@Kawaii ur the best jailer in these lands. tell me what to do. give me ur wisdom!
Whisper someone you are the jailor D1
On a serious note though, at this point you gotta take risky plays in my opinion.Not sure I agree with your latest plan but imo killing the new MM is the most important, else theyll just recruit again at night and shrek town with the Reaper.
Reaper at this point would want to kill Unseen and indies so Playa shouldnt be problem rn.
We can always lynch him since hes probably scum and you jail mid leaving them at 2 tonight but then the Assassin would get 2 doubles, and then Hope the Reaper goes after them.