Role Madness Too Many Doctors (Game Thread)

[Hayumi]

If Flower/Ratchet is v/v the amount of time wasted on this interaction is insane

 

[Hayumi]

Literally everyone and their dog want to lynch Ekko. Who are his team mates even.

I mean half the game isn’t really playing. If everyone was super active this would be a more valid comment

 

[Yoho]

🤔

 

[Flower]

I mean half the game isn’t really playing. If everyone was super active this would be a more valid comment

Pretty much everyone has posted by now. None is defending him except maybe Alexis (but that’s not his style as scum anyway, so you can say that Alexis/Ekko aren’t a team).

 

[Flower]

🤔

What are your reads?

 

[MangoSenpai]

Here he argues again that the main issue with my plan is that not everyone will be on board.

Well, it is. Because who decides, why do they decide, how do you decide?

Here he shades my read on Hime.

My friend, that is not shading, that is a thought out argument/ counterargument.

If I said; "your read on hime is so shit, how do you even come to this conclusion"

That would be shading. Ratchet disagrees with your reasoning and explains why he thinks so in an easily intelligible manner.

And here comes the Kingmaker plan which may fix the issue of selecting a target, but the above clearly shows that he considered the main issue with my plan to be that not everyone will be on board. Which isn’t solved by playing Kingmaker either. Another thing is that Ratchet saw a Kingmaker Lynch system being exploited by a scum team in Favs, when Purple Mafia used it to their advantage.

This is incredibly disingenuous, I've laid out multiple times why a kingmaker would be beneficial for town in the grand scheme of things.

It is very clear to me that your case is based on misinterpretations, half-truths and a whole lot of villification

 

[MangoSenpai]

Literally everyone and their dog want to lynch Ekko. Who are his team mates even.

 

[Ratchet]

Literally everyone and their dog want to lynch Ekko. Who are his team mates even.

Let's see if that's the case first. Then let's see how people engage with the wagon. Then draw conclusions. You're jumping the gun. Let me ask you - have you even read why I scum read Ekko? If do, I'd like you to tell me what it is.

 

[Yoho]

What are your reads?

None for now I wanna see who survives the night and who decides to visit who in order to get a better understanding on what im dealing with

 

[Ratchet]

If Flower/Ratchet is v/v the amount of time wasted on this interaction is insane

Not a fan of this drive by comment. Where do you stand on it Hayumi?

 

[Hayumi]

Pretty much everyone has posted by now. None is defending him except maybe Alexis (but that’s not his style as scum anyway, so you can say that Alexis/Ekko aren’t a team).

But also like half the players have under 20 posts. Even assuming there’s his scum mates among the more active ones, do you think if Ekko is scum there would be obvious defense of him at this stage when we have 24+ hours left

 

[Flower]

Well, it is. Because who decides, why do they decide, how do you decide?

…how we decide lynches…via vote…via democracy. And that also makes most people at least go along with the plan…because they get to decide who goes themselves and not the King…they are far more likely to disagree with the target if only a single player decides, which causes chaos and a lot more conflict.

And once again you are using Ratchet as a crutch. My points are valid and you fail to address the main issue.

 

[MangoSenpai]

If Flower/Ratchet is v/v the amount of time wasted on this interaction is insane

I'm sorry but how can you with a straight face tell me this is a Town POV case by Flower?

It's a massive reach held together by a single string of cobweb

 

[Flower]

But also like half the players have under 20 posts. Even assuming there’s his scum mates among the more active ones, do you think if Ekko is scum there would be obvious defense of him at this stage when we have 24+ hours left

Ofc. He‘d also put much more into defending himself if he had an inactive team, too. I don’t see him being teamed with anyone so far which likely just means he‘s Town.

 

[Ratchet]

I do not think Ekko has to be scum. I do think there is a high amount of performative drivel in his posting thus far, which is never a good sign. And that he seemed to come into this thread prepared and ready to push these angles. I also think if hes playing in that way he would be resigned pretty quickly to not lasting too long, so I would be expecting him to tell his mates to either bus or otherwise make sure they look okay. Whether they listen is another matter.

 

[Ratchet]

…how we decide lynches…via vote…via democracy. And that also makes most people at least go along with the plan…because they get to decide who goes themselves and not the King…they are far more likely to disagree with the target if only a single player decides, which causes chaos and a lot more conflict.

And once again you are using Ratchet as a crutch. My points are valid and you fail to address the main issue.

Have modern day politics taught you nothing?

 

[Flower]

While I can see the likes of Ratchet and Mango being teamed with a lot more people given that their wagons gain zero traction whenever proposed.

 

[Ratchet]

I'm sorry but how can you with a straight face tell me this is a Town POV case by Flower?

It's a massive reach held together by a single string of cobweb

It can be. As sad as it is, there's nothing here that she couldn't come out with as town. But for me I think you need to draw the line somewhere, if that's forcing her to make better arguments then so be it.

 

[Hayumi]

Not a fan of this drive by comment. Where do you stand on it Hayumi?

More inclined currently to think you’re v/v honestly, thus the point of my comment

 

[Flower]

Have modern day politics taught you nothing?

Modern day politics literally prove that electing a representative who makes decisions for you is shit because they can do what they want with the power you gave them. If you vote directly for a decision at least you have a bit of control over your own fate.