Role Madness Too Many Doctors (Game Thread)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Flower

Flower

‎
#963
#963
Yoho said:
Wdym out all the doctors literally everyone is a doctor that's the whole premise of the game

The only people who arent doctors unless I misread the opening post is a handful of scums and cause scum team only has one doctor

How is lowering the chances of multiple people visiting the same person flawed

It doesn't give scum free kills which your plan does and it drastically decreases the chance of town on town crime
Click to expand...
My plan literally does the opposite as the scum team is forced to kill the target we choose or they risk not being seen in the Watcher result and getting outed. All of Town except the targets themselves should be seen in the result, after all. So they literally can’t target anyone else.
 
Yoho

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
‎
#965
#965
Flower said:
And how is the Watcher seeing that 5th target, Sherlock? They have a 3x Ninja.

And any scum player worth their salt can predict who Town is gonna target.

Respectfully, dismissed.
Click to expand...
No one is psychic no one knows how others think the odds scum picks out exactly who the townies individually protect is extremely low

The fact you're so against a plan that keeps town safe is highly suspicious If you ask me

And the watcher is on the scum team as far as I can tell town has no watcher we're quite literally all doctors
 
Yoho

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
‎
#976
#976
Flower said:
My plan literally does the opposite as the scum team is forced to kill the target we choose or they risk not being seen in the Watcher result and getting outed. All of Town except the targets themselves should be seen in the result, after all. So they literally can’t target anyone else.
Click to expand...
Yes and if that target is town you're giving scum free kills

My plan lowers both the chance of killing townies and scum just hopping on the wagon

Why would scum waste time targeting someone else if town is doing their job for them

Your plan might work better later when the player base is dwindled down but right now theres to many moving pieces for it to work to its full potential
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#979
#979
Jump to the post for seeing the quotes and give this a read please @Michelle .


Flower said:
The Ratchet scum case:






Here, he argues mostly that the biggest flaw in my plan is that not everyone will be on board. It‘s not a bad argument per se, but continue reading why this is outing actually.

Here he shades my read on Hime. Needless to say Hime won’t be aligned with him if he‘s scum because Ratchet 1) would be more likely to support a scum read on her to distance as scum mates with Hime and 2) it sounds more like he‘s trying to win her favour as opposed to a genuine take. He also ignores the entire premise of why our push on her started, which was Hime arguing on the basis of not knowing that the faction kill is mandatory. She even conceded that my plan makes more sense in that lense thus showing that she understands why we pushed her over this and my read on her also improved a little over this since it really wasn’t in the opening post.

Here he argues again that the main issue with my plan is that not everyone will be on board.

Again Town spewing Hime and shading me when it was long cleared up.

Again with the everyone needs to be on board issue.

Again buddying Hime.




Nothing but shade at Ekko and me.


And here comes the Kingmaker plan which may fix the issue of selecting a target, but the above clearly shows that he considered the main issue with my plan to be that not everyone will be on board. Which isn’t solved by playing Kingmaker either. Another thing is that Ratchet saw a Kingmaker Lynch system being exploited by a scum team in Favs, when Purple Mafia used it to their advantage. Since that Favs came up recently in the Overlord game I‘m sure he remembers that and how it destroyed both Town and the other scum team. It‘s allowing for scum to have needless thread control. Given that he was Town and on the receiving end of that system I don’t think he‘d come up with that as Town here knowing how disastrous it can be when abused by scum. Not to mention he considers himself the best player here and so far hasn’t produced a single direction other than Ekko (who I currently believe is Town). Given the zero amount of defense for Ekko from anyone and the general appetite to lynch him from many sides I currently don’t believe he‘s scum since he seems alone in the thread. I can’t reasonably find team mates for him either atm. So this direction seems awful from my current pov.

Welcome to my Ted talk.
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top