Controversial Thoughts on this thread?

[suzaku]

Mihawk>shanks.
Zero changes

 

[HA001]

I've always shared a viewpoint like this, hell we've seen Roger and BM use pistols in the past alongside their sword...as most classic pirates generally should.

Spoiler: Strong World - Chapter 0

Spoiler: Anime version

No idea why the anime gave Garp a sword, pretty cursed to think about it until we remember that all Vice Admirals had to be trained using one alongside haki.

Hey man, that's fair and all but don't keep those good thoughts to yourself just because there are those who will disagree. That mentality can basically be applied to any theory or speculation out there.

Roger has no gun in the manga bar strong world

Roger's beloved blade which oda CONFIRMED IN THE SBS

 

[soheilhazrat]

the guy goes on to say how shanks and roger are swordsmen so eos zoro > anyone not named luffy confirmed

i agree with that take

Daikengo just means great swordsman.
Zoro wants to be the 1 of great swordsman

Zoro is now a MASTER SWORDSMAN his literal role in the crew and rank has changed because of haki not sword skill

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1765085786553336157

https://onepiece.fandom.com/f/p/4400000000003694163

Yes zoro got the upgrade because of haki but still someone can be a better swordsman but weaker overall
Thats why i think roger > mihawk

 

[Cruxroux]

better swordsman but weaker overall

This doesn't fetch you a bounty of 3.6 B

 

[HA001]

i agree with that take

Yes zoro got the upgrade because of haki but still someone can be a better swordsman but weaker overall
Thats why i think roger > mihawk

They can't that doesn't make sense.

If zoro is getting higher swordsman ranks because of haki that means haki is included in being a swordsman

Roger has no overall
Hes a swordsman

 

[soheilhazrat]

This doesn't fetch you a bounty of 3.6 B

You have to look at my posts cause i clearly never said its only swordsmanship

They can't that doesn't make sense.

If zoro is getting higher swordsman ranks because of haki that means haki is included in being a swordsman

Roger has no overall
Hes a swordsman

yup, roger can have better stats on other categories and be stronger

 

[HellBlazer04]

https://x.com/jabulkheir/status/1765431668028932266?s=46

 

[WalnutTax]

Roger has no gun in the manga bar strong world

Roger's beloved blade which oda CONFIRMED IN THE SBS

Of course! The cutlass is his trademark weapon after all and got personified in the latest SBS. I think anytime we see Oda give their characters a different weapon, it's just there for a moment or to do with small section of story. Otherwise we are gonna have people think that Kaido is a sniper after what he did to Oden.

 

[HA001]

You have to look at my posts cause i clearly never said its only swordsmanship

yup, roger can have better stats on other categories and be stronger

He can't.
Hes a swordsman
That's how he fights.

 

[Herrera95]

May i see? Tho this thread is more about people who think Mihawk > Roger
Just cause mihawk is WSS

Mihawk can't be better than Roger just for being WSS because he wasn't WSS during Roger's era unless he won his title by the hands of the previous WSS that was active during Roger's era.

 

[soheilhazrat]

He can't.
Hes a swordsman
That's how he fights.

Da faq so roger cant be faster than mihawk?

 

[Moegara]

This is pointless.

Zoro wants to be the strongest. If Roger, being a kengou, is stronger than a dai kengou, it doesn't change Zoro's actual dream or Mihawk's status: the strongest swordsman, which characters like Roger and Rayleigh are.

It couldn't be more simple or explicit, and this discussion only exists because of agendas.

 

[HA001]

Da faq so roger cant be faster than mihawk?

Based on what

 

[M944]

But Roger love Ace