolecop i mean

No because she was using that to throw shade and dirt on Xlaw. I mean it's possible of course but it doesn't make much sense to me. Just step back and think about it. If they're scum together, why would Xlaw claim results - it puts his claim and Zemmi's at odds. It could be one big botch job of course but then you have to ask where the town investigatives are and so on.

 

[Charlie]

BTW, I do have to ask, why is "looking like mafia don't give a shit" a key hangup for you? I ask because I think it's perfectly plausible that we have very low effort mafia here that are just relying on town infighting and not really pushing anything.

I like thinking of worst case scenarios tbh

Like, i was thinking maybe Zemmi's hidden action is something like "get sacrificed for some type of mass kill" and that's why they didn't care, but this is too much of doom thinking even for me i think.